DANIEL ROBERT MAZURTHE ARCHITECTURE OF BELIEFShop the books ↗

Seeking Change

Documented correspondence – annotated edition

Seeking Change

A documented correspondence about apology, evidence, accountability, pastoral responsibility, and family estrangement
60 of 60 entries

Written correspondence – June 2024 to July 2025

In June 2024, while preparing to travel to Syracuse for my niece's wedding, I learned that Pastor Bryan Rocine had publicly invited people he believed he had harmed to contact him so that he could apologize.

After years of unresolved questions about my family, my father's church, and Bryan's own words and decisions, I understood that invitation as an opportunity to ask what he believed he had done, what he was prepared to acknowledge, and what meaningful accountability might require.

I chose to communicate in writing. The issues reached across decades and involved disputed memories, earlier correspondence, family estrangement, public statements, religious authority, and serious questions about what people within the church knew or believed. Writing gave both of us time to respond and created a record of what was said.

The exchange began with a question about apology. It soon became a wider disagreement about evidence, forgiveness, accountability, compassion, institutional loyalty, pastoral authority, public correction, and the difference between acknowledging pain and accepting responsibility for causing it.

This page preserves that exchange and examines it in detail.

Editorial note

The correspondence is presented in the participants’ own words. Titles, summaries, and commentary provide context and interpretation; they do not replace the messages themselves. They are separate from the original correspondence.

The commentary distinguishes among what a message directly says, Dan's interpretation, Bryan's acknowledgment or denial, what remains unanswered, what submitted evidence can establish, and what another reader might reasonably understand differently.

Some consecutive messages are grouped because they develop one continuous argument. Grouped messages are presented in full.

This correspondence contains serious disputed claims. Its existence establishes what each participant said and how each responded. It does not independently prove every historical allegation within it.

How to read this record

60 editorial units across eight parts. Open an entry to read the original correspondence first, then the commentary and evidence notes. Search includes closed entries. “Original only” hides commentary and evidence assessments; source and content notices remain visible.

Original correspondence includes participants’ accusations and interpretations. Charged descriptions belong to their speakers; they are not findings of this edition.

Closing synthesis · Right of reply · Sources and corrections

Part One – The public invitation and the first test

The exchange begins with a challenge to Bryan's public invitation and quickly becomes a dispute over what a meaningful apology must name.

01
The public invitation put to the test
Dan – June 22, 2024
+

Dan questions whether Bryan's public invitation represents genuine accountability or a performance of accessibility and repentance.

Opening positionMotive questionedAccountability
Original correspondence

June 22, 2024

Dan: Why would a man publicly announce his availability for anyone to contact him? What is the true message here? Is it genuinely for those who may wish to reach out to him, or is it merely a performance for the world to perceive him as accessible and accountable?
If this person sincerely believes he has unjustly harmed others, should he not already know who these individuals are and take the initiative to reach out to them directly?
Imagine a scenario where someone spends thirty-six years meticulously documenting the ways in which he and others have been harmed by this man, compiling these details into a manuscript and placing it before him. Such an effort far exceeds any public declaration of willingness to accept calls from those wronged, ostensibly to discuss and make amends. Yet, this manuscript would be ignored, and any attempt to bring it to light would be vehemently suppressed and attacked.
What does this say about such a person? He has constructed a world that he and others inhabit, a realm he will defend at all costs. He is a consummate salesman, perpetually presenting his pitch to anyone at his doorstep. Until his final days, he will fabricate stories to preserve the comforts he has created for himself.
This is not a man of integrity, honor, or character to be admired. He is someone from whom people need to protect themselves, lest they fall victim to his deceitful machinations.

What the message says

Dan questions whether Bryan's public invitation represents genuine accountability or a performance of accessibility and repentance.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The opening is not neutral. It begins with questions but ends with conclusions about Bryan's character and motive. Dan is testing Bryan's invitation against years of unresolved experience and has already concluded that the invitation may be more concerned with appearing accountable than confronting particular harm.

The intensity communicates accumulated distrust, but it also places Bryan in a defensive position before he has answered. Later discussion of Bryan's guardedness should be read alongside this opening. A hostile presentation can make dialogue harder without making the underlying grievance false.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Did Bryan have particular people or actions in mind?
  • Had he already contacted people he believed he harmed?
  • Had he read or considered the manuscript?
  • What did he believe accountability required beyond making himself available?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
A reader sympathetic to Bryan may see this as a verdict delivered before the conversation begins. Dan's view is that a neutral opening would conceal the seriousness of what he believed Bryan needed to confront.
02
An apology, a counter-forgiveness, and a boundary
Bryan – June 24, 2024
+

Bryan requests forgiveness, says he forgives Dan as well, and warns that communication may not continue because he considers the opening caustic and cynical.

ApologyMutual blameBoundaryTone
Original correspondence

June 24, 2024

Bryan: Is this Daniel? What do you prefer to be called? Dan? Danny? Daniel?
Please forgive me for the unnecessary, unhelpful pain I have caused you. I forgive you for the same.
Judging by the caustic and cynical position of your text we may not be able to continue with any communication.

What the message says

Bryan requests forgiveness, says he forgives Dan as well, and warns that communication may not continue because he considers the opening caustic and cynical.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Bryan acknowledges causing unnecessary and unhelpful pain but does not yet identify what he did. That omission becomes the immediate subject of the correspondence.

The reciprocal forgiveness establishes equivalence before either person identifies the relevant acts. To Dan, this makes the apology feel conditional or self-protective. The objection to tone may be a legitimate boundary, but it may also redirect attention from the complaint toward its presentation.

What it answers or contributes
  • Acknowledges causing pain
  • Signals willingness to apologize
  • Identifies tone as an obstacle
What remains open
  • What did Bryan do?
  • What does he believe Dan did to him?
  • Why are the injuries described as equivalent?
  • What action, if any, is he prepared to take beyond asking forgiveness?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may have intended an initial peace offering rather than a complete confession, believing mutual forgiveness was necessary before productive conversation could begin.
03
What, specifically, is being forgiven?
Dan – June 24, 2024
+

Dan challenges an apology paired with criticism, then reconsiders and asks Bryan to identify the conduct for which he seeks forgiveness.

SpecificitySelf-correctionMeaning of forgiveness
Original correspondence

June 24, 2024

Dan: To seek my forgiveness and, in the same breath, label my message as caustic and cynical, does not reflect the actions of an honest or sincere individual. Have you ever considered that true contrition and criticism cannot coexist in a single plea for forgiveness? True repentance demands humility and self-reflection, not judgment and reproach.

June 24, 2024

Dan: But perhaps, upon further reflection, I am mistaken, and your message is sincere. I have been wrong before, many times in fact. If you genuinely seek my forgiveness, it is a request I am bound by duty and conscience to consider. Please tell me, what is it that you believe you have done to me for which you seek forgiveness? Without this clarity, I find myself without even the option to offer forgiveness. How can I say I forgive you without knowing what I am forgiving you for?

What the message says

Dan challenges an apology paired with criticism, then reconsiders and asks Bryan to identify the conduct for which he seeks forgiveness.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Dan first argues that contrition and criticism should not share the same plea. He then pauses, allows that he may have misjudged Bryan, and asks the direct question that structures the next phase: What are you asking me to forgive?

This moves the exchange from character judgment toward identifiable conduct. Dan is not rejecting forgiveness; he is arguing that forgiveness without an object risks becoming ceremonial rather than accountable.

What it answers or contributes
  • Defines the standard Dan will apply to later apologies: the conduct must be named
What remains open
  • Does Bryan accept that standard?
  • Is apology a general relational gesture or acknowledgment of specific wrongdoing?
  • Must mutual forgiveness precede factual agreement or follow it?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
A person can sincerely regret causing pain without remembering or accepting every disputed event. Dan's answer is that such regret does not establish accountability unless the person identifies what he owns.
04
The conduct Dan wants named
Dan – June 24, 2024
+

Dan identifies possible subjects of Bryan's apology: failing to help him as a teenager, judging him through others' accounts, describing him as rebellious or hostile to God, and declining opportunities to understand his life directly.

Specific allegationsPastoral responsibilityEarlier correspondence
Original correspondence

June 24, 2024

Dan: Bryan, I ask you once more: what is it you wish me to forgive you for? What have you done that you regret, that you acknowledge has caused me harm? Are you sorry for rejecting my pleas for help when I sought your assistance in reaching out to my father years ago, unlike other pastors who showed compassion and tried to help? Are you sorry for judging me and labeling me as a rebellious son without ever having a conversation with me about my life and my relationship with my father, relying solely on the biased views of others? Are you sorry for ignoring my request to visit me and understand my perspective through the lens of those who have known me for decades here in Miami? What is it that you want my forgiveness for? Is it any of this?
How can you know what has caused me harm if you do not ask or tell me what you seek forgiveness for? What have you done? Why wouldn’t you first acknowledge your wrongdoing? What meaning could “forgiving you” possibly have without knowing what for? Maybe you don’t feel there’s anything wrong with the actions I’ve mentioned that harmed me. If this is the case, and I simply say “I forgive you,” would that not be entirely incoherent and meaningless? If you never tell me what you’ve done wrong, how can I believe that it is forgiveness you seek and not something else entirely?
In our past correspondence, I asked you many questions, most of which you refused to answer, choosing instead to disparage me. No other pastor in Syracuse treated me with the same distance and disdain as you did, claiming to know my thoughts, even going so far as to say “God is my arch enemy.” How is it that so many years have passed, and you have yet to address these wrongs? Are you different today? Do you now acknowledge that your behavior was wrong and regret it? How am I to know? Why is this so difficult for you?

What the message says

Dan identifies possible subjects of Bryan's apology: failing to help him as a teenager, judging him through others' accounts, describing him as rebellious or hostile to God, and declining opportunities to understand his life directly.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is the first list of identifiable actions. Dan presents a theory of pastoral failure: judgments were formed without sufficient inquiry, relying upon other people's accounts, and opportunities to test those judgments were declined.

The message expands accountability beyond what Bryan said to how he came to believe it and whether a pastoral role created a greater duty to investigate before judging.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Is any of this conduct part of Bryan's apology?
  • Does Bryan reject the earlier judgments or only regret their expression?
  • Did his leadership role create a heightened duty to investigate?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan could acknowledge that he sincerely believed an incomplete account and later recognize that his certainty or harshness caused harm without admitting deliberate malice.
05
Who had the responsibility to ask?
Dan – June 24, 2024
+

Dan asks whether Bryan sought to understand the circumstances surrounding his psychiatric institutionalization rather than interpreting him through spiritual or character judgments.

Mental healthAssumptionsPastoral dutyEvidence
Original correspondence

June 24, 2024

Dan: What do you truly know of me, of my life? You know I was committed to a mental institution, but do you understand the circumstances? Instead of judging me as a reprobate and a God-hater, did you ever think to ask me? Did you ever consider that you might have been contributing to the damage inflicted upon me? Maybe you have, and this is what you’re asking my forgiveness for. How can you not understand how meaningless it is to ask for forgiveness without stating what for? You are a pastor, someone who is supposed to study these matters for the benefit of others.
Take this as criticism if you must, but I simply do not understand your behavior. As a leader, with many eyes on you, the responsibility of your position is immense. Should you not put every fiber of your being into getting these things right? And as a leader, should you not focus more on your own actions rather than defending your wrongdoings by pointing out that others have wronged you too?
Where is the wisdom I longed to see for decades that would have had me by my father’s side, a member of your congregation? Your position demands a higher standard, one that requires introspection and accountability. It is time to reflect on your actions and genuinely seek to understand the impact they have had on others, especially those who looked to you for guidance and support.

What the message says

Dan asks whether Bryan sought to understand the circumstances surrounding his psychiatric institutionalization rather than interpreting him through spiritual or character judgments.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The deeper issue becomes what one person may responsibly claim to know about another. Dan argues that Bryan treated an explanation as settled before hearing the person being explained.

Because Bryan held pastoral authority, Dan argues that his interpretations carried influence and therefore required greater care, evidence, and willingness to revise.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • What did Bryan actually know?
  • What sources informed him?
  • Did he ever ask Dan for his account?
  • Does he still stand behind the earlier judgments?
  • Does he accept that those judgments may have caused added harm?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may have believed he was responding to the information and theological categories available at the time. That could explain the conduct without settling whether the judgments were responsible.
06
Police, the FBI, and a request for disclosure
Dan – June 24, 2024
+

Dan asks whether Bryan knew about or participated in reports that led police to search his home and the FBI to investigate him.

Factual inquiryPoliceFBIDisputed allegation
Original correspondence

June 24, 2024

Dan: When the police came to my door, claiming my father told them I was building a bomb to blow up the church, did you have a hand in that? Is it too much to ask for you to tell me the truth? This occurred around the same time you wrote to me, insisting our correspondence was confidential while subtly threatening me not to disclose your comments to others. The people I know here, when told of such events, say you all are nuts, that you all are crazy people and I need to stay away from you. Why don’t you provide evidence to the contrary? What do you know about the police searching my home for a bomb or the FBI investigating me? When I’ve asked you for similar information before, your response was simply to attack my character. Should I expect differently today? Or have you changed? Will you be forthcoming? Is any of this what you seek my forgiveness for?

What the message says

Dan asks whether Bryan knew about or participated in reports that led police to search his home and the FBI to investigate him.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is one of the most serious factual questions in the exchange. It contains both a direct request for information and an inference based partly on timing and prior interactions.

The correspondence establishes that Dan asked. It does not independently establish Bryan's involvement. A later denial answers Bryan's claimed personal role but does not identify who initiated the investigation or what others knew.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Did Bryan make or assist with a report?
  • Did he know police searched Dan's home?
  • Did he know of an FBI investigation?
  • Did he discuss Dan with anyone connected to those events?
  • What did confidentiality mean in earlier correspondence?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
A precise annotation must distinguish Dan's account, Dan's suspicion, Bryan's later denial, and the still-unresolved origin of the investigation.
07
Private forgiveness or public repair?
Dan – June 24, 2024
+

Dan argues that forgiveness is insufficient if damaging statements were made publicly or institutionally and continue affecting family relationships.

Public correctionRepairFamily estrangementAccountability
Original correspondence

June 24, 2024

Dan: This matter transcends forgiveness and enters the realm of accountability, embodying the true essence of taking responsibility for past wrongs. As a pastor, it is your duty to address the injustices perpetrated against me from the very pulpit of your church. Perhaps you are unaware, but to this day, I remain estranged from my brother David. I was deeply upset when he stood before the congregation, misrepresenting my thoughts and praising you all, claiming I saw the “good” in you and how “perfect” the memorial service was. I never said such things. In fact, I had confided in him about the immense challenge it was for me to stay calm in an environment that severely tested my well-being.
I had hoped that the days of being disparaged and lied about from the pulpit, as my father did, had ended with his passing. Yet, when I expressed my distress to my brother, he showed no inclination to make amends. If you have truly changed, you should understand that seeking forgiveness is not enough. The matter must be addressed and corrected. The congregation needs to hear the truth about the past—about who I am, who I was, and what I did not say or do.
I have already taken steps to set the record straight in my book, where I speak the truth for anyone who cares to seek it. If you are a true seeker of truth, you will understand the importance of these matters and will ensure that the falsehoods spoken about me from your pulpit are corrected from that same pulpit. Yet, at this very moment, I have no idea if these are the matters you regret your participation in. As all this transpired, you stood there, hands folded by my father’s side. Who are you today, Mr. Rocine? Are you the same man who stood silent, or have you become someone who will confront the past and embrace the truth?

What the message says

Dan argues that forgiveness is insufficient if damaging statements were made publicly or institutionally and continue affecting family relationships.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message distinguishes forgiveness, acknowledgment, correction, and repair. Dan's logic is that a private apology cannot correct an allegedly public narrative because the audience's understanding remains unchanged.

The principle is coherent, but its application depends on disputed facts: what was said, who said it, who heard it, whether Bryan endorsed it, and how it affected present relationships.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • What was actually said publicly?
  • Who said it and how often?
  • Was Bryan present or did he endorse it?
  • Does he now have authority to correct it?
  • Is there evidence connecting those statements to current estrangement?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may regard the family estrangement as private family business that cannot fairly be assigned to the church. Dan believes the church supplied the moral framework through which separation was understood.
08
Integrity made into the test
Dan – June 24, 2024
+

Dan asks Bryan to demonstrate that truth and justice matter more than personal comfort, institutional loyalty, or a desired outcome.

Character challengeTruthJusticeEscalation
Original correspondence

June 24, 2024

Dan: So tell me that I am wrong, that my belief in your lack of integrity has been misplaced. Assure me that doing what is right is indeed paramount to you, even when it doesn’t align with your desired outcome. Tell me that my understanding of your true nature, of who you really are, has been mistaken all these years. Proclaim that you believe in justice and truth above all, and that personal wants and desires play no part in your decision-making process, especially in matters that affect those harmed by the organization you are part of. Show me that you stand for what is right, regardless of the cost. Demonstrate to me, and to everyone who doubts, that you embody the principles you preach, and that truth and justice guide your every action.

What the message says

Dan asks Bryan to demonstrate that truth and justice matter more than personal comfort, institutional loyalty, or a desired outcome.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message raises the stakes from particular actions to Bryan's character. It creates a difficult test in which agreement may be treated as integrity while denial, qualification, silence, or objection may be treated as avoidance.

The challenge is not necessarily illegitimate, but its structure must be visible: who gets to define what a truthful response would look like?

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Can Bryan disagree with Dan's interpretation without the disagreement becoming evidence of failed integrity?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Dan sees this as a test Bryan created by inviting contact. Bryan may see it as requiring him to prove integrity by accepting Dan's account of disputed history.
09
The record offered as evidence
Dan – June 24-25, 2024
+

Dan says the church's account was distorted, offers a video and supporting material, and asks Bryan to face consequences rather than retreat after acknowledging wrongdoing.

Evidence offeredNarrativeVideoPublic account
Original correspondence

June 24, 2024

Dan: The narrative of my experience with your church has been purposefully contorted and contrived to suit the needs of others. You have all misunderstood me profoundly. It is for these reasons that I published my book. Additionally, I have created a short video—a slide presentation—that you and others in your congregation need to see. It is something you should willingly present to your group to set the record straight.

June 25, 2024

Dan: Your integrity is under scrutiny. Having confessed to wrongdoing, you must face the consequences with courage, not retreat. Your role as a leader, an influencer, and a pastor demands accountability and unwavering transparency.

What the message says

Dan says the church's account was distorted, offers a video and supporting material, and asks Bryan to face consequences rather than retreat after acknowledging wrongdoing.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is the transition from accusation toward potentially reviewable material. The link should be presented as supporting evidence with a neutral description of what Dan says it demonstrates.

The page should not tell readers that the material proves every claim before they view it. The correspondence shows it was sent; whether Bryan opened or evaluated it is not established in the immediate response.

What it answers or contributes
  • Identifies specific material Dan wants reviewed
What remains open
  • Did Bryan watch the video?
  • Did he review the manuscript or other evidence?
  • Did he accept that a public narrative existed?
  • What consequences did Dan expect to follow?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The material should be separated into an evidence card with source, date, purpose, and limits.
10
A specific apology followed by denial
Bryan – June 25, 2024
+

Bryan offers his first specific apologies while disputing Dan's account of the FBI, public statements, church gossip, and the degree to which Dan occupied the community's attention.

Specific apologyDenialScope disputedTurning point
Original correspondence

June 25, 2024

Bryan: Thanks for your explanation. Somethings are becoming clear to me.
Please forgive me for not being a greater help to you when you were a teen when I was trying to be a good influence on the teens in the church. Shame on me I gave up on you. Please forgive me for the harshness of my emails to you some years ago.
Here’s what I am realizing. You don’t have an accurate picture of what is going on in our church community regarding yourself. No one I know sicked the FBI on you. I had nothing to do with it. Id be shocked to learn your dad did. He was very quiet about you.
There has been next to zero public statements about you. I recall very brief and uncritical, 40 years ago like, “My son asked me to stay home from church for him. I couldn’t do that. “. (I summarize.)
I have never that I remember preached a single word about you knowingly or intentionally. The church is very quiet and respectful about what we consider Mazur family business. We don’t gossip about you. We hardly think about you.
I hardly ever talk about you to anyone. And hardly ever for more than a sentence . Most of any talk is in prayer. You are not a bigger topic or a preoccupation around here than anyone else.
My texts take a long time to come back to you because I have many other people to prioritize ahead of you.

What the message says

Bryan offers his first specific apologies while disputing Dan's account of the FBI, public statements, church gossip, and the degree to which Dan occupied the community's attention.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is the first substantial answer and should not be described simply as accountability or evasion. Bryan names two matters he regrets: giving up on Dan as a teenager and the harshness of older emails.

At the same time, he limits responsibility by rejecting the larger account in which the church persistently discussed, mischaracterized, or acted against Dan. The message creates a lasting distinction between what Bryan personally owns and what Dan believes institutional responsibility requires.

What it answers or contributes
  • Failure to help during adolescence acknowledged
  • Harshness of earlier emails acknowledged
  • Personal FBI involvement denied
  • Bryan states his recollection of public discussion
What remains open
  • Does Bryan retract the underlying judgments or only their tone?
  • Did he review the offered evidence?
  • What exactly was said from the pulpit?
  • Does he believe public correction is warranted?
  • What did reciprocal forgiveness refer to?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
A reader sympathetic to Bryan may see a responsible effort to own what he can verify while refusing allegations he believes inaccurate. Dan sees a partial apology that stops before the larger history.

Part Two – Competing accounts of the past

Bryan's first specific apology narrows responsibility. Dan argues that the larger history – evidence, public statements, family consequences, and inherited judgments – remains unaddressed.

11
What the apology does not reach
Dan – June 25, 2024
+

Dan welcomes the specific apology but says his principal concerns involve later judgments, public statements, family estrangement, and refusal to engage evidence.

Partial acknowledgmentScope of apologyLater conductUnresolved history
Original correspondence

June 25, 2024

Dan: This message feels like the beginning of a meaningful dialogue, and for that, I am deeply grateful. As I reflect on the past, I harbor no resentment for any perceived lack of encouragement during my teenage years. My greater concern lies with the events that have transpired in the years that followed.
I’m unsure if you’ve read my book, but it contains crucial information that sheds light on my comments. For instance, shortly after I moved to South Florida, the FBI came knocking on my door. This was a direct consequence of my father’s actions—something you might not have known. Considering everything else that has transpired, this shouldn’t come as a shock, though it’s possible you were unaware.
You mentioned there have been “zero” public statements about me. This is not true. I have received copies of several statements embedded in the sermons of the organization you now head. I’ll share one of them with you here; it’s an audio recording from the pulpit. I would appreciate your thoughts on this message made within your church and whether you believe such a comment should be addressed or corrected. My father has claimed, and even insisted to me and others, that he has not discouraged my siblings or anyone from having a relationship with me. This is an outright lie, one of many manipulations I can prove have existed, and as a person in your position, you have a responsibility to address it. This is one of many circumstances occurring long after my teenage years that I ask you to respond to and address.
You claim not to gossip about me, yet you have written extremely harsh criticisms of my character. From where your conclusions about me originate, I can only speculate. These comments, a few of which I have already addressed in this thread, are very damaging and have compounded other false claims and attacks that have caused significant harm, not just to me, but to others as well. It’s these criticisms of yours, not anything from my teenage years, that I want you to address.
I also want to remind you of the time I invited you to Miami to meet people who know me, rather than relying on the damaging comments of others. Instead of accepting or even responding to my sincere offer, you accused me of being obsessed with you and justifying myself to you. These examples of your behavior are what concern me and deserve a proper response.
There is much more to discuss, but addressing these points would be a good start.

What the message says

Dan welcomes the specific apology but says his principal concerns involve later judgments, public statements, family estrangement, and refusal to engage evidence.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Dan does not call Bryan's apology false. He says it addresses a comparatively limited part of a much larger history. The disagreement becomes one of scope.

Bryan appears to define responsibility through conduct he personally remembers. Dan asks him to examine sources of judgment, church influence, the father's role, later statements, and continuing family consequences.

What it answers or contributes
  • Acknowledges that Bryan has finally named specific wrongdoing
  • Clarifies that teenage failure is not Dan's central grievance
What remains open
  • Will Bryan review the evidence?
  • Will he address later judgments?
  • Does responsibility extend beyond direct personal conduct to accepted or repeated institutional narratives?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may be appropriately limiting responsibility to conduct he can honestly own. Dan believes that boundary is too narrow for a leader who inherited authority within the institution.
12
The recording offered as a test of memory
Dan – June 25, 2024
+

Dan supplies an audio link after disputing Bryan's claim that almost no public statements were made about him.

Supporting materialAudio evidencePublic statementsVerification
Original correspondence
What the message says

Dan supplies an audio link after disputing Bryan's claim that almost no public statements were made about him.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This moves the dispute from memory toward reviewable evidence. The page should identify the recording, speaker, date, setting, excerpt, and full context rather than show a bare URL.

Two questions must remain separate: whether the recording contains the attributed statement, and what that statement means in context or requires by way of correction.

What it answers or contributes
  • Provides a potentially verifiable source
What remains open
  • Did Bryan listen?
  • Did he accept that it referred to Dan?
  • Did the full context alter its meaning?
  • Did he believe correction was required?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Use a status label such as: Response status – no direct response to the recording appears immediately afterward.
13
The narrative and the continuing family divide
Dan – June 25, 2024
+

Dan argues that a distorted account of his departure remains active and continues contributing to estrangement from his brother David.

Family estrangementContinuing consequencesNarrativeRepair
Original correspondence

June 25, 2024

Dan: You need to understand that the entire narrative surrounding my departure from my family and your church has been a gross manipulation and complete mischaracterization of the truth. I urge you to watch the video clip I sent you, if you haven’t already. It accurately represents what truly happened, unlike the false narrative constructed for you and the church members to believe. This narrative was crafted to fit a misleading image of who I am and how I should be perceived.

June 25, 2024

Dan: This false narrative endures, continuing to fuel the rift between me and family members, especially my brother David. It has become an impenetrable wall that must be torn down. Only by confronting and dismantling these misconceptions can healing begin and genuine reconciliation be found.

What the message says

Dan argues that a distorted account of his departure remains active and continues contributing to estrangement from his brother David.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The messages move from historical acknowledgment to present consequence. Dan argues that what others came to believe still shapes who will speak with him and whether reconciliation is possible.

The causal claim is important but not fully established by the correspondence. Family estrangement may reflect church narratives, the father's influence, later communications, individual choices, and years of separation.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Did church teaching influence David?
  • Does Bryan have authority or opportunity to help?
  • Would family reconciliation require a public correction?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may see the rift as private family history. Dan sees the church as the background authority that made the separation morally intelligible.
14
Bryan and the father: a distinction Dan still makes
Dan – June 25, 2024
+

Dan says he has not personally observed Bryan lying, while asking him to confront what Dan describes as his father's pervasive dishonesty.

DistinctionFather's influenceGood and harmInstitutional inheritance
Original correspondence

June 25, 2024

Dan: Before I continue with my workday, I’d like to share one more point for you to ponder. It concerns the contrasting perspectives I hold of you and my father. Throughout our communications, I have never questioned your honesty. I’ve never caught you in a lie or observed any intentional deceit. Perhaps you truly believed, at least at the time, the negative sentiments you expressed about me. I cannot say with certainty whether you are a dishonest person, but dishonesty is not something I have witnessed from you.
However, it’s crucial to recognize that my father possessed a deeply troubling characteristic. He was not just dishonest; he engaged in deceit far beyond simple dishonesty. Simply stated, as painful as it is to say this about one’s own father, my dad was not an honest man. He was capable of crafting and spreading the most untruthful stories to achieve his desires. Whether you have discovered or acknowledged this yet, you eventually need to contemplate this harsh reality. If you are ever to move forward in situations like mine and others, with a godly purpose aligned with the teachings of the Bible, you will eventually need to cross this bridge. You will need to face this most uncomfortable truth, as I have, about who my father truly was.
Did he believe in many good things? Was he a great contributor to the well-being of others? Certainly, he was. However, this characteristic you may identify as a sin had dire consequences. No matter how much good anyone does, it is vital to address such deficiencies to prevent further damaging consequences. In the end, it is not merely our actions that define us, but our willingness to confront the uncomfortable truths about those we love and ourselves. Only then can we strive for true integrity and redemption.

What the message says

Dan says he has not personally observed Bryan lying, while asking him to confront what Dan describes as his father's pervasive dishonesty.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This message is more nuanced than the surrounding accusations. Dan distinguishes deliberate deception, attributed to his father, from sincerely held but harmful judgment, which he allows may describe Bryan.

It creates a possible route toward accountability that does not require Bryan to confess malice: he could say he believed an incomplete account and later recognize the harm of that belief.

What it answers or contributes
  • Acknowledges the father's good works
  • Avoids treating Bryan and the father as identical
What remains open
  • Will Bryan reconsider the moral inheritance he received from the founding pastor?
  • Which claims about the father are documented and which remain Dan's assessment?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The commentary must identify categorical claims about the deceased father as Dan's conclusions unless specific supporting evidence is displayed.
15
The day he would not stay
Dan – June 26, 2024
+

Dan responds to the remembered claim that he asked his father to stay home from church, saying he asked only for recognition of a serious crisis and the possibility of being late.

Competing memoryFather and sonPublic retellingContext
Original correspondence

June 26, 2024

Dan: It’s 12:45 AM. I usually wake at 2 AM every weekday morning to begin my day. But not this morning. What you wrote to me yesterday, about my father telling you I asked him to stay home from church for me, has kept me up all night, unable to sleep. So, as I have often done when dwelling on poignant moments of my past, I turn to my pen.
The moment I read your message, I knew exactly which day you were referring to. Your message from my father—whether you recall his words clearly, partially, or exactly as he said them—brought back memories I cannot shake. I remember that day vividly, as it was during a formative time in my youth. I was going through a crisis, the specifics of which blur among many, but the significance of that moment stands out starkly.
The crisis was as severe as when I needed to speak with my father about being molested by someone in my younger years who I had just learned was coming to town and would be visiting my family. Despite my distress and the gravity of the situation, my father refused to even be late for church to address my crisis. That response shifted my concern from the crisis itself to a more devastating, ongoing issue between me and my father.
No, I did not ask my father to forfeit his presence at church that day to be with me. My request was simply for him to understand the gravity of my situation and the worth of a moment with me, even if it meant risking being late for one of his meetings. Whether he misrepresented that day to you, or if you are absolutely certain he told you I expected him to forfeit his church attendance, then he certainly did. And if he did, that encapsulates the problem between us.

What the message says

Dan responds to the remembered claim that he asked his father to stay home from church, saying he asked only for recognition of a serious crisis and the possibility of being late.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

A small wording difference reorganizes the moral meaning. One version presents a son demanding that a pastor abandon duty; the other presents a child in crisis asking his father to pause and help.

Dan uses the event to show how context can disappear and a request for care can become a moral lesson about the person asking.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • What exact words did the father use?
  • How precisely did Bryan remember them?
  • Was the statement public?
  • Did Bryan repeat it beyond the exchange?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may have inherited a stripped-down account without knowing the crisis behind it. Dan's argument is that leaders should ask before forming conclusions.
16
How a personal failure became a sermon
Dan – June 26, 2024
+

Dan offers a second example in which he says his father transformed an event from Dan's life into a sermon serving a substantially different moral narrative.

Story shapingSermonPersonal historyInstitutional narrative
Original correspondence

June 26, 2024

Dan: During my youth, any significant event in my life was often altered by my father to fit a narrative that suited his interests. For instance, in my book, I recounted a story about a fight I got into with a school kid. The entire incident was my doing, my fault, and I needed to be admonished and to learn a lesson about the wrong I did. However, when I approached my father to explain what happened, despite my extreme efforts to be truthful and represent what truly happened, he would not hear it. He turned the story entirely around and made it part of his sermon the following Friday evening, about how Christians need to defend themselves when attacked by sinners.
This is just one anecdote representing my lifelong struggle to communicate with a father who not only would not hear me but was willing to present me to others in an untruthful way that suited his narrative. He molded every significant moment to fit his interests, to serve the purpose of his church and other ambitions, many of which I believed then, and today are very good, but not worthy of the many deceptive means I observed his accomplishments achieved by.
What truly concerns me, what haunts me in the quiet hours of the night, is not merely the events themselves but the chasm they created between us. A chasm built on misrepresentation and a lack of understanding that has left me, even decades later, grappling with the lifetime of silence between us that he enforced and ensured until his dying days.

What the message says

Dan offers a second example in which he says his father transformed an event from Dan's life into a sermon serving a substantially different moral narrative.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Dan describes a process in which an event occurs, the person involved tries to explain it, authority declines to hear the account, and the event is retold publicly through a preferred framework.

The concern is not merely embarrassment but appropriation: the experience becomes raw material for a lesson the authority already wants to teach.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Is there a recording or sermon record?
  • How would other witnesses remember the event?
  • Did the father intend to recount Dan's event precisely or speak more generally?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The page should present this as Dan's illustrative recollection, not independently verified fact.

Part Three – Repentance tested in practice

A successful act of welcome briefly creates goodwill. The discussion then turns to whether repentance must lead to investigation, compassion, repair, and institutional action.

17
A practical test of welcome
Dan and Bryan – June 29, 2024
+

Dan asks Bryan to welcome his visiting aunt. Bryan acknowledges the request, and Dan later reports that she felt welcomed.

Practical requestCooperationWelcomePresent conduct
Original correspondence

June 29, 2024

Dan: I wanted to let you know that my aunt will be at the church tomorrow. I feel very strongly that a warm hello from you would be very well received. Rest assured, I will ensure there are no concerns about any difficulties from me.

June 29, 2024

Bryan: Nice of you to give a “heads up.” Thanks.

What the message says

Dan asks Bryan to welcome his visiting aunt. Bryan acknowledges the request, and Dan later reports that she felt welcomed.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This moves from abstract accusation to a limited, achievable action. It shows that the relationship was not incapable of cooperation and that Dan could acknowledge conduct he regarded as kind.

A warm greeting does not resolve history, but in a relationship defined by distrust, ordinary courtesy can carry unusual significance.

What it answers or contributes
  • Request acknowledged
  • Positive outcome later reported
What remains open
  • None material to this small exchange; the historical dispute remains unresolved
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Some readers may see ordinary courtesy rather than a test of repentance. The page can state both.
18
Goodwill, Isaiah, and a chapter offered
Dan – July 2, 2024
+

Dan thanks Bryan for welcoming his aunt, praises Isaiah, and asks Bryan to forward a chapter explaining Dan's estrangement from the church.

GratitudeIsaiahFamilySupporting materialBelief
Original correspondence

July 2, 2024

Good morning, Bryan,
I want to express my heartfelt gratitude for making my aunt feel welcomed at the church. Despite her initial reservations, she deeply appreciated attending the Sunday morning service. A particularly significant moment for her was reconnecting with an old acquaintance and coworker from General Motors. Despite a past rift, he approached her with open arms, genuinely happy to see her. This was just one of several similar positive experiences she encountered.
For me, this experience illuminated the inherent goodness in others. Your son, Isaiah, especially stood out. I had the pleasure of spending time with him at the wedding and after the Sunday sermon. Isaiah was approachable and engaging, and our conversation left me eager to learn more about him and your family.
Interestingly, Isaiah knew very little about me, including the fact that I have published a book. This lack of awareness was surprising, especially considering I discovered yesterday that even my own niece, Natalie, was unaware of it. It seems that those I spoke with were not particularly interested in learning more about me, which was unexpected given my deep curiosity about them. This realization was both informative and eye-opening.
During our conversation, Isaiah asked why I am not a Christian. Given our shared background and exposure to the Living Word Church, I found it difficult to provide a concise answer in the moment. Interestingly, it was my nephew, Davie, a close friend of Isaiah, who told him everything he knew about me. The only thing he knew was simply that I am an atheist. I found it intriguing that this was what came to mind when asked about who I was. Additionally, my nephew had confided in me that intimate relationships with non-Christians, people like me, were not possible for him. This revelation was profoundly impactful and is crucial to understanding my perspective.
In retrospect, I believe a chapter from my book encapsulates my reasons for not being involved in your church and why my beliefs have diverged from those in attendance. This chapter delves into the theme of family and the potential for positive relationships between people of differing beliefs. It explores how these relationships, once full of promise, were shattered by stringent dogma that, in my view, needed to be more flexible to keep good people together instead of apart. This rigid adherence to unyielding doctrines, I believe, undermines the possibility of unity and mutual respect among individuals with diverse perspectives. The chapter seeks to convey the profound impact of these dynamics on my own journey and relationships.
If Isaiah is interested in knowing more about me and my perspective, could you kindly provide him with the following link to this chapter?
https://drive.datadupe.com/f/6d9983bda451435781ab/
Once again, thank you for greeting my aunt and making her feel welcome on Sunday morning. Your kindness did not go unnoticed.

What the message says

Dan thanks Bryan for welcoming his aunt, praises Isaiah, and asks Bryan to forward a chapter explaining Dan's estrangement from the church.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message begins in gratitude and turns toward identity. Dan is troubled that people may know him mainly through the label atheist rather than through his own account.

The request asks Bryan to act as intermediary. It introduces the later question whether Bryan should decide if Isaiah receives the material or whether Isaiah should decide for himself.

What it answers or contributes
  • Acknowledges kindness
  • Introduces Isaiah as a distinct relationship
  • Offers material intended to broaden the available account
What remains open
  • Was the chapter forwarded?
  • Did Isaiah want it?
  • What boundary exists between a father's judgment and an adult son's autonomy?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The request may be reasonable or intrusive depending on Isaiah's wishes and Bryan's role as intermediary.
19
Repentance must become action
Dan – July 5, 2024
+

Dan applies Bryan's sermon on repentance to interpersonal wrongdoing and proposes a concrete act of reconciliation involving his mother, Mary, and Mary's sister.

RepentanceSermon responseRepairCompassionAction
Original correspondence

July 5, 2024

Dan: Your sermon last Sunday morning, titled “The Power of Repentance,” left a profound impact on me. You began by referencing Mark, where John the Baptist preached repentance for the forgiveness of sins, drawing the entire Judean countryside and the people of Jerusalem to confess their sins. You emphasized the transformative power of repentance, asserting that it can alter the course of one’s life. Repentance, you stressed, offers a pathway to forgiveness, severing the chains of wickedness that bind us to our past and preventing it from dragging us into the depths of despair.
You explained that repentance involves both intellect and emotion, compelling us to feel genuine sorrow for our wrongdoings. This change in attitude moves us away from fault-finding and toward self-reflection. Quoting Jeremiah, you lamented how few people genuinely repent, asking, “What have I done?” You urged us to ask the Lord this crucial question, and to follow it with, “What shall I do?”—a significant step in the process of repentance.
After the sermon, my mother, aunt, Jody, and I dined at The Waterfront Tavern in Central Square, where the sermon became the central topic of our conversation. The emphasis on forgiveness resonated deeply with me, sparking hope for a meaningful dialogue with you. I listened intently to your sermon and engaged in discussion with my family and friend, Jody.
I shared with Jody how my ears perked up when you spoke of repentance and forgiveness. Your repeated call to ask, “What have I done?” and “What shall I do?” filled me with excitement and hope. It struck me that just as we seek forgiveness from God through repentance, we must also seek forgiveness from those we have wronged. This vital aspect seemed missing from the sermon, and I hoped it might appear in your concluding remarks.
When I expressed this to Jody, she responded, “Well, the service is only so long. Brother Bryan can’t fit everything into one sermon.” To which I replied, “Do you mean the message I just shared with you—something you clearly understand—delivered in less than sixty seconds?”
My visit with my family lasted an entire week, from one Wednesday to the next. Though the invitation to my niece’s wedding required fewer days, I chose to stay longer to spend precious time with my aging mother. This extended visit allowed for many moments of deep conversation between us, often centering around the current and past activities of our family and the church, some of which I have already shared with you.
Throughout this past week, my mother has increasingly acknowledged the past wrongdoings of her church, my father, and herself. She has continually sought my forgiveness for her role in these events—transgressions she has confessed and for which I have long forgiven her. Our conversations have revealed her growing understanding of my beliefs, and she often says, “Danny, you’re not an atheist; I just don’t believe it.” To this, I respond, “Mom, today I am; tomorrow I may be something else.”
She insists, “But you believe in God. You must, I can tell.” I reply, “Well, if He exists, where can I find Him—in your church?” This gives her pause, as she has come to realize the extent of the wrongs, deceit, and harmful behavior that have made it impossible for people like me, who have strived to live according to Christian principles, to remain connected not only to the church but also to their own family.
During my visit, I had the opportunity to visit Mary Sorrendino on Monday. As you’re aware, Mary once attended the Living Word Church and even taught Sunday School there for about ten years. I recently read her book, Misery to Ministry, where she recounts a traumatic event she and her sister experienced when they first attended the church.
Mary’s sister was about to deliver a child, but tragically, the baby was stillborn. Not knowing how to handle the situation, Mary called our home to speak with my father, her pastor. My mother answered the phone and told Mary that the church does not handle such matters and that there was nothing they could do. There was no offer of sympathy or mention that the church would pray for her sister and her family.
Furthermore, due to the church’s doctrine against secular counsel, no external support was sought. Mary’s sister, adhering to the church’s teachings, refrained from seeking the necessary help. Consequently, they endured greater and unnecessary suffering, difficulties that could have been mitigated with proper counsel and support.
Considering everything thus far, I intend to send another message to my mother. If she is truly interested in my belief in God, she has the capacity to demonstrate a quality that, if He exists, He would surely possess. I have often stated that while I do not yet know where God is, I do know where He is not.
I would ask my mother to show me that, unlike so much I’ve seen in the past, a member of the Living Word Church has the courage to do what the Bible says and embody the principles you preach. The truth of Mary’s claims and the accuracy of her memories—do these even matter? Do we need a witness? The fact is, Mary and her sister were hurt.
What if my mother found the courage to invite Mary and her sister over for coffee? What if she allowed them to express their pain without judgment? My God, the woman lost her child. Is it too late? Is it ever too late to show love, care, and concern for another? To acknowledge where we have fallen short and ask for forgiveness?
This gesture could be a profound act of healing. It would demonstrate the true essence of repentance and forgiveness, offering a tangible example of living out the principles of compassion and empathy. It would show that faith is not just about belief but about action—about reaching out to those we have wronged and seeking to make amends. This is the God I would believe in, a God reflected in the courageous acts of those who follow Him.
Am I saying this would make me believe in God or in His involvement with your church? Maybe it would, maybe it wouldn’t. But it is in such places, through such actions, that I would continue to observe closely. I am searching, and if I found a place aligned with what I know to be right, I would want to delve deeper, eager to discover what I do not yet know. I recognize truth when I see it, and I am drawn to it.
As I’ve said, I will convey this message to my mother. However, as her pastor, your involvement could significantly impact Mary and her sister and my mother. If you spoke with my mother and facilitated a meeting with Mary and her sister, the gesture would be powerful.
As you’ve preached, the sin that does not lead to death is the sin that is quickly repented of. I will send you a copy of the passage from Mary’s book detailing what happened. It is my hope that you act swiftly upon this opportunity. If not, I will be the one providing my mother and others the chance to benefit from this experience.
This moment could be a testament to the true spirit of repentance and forgiveness, demonstrating that faith is not just about words but about actions. It could bring healing and reconciliation, showing that the church is a place where love and understanding prevail. This is the God I could believe in—a God reflected in the courageous and compassionate acts of His followers.

What the message says

Dan applies Bryan's sermon on repentance to interpersonal wrongdoing and proposes a concrete act of reconciliation involving his mother, Mary, and Mary's sister.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Dan takes Bryan's questions – What have I done? What shall I do? – and turns them into a test of institutional practice. Repentance, in his view, must produce action toward people affected.

The proposed meeting is framed as listening and acknowledgment rather than a tribunal. Yet the request assumes the accuracy of several contested facts and the willingness of all participants to meet.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Did Mary or her sister want Bryan involved?
  • Did Dan's mother want the meeting?
  • Could the conversation occur without assigning blame prematurely?
  • What role should a pastor have in arranging it?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may see Dan as expanding a personal exchange into responsibility for multiple historical grievances. Dan sees a direct opportunity to practice what Bryan preached.
20
A third-party account enters the record
Dan quoting Misery to Ministry – July 5, 2024
+

Dan supplies an extended passage describing pregnancy loss, stillbirth, refusal of counseling, and an allegedly unsympathetic response from the pastor's household.

Supporting documentThird-party accountPregnancy lossCounselingPastoral care
Original correspondence

July 5, 2024

Dan: From “Misery To Ministry”
Bill was coming out to church with Toni. Back in 1977, on Christmas day, Toni had miscarried in the 16th week. I was in England at the time. Toni’s baby would have been 7 months younger than my second son, Jason. It was hard for her, but Toni was taught not to count her chickens before they hatched. So, she just tried to think that it was not a baby and she shouldn’t be upset.
Toni got pregnant shortly after she accepted Christ, and I was excited! I thought, How awesome this is! Eric was one year old and would be two in April; Toni’s baby was due in June 1982. We always thought that we would have our children at the same time or very close in age. Although Jason and Toni’s other baby would have been the same age, I was glad that Eric would be just two years older than this baby.
I planned for the baby shower to be when Toni was in her eighth month. That way if she delivered early the baby should be okay. After having Chuckie six weeks early and Jason ten weeks early, I knew how fragile life is.
We had a surprise baby shower at my home and invited a lot of family members. Everyone was so excited because they felt terrible when Toni lost that other baby in the fourth month in 1977. Bill’s daughter Tami was there and was also excited, because she was going to have a little brother or sister. Tami was 7.5 years old; she was a sensitive little girl.
Tami said to me, “I hope what happened that last time won’t happen again.” I said, “Sweetheart, that won’t happen. She’s almost due….” I went over to the trailer where Toni and Bill lived. Bill had put the crib together, and Toni was very excited. But I thought I heard God say that no baby would sleep in this crib in this house.
About two weeks later I was sitting at the dinner table and I had this overwhelming sense that something was wrong with my sister. I said to my husband, “Oh my God! I feel like something is wrong, like Toni is sick or dying !!!!
Chuck knew how I had had dreams in the past that came true or feelings that had meaning. I immediately called Toni; she was taking a nap, and she was very tired. I asked how the baby was, and she said “Good, but it was weird that the baby kicked really hard earlier.” I said I was just checking on her because I was worried. “Don’t worry, I’m okay, just tired.”
The next day Toni said, “Mary, the baby’s not moving anymore.”
“Well, Toni, there’s not much room for the baby.”
A few days later Toni had an appointment with her OB/GYN, Dr. Ziver Huner. When he went to listen for the heartbeat, there was silence. He immediately asked if she was alone. She said no, Bill had come with her. Then Dr. Huner asked him to come in, and they talked and set up an ultrasound to be done immediately. Toni went for the test and was very confused. As they went down the hall Bill knew what was going on, but Toni was not getting it. She asked Bill, “What are they going to do now to get the heartbeat back?” She said she felt the Lord say that everything would be okay.
She returned to the office and Dr. Huner told her and Bill that their baby had died. Toni was unable to process the information…. He offered counseling. Toni said no, she thought that it was WRONG to meet with a counselor because the church we attended spoke against it, and she wanted to do the right thing. At this church counseling was not recommended, and anyone who did see a counselor was somehow in error.
I was home when Toni and Bill left Dr. Huner’s office. Bill knew that he had to bring Toni to see me. I looked out and saw them getting out of the car, and I KNEW! God said, “I am in control.” I was devastated!!!! Toni was devastated!!!!
I called the pastor’s house. It was a Friday, and being Catholic I wondered what they would do to help us. I was recently baptized and Toni was attending regularly. The preacher’s wife got on the phone. I was very upset and asked if she knew my sister. She said yes, she had seen her in church. I went on and told her that her baby died and that we would need a pastor or something like that for the funeral arrangements. I asked, “What do you do in these situations?” She said, “Nothing. We do nothing.” She never said she was sorry – just “nothing,” like it was no big deal! She didn’t even say they would pray.
I thought, Oh…this church is much different than what I was brought up in. I felt hurt by the lack of care and concern for a family in the church that was experiencing a devastating situation. Although this did not make sense, I thought that God had sent me to this church and we were just expected to lean on God. After their response I thought that I was wrong to expect anything from them. I did not trust my feelings or thoughts, so I assumed that I was wrong for contacting them.
Finally, on June 1, 1982 Toni gave birth to her stillborn daughter, Therea Ann Wood. Toni never went to counseling and therefore was not prepared for the birth. She pretended that she was not going through this. Although she did do some grieving, she never held Theresa. The nurses at Community General Hospital were great. Bill did look at their daughter and said she just looked like she was asleep. She had dark hair, and later Toni found out from the nurse that she had really long eyelashes and she weighed 1 lb. 7 oz. Later in the day Toni asked if she could see the baby now and maybe hold her… but it was too late. If she had counseling she would have been prepared for this and would have known that she could have held the baby.
Toni was traumatized by the event. She worked at a retail store on Erie Boulevard, and many customers asked her if she had a boy or girl. Tini told them she had a little girl but she was stillborn. The customers and her co-workers were wonderful and compassionate to my sister. It was very difficult working in public with so many individuals having contact with Toni.

What the message says

Dan supplies an extended passage describing pregnancy loss, stillbirth, refusal of counseling, and an allegedly unsympathetic response from the pastor's household.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The excerpt introduces a third-party report and asks whether the same institutional patterns affected others. It contains two distinct issues: the response Mary says she received and the effect church teaching may have had on Toni's refusal of counseling.

It is evidence of what Mary remembers and published, not independent proof that every participant remembers the events the same way.

What it answers or contributes
  • Provides a published first-person account that supports Dan's request for compassionate engagement
What remains open
  • What were the exact words spoken?
  • What was the church's counseling position?
  • Why did Toni decline counseling?
  • Did all involved consent to publication and renewed discussion?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Because this is an extended quotation from another author, verify permission to reproduce it; otherwise use a shorter excerpt, summary, and citation.
21
Hearsay, faith, and the limits of investigation
Bryan – July 5, 2024
+

Bryan partly agrees that interpersonal repentance could have been included more fully, but declines to investigate Dan's mother on what he regards as hearsay and redirects the question of belief toward God rather than believers.

Partial concessionHearsayEvidenceTheologyBoundary
Original correspondence

July 5, 2024

Bryan: Hi Dan. Thank you for listening so intently to the message of such an imperfect messenger as I. Your recall is almost perfect.
1. Right or wrong, I did intentionally include the subject of our human relationships and person-to-person sin. I am sure you recall something like this: “Don’t take this message as being for someone on the other side of the aisle. THEY should repent.” I’ll explain. I thought the Lord wanted us to focus on first things first — our relationship with Him. But of course you may be right. Shoulda included our person-to-person relationships as part of an inseparable package. I often operate under the principle “less is more,” sometimes to the detriment of the bigger picture.
2. I don’t know how to satisfy you when it comes to the Toni S story. What your mom did and said is coming to us as hearsay. I know your mom very well, and I’m not about to doubt or investigate her tender and compassionate nature based on hearsay.
3. Re your challenge, that you may believe in God when you find people who live sincerely in obedience to the teaching of Jesus… don’t throw down that gauntlet. Judge God on His own merit not on mine or anyone else’s. I fall pathetically short. But He sent His Son to pay the price of our sins. What He did for us is enough to inspire undying faith and loyalty.

What the message says

Bryan partly agrees that interpersonal repentance could have been included more fully, but declines to investigate Dan's mother on what he regards as hearsay and redirects the question of belief toward God rather than believers.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message contains three different responses: a genuine concession about the sermon, an evidentiary objection, and a theological redirection.

Bryan is correct that serious judgments should not be made without adequate evidence. But relying on a favorable view of a person's character is not proof that a painful event did not occur. Inquiry need not begin by assuming guilt; it can begin by hearing all participants.

His theological distinction – God should not be judged solely by imperfect believers – is coherent, but it does not fully answer the institutional question Dan is asking about whether the church's conduct reflects its teaching.

What it answers or contributes
  • Accepts that the sermon might have addressed interpersonal repentance more fully
  • Explains why he will not investigate on the basis presented
  • States that Christian failure should not determine judgment of God
What remains open
  • Would he listen to Mary directly?
  • Could he facilitate compassion without presuming guilt?
  • Did the church discourage secular counseling?
  • What process exists for former members reporting harm?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may be protecting an elderly woman from unsupported accusation and declining recruitment into an unverifiable conflict. Dan sees insider loyalty preventing inquiry.
22
Compassion before proof?
Dan – July 5, 2024
+

Dan argues that his request is not about satisfying him or proving every detail first, but about responding compassionately to people who report harm.

CompassionEvidenceMoral responseVerification
Original correspondence

July 5, 2024

Dan: Thank you for responding, Bryan. I understand your emphasis on personalizing the message, and I recall your mention of it that Sunday morning. However, my concern remains. It is crucial to openly communicate what we need forgiveness for. This has been my message from the beginning and remains so now.
You mentioned, “I don’t know how to satisfy you.” But it’s not about satisfying me; it’s about recognizing the validity of my points, which align with what God requires of us. The truth of the story isn’t as important as the moral implications. When people come to you claiming they’ve been wronged, do you ask for a witness? Isn’t it more important to show compassion and concern, regardless of evidence?
Consider the story of Mary and her sister’s loss. Whether a child truly died or the accuracy of the occurrence isn’t the point; the real issue is how we respond with empathy and support. This experience should teach us to be more compassionate and to encourage others to seek appropriate counseling, whether secular or otherwise. Regardless, as I’ve mentioned, should you not be willing to participate in this opportunity to help my mother, Mary, her sister, and others, I will certainly be the one to do so.

What the message says

Dan argues that his request is not about satisfying him or proving every detail first, but about responding compassionately to people who report harm.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Dan distinguishes determining whether an accusation is true from responding humanely to a person reporting pain. Listening and support do not require an immediate verdict against another person.

His strongest principle is that immediate compassion and careful investigation are compatible. Some wording, however, risks suggesting that facts do not matter, which would conflict with the page's larger emphasis on truth and evidence.

What it answers or contributes
  • Clarifies that empathy need not wait for final adjudication
What remains open
  • What support did Mary and Toni actually want?
  • Could the matter be addressed without imposing a meeting?
  • Was Bryan's refusal based on evidence, boundaries, time, or unwillingness to revisit the past?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
A responsible response could express sorrow, ask what happened, avoid prejudging anyone, and offer support without pretending that the facts are already settled.
23
The repeating pattern of the closed door
Dan – July 6, 2024
+

Dan compares Bryan's reluctance to engage with his father's earlier resistance, accuses both men of protecting control and institutional appearance, and asks Bryan to help reunite people separated through the church's influence.

PatternFather and successorControlReconciliationEscalation
Original correspondence

July 6, 2024

Dan: I awoke this morning with an eerie feeling, one that evokes memories of my conversations with my late father. As I write to you, I am reminded of the profound dialogues we shared. My father, like you, held the position of pastor, and he too struggled with the weight of his responsibilities.
Despite my repeated requests, I still do not know if you have read my book. Your reluctance to engage in open and honest dialogue with me has left me feeling unheard and misunderstood. When I inquired about presenting my offer to your son, your response was absent. When I tried to discuss the disparaging comments you made about me years ago, you closed the door to any meaningful conversation. Your initial response to my first message indicated that a dialogue was unlikely due to my perceived caustic and cynical position. However, it is clear to anyone that I have approached you with sincerity and a genuine desire for understanding.
This situation reminds me of my early mornings with my father. While my siblings were at school and my mother was teaching kindergarten at the Academy, my father would approach me, seeking my opinion on handling sin within the church—an elder molesting his children, members engaging in fornication, and such. Despite offering my thoughts, he often chose to keep such matters hidden to maintain the church’s facade. Yet, these were not the most disturbing conversations; rather, it was those where I implored him to show more compassion and understanding.
Had my father opened his heart and relinquished his need for control, my mother would have been spared decades of separation from loved ones, including her sister and parents. His insistence on isolation and stringent actions to maintain separation from those he deemed capable of diminishing his control of others caused immense damage. Today, my mother’s parents are gone, and she can never amend that loss. However, she has found solace in a renewed relationship with her sister and others, including me, the very person my father stripped away from her in his efforts to control and isolate.
Now, I see the same pattern repeating with you. Your door is closed, and you resist any effort to reunite loving people. Outsiders often describe your church as one devoid of love. This perception stems from the lack of compassion, empathy, wisdom, and understanding. Like my father, who saw himself as a simple small-town preacher, you project yourself as a humble servant of God. Yet, your actions suggest otherwise.
As a pastor, it is your duty, as mandated by the scriptures, to facilitate the coming together of people who have faced life’s challenges. What is required of you, as it was of my father, is simple: step aside and allow the spirit to move.
Please, Pastor Bryan, consider opening your heart and embracing a path of compassion and empathy. Let us work together to reunite those who have been separated, to heal wounds, and to foster a community grounded in love and understanding.

What the message says

Dan compares Bryan's reluctance to engage with his father's earlier resistance, accuses both men of protecting control and institutional appearance, and asks Bryan to help reunite people separated through the church's influence.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is where Dan makes the father-Bryan comparison comprehensive. He argues that even if motives differ, the effects resemble one another: questions remain unanswered, authority defines the permissible conversation, and institutional interests take priority.

The message asks for openness, evidence review, and facilitation of reconciliation. It is weakened when it also states Bryan's inner motives and implies that resistance itself proves lack of compassion.

What it answers or contributes
  • Identifies concrete unanswered matters
  • Articulates a request that Bryan use authority to facilitate rather than prevent reconciliation
What remains open
  • Which actions are Bryan's and which belong to the father?
  • What evidence supports the claimed continuity?
  • What would an appropriate reconciliation process look like?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Dan sees repeated refusal from related positions of authority. Bryan may see an unfair equivalence in which ordinary boundaries are treated as proof of control.
24
Internal oversight is not personal accountability
Bryan – July 6, 2024
+

Bryan says he is accountable to an internal group with authority to discipline or dismiss him, rejects the deeper relationship Dan is seeking, and confirms that he has not read and will not read the book.

Institutional oversightBoundaryRefusalBookAccountability
Original correspondence

July 6, 2024

Bryan: I have accountability to a group of experienced men and women of faith. I am honest with them about my failings and keep them appraised of my actions and communications. They have the power to censure and/or fire me. They decide how to take care of me. I would not want it any other way. You simply are not in a position to be part of that group.
I literally don’t have time, energy, or interest in giving you that kind of relationship with me. In fact, it would be inappropriate and impossible. Cmon, Dan, you should understand that.
Since you are so desperate to know about me and your book, I have not read it. I don’t plan to read it. I really don’t relish telling you this.

What the message says

Bryan says he is accountable to an internal group with authority to discipline or dismiss him, rejects the deeper relationship Dan is seeking, and confirms that he has not read and will not read the book.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is the decisive boundary-setting message of the first arc. Bryan distinguishes internal institutional accountability from the direct relational accountability Dan seeks.

The response clarifies Bryan's position but leaves the process opaque. Internal oversight may be legitimate, yet the correspondence does not show whether outsiders can bring complaints, whether the group reviewed this exchange, or whether it hears affected people.

What it answers or contributes
  • Confirms he has not read the book and does not plan to
  • Rejects the sustained relationship Dan requests
  • States that an internal group can censure or fire him
What remains open
  • Who is in the oversight group?
  • Can outsiders submit complaints?
  • Has the group seen the correspondence?
  • Does internal review substitute for answering the person alleging harm?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
A pastor cannot provide unlimited access or quasi-disciplinary relationships to everyone who contacts him. Dan's objection is that he is not asking to supervise Bryan's life but to receive answers and repair for conduct that affected him.
25
Forgiveness without resolution
Dan – July 6, 2024
+

Dan says he will stop seeking answers, offers forgiveness for past and present wounds, and leaves open the possibility of listening if Bryan later wishes to speak.

ClosureForgivenessWithdrawalOpen door
Original correspondence

July 6, 2024

Dan: Hi Bryan,
Fortunately, you won’t need to fabricate stories to distance yourself from me. I live far away, and you may find solace in knowing that I will no longer seek answers or further discussion from you. Yet, before we part ways, I wish to leave you with a final reflection on the matter that began this thread: forgiveness.
Your recent comments about my supposed obsession with you, echoing past remarks for which you sought forgiveness, and your ongoing reluctance to address my concerns, hint at a lack of understanding or compassion. Despite this, should it matter to you, I forgive you for both the past and present wounds inflicted by your words.
Know this: while empathy and understanding seem absent in your responses, I harbor no resentment or ill feelings toward you. After this message, you will no longer be troubled by my outreach. Despite your disregard for my concerns, my door will always remain open, just as it is with my brother David. Should you ever wish to discuss something that weighs on your mind, I will not judge you for your past or present actions. I will gladly listen, offer my full attention, and do my best to support you in any sincere matter you bring forth.
Life is hard, and we all make mistakes. I have made many and will make many more. But when I recognize them, I strive to address them with compassion, empathy, and understanding, especially when they affect others. Good luck to you, Bryan, and my best wishes for your future endeavors.

What the message says

Dan says he will stop seeking answers, offers forgiveness for past and present wounds, and leaves open the possibility of listening if Bryan later wishes to speak.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message closes the first phase without shared factual agreement, institutional review, public correction, or family repair. Forgiveness is offered without resolution.

It contains both release and indictment. Dan honors Bryan's boundary and says he bears no resentment, while still judging Bryan's empathy, honesty, and willingness to engage.

This mirrors the tension Dan objected to in Bryan's original message: forgiveness is paired with an account of the other person's wrongdoing.

What it answers or contributes
  • Grants the forgiveness Bryan requested
  • States that Dan will stop outreach at that point
  • Leaves a future door open
What remains open
  • No shared account of the past is reached
  • No evidence is jointly evaluated
  • No institutional process is activated
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Dan may understand the message as mercy and closure. Bryan may understand it as a final accusation framed as forgiveness.

Part Four – Related correspondence with Isaiah

This is a distinct, subordinate correspondence about adult autonomy, inherited reputation, leadership, boundaries, and the next generation.

26
The gift and Isaiah's right to decide
Dan – July 13, 2024
+

Dan asks whether Bryan passed along a gift or book material and argues that Isaiah, as an adult, should decide for himself whether to receive it.

GiftAutonomyIsaiahIntermediary
Original correspondence

Narrative note — Dan’s account

Not long later, I corresponded with Bryan’s son Isaiah…

July 13, 2024  Dan: Hi Isaiah,
This is Dan Mazur.
It was wonderful meeting you during my trip to Syracuse for my niece’s wedding, both at the ceremony and later at the Church. Over the past few weeks, I have been in touch with your father and told him about our meeting. I also entrusted him with a gift for you, chosen with great care and heartfelt intentions.
I can’t help but wonder if he might have presumed you wouldn’t like it. However, I believe it should be your choice to accept or reject what I offered.
Has your father mentioned what I left for you?

What the message says

Dan asks whether Bryan passed along a gift or book material and argues that Isaiah, as an adult, should decide for himself whether to receive it.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This begins a distinct correspondence arc. The core issue is adult autonomy: should Bryan filter what reaches Isaiah, or should Isaiah decide whether to engage?

The request also shows how the Bryan dispute extends into the next generation. The page should not assume that Isaiah shares his father's knowledge, responsibility, or authority.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Was the gift delivered?
  • Did Isaiah know about it?
  • Did he want the material?
  • What responsibility, if any, did Bryan have as intermediary?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
This material is best presented on a separate tab or companion page because it concerns a different person and relationship.
27
A friendly beginning
Isaiah and Dan – July 13, 2024
+

Isaiah responds warmly, says he has not seen his father much, promises to ask, and exchanges brief friendly messages with Dan.

Friendly contactDelay explainedGoodwill
Original correspondence

July 13, 2024  Isaiah:  Hi Dan! It was great chatting with you too. I enjoyed getting to know you a little bit.

I haven’t seen my dad really this week. We’ve been a little bit like ships passing in the night, but tomorrow I’ll be at his house and ask him about it. Thank you for thinking of me 🙂

July 13, 2024:  Dan  Hi Isaiah,

Ah, I see you got my message! I wasn’t sure I had the right number. Thank you for following up. I put a lot into what I have for you. Have a great weekend!

July 13, 2024  Isaiah:  You too! Hot and muggy here.

July 13, 2024:  Dan

Miami extends a warm welcome to the club!

July 13, 2024  Isaiah: 😆

What the message says

Isaiah responds warmly, says he has not seen his father much, promises to ask, and exchanges brief friendly messages with Dan.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The initial tone is easy and nonconfrontational. Isaiah does not reject Dan or the gift; he says he will ask his father.

The short weather exchange and emoji belong in the same unit because they demonstrate ordinary human contact before the conversation becomes burdened by the larger history.

What it answers or contributes
  • Isaiah acknowledges the request
  • Promises to ask Bryan
  • Shows openness to direct contact
What remains open
  • Whether he followed up with Bryan
  • Whether the gift reached him
28
The follow-up becomes a test
Dan – July 18-23, 2024
+

Dan follows up several times, then interprets the delay through the history of inherited reputation and the church's account of him.

Follow-upDelayInherited narrativeEscalation
Original correspondence

July 18, 2024:  Dan

Good morning, Isaiah,

When I was in Syracuse, I had the pleasure of meeting you for the first time and several others, including Nila, another member of the church. Nila generously gifted me a book titled “A Tale of Three Kings” by Gene Edwards, which she asked me to read. I just finished it yesterday and am looking forward to discussing it with her on Saturday.

Regarding the gift I left for you with your father, have you received it yet? By the way, have you read “A Tale of Three Kings”? I’m curious to hear your thoughts if you have.

It’s supposed to be hot and rainy here in Miami today. I hope you have a great day in Syracuse.

Dan

July 22, 2024:  Dan

Hey Isaiah, you didn’t forget about me did you?

July 23, 2024:  Dan

Isaiah,

Over the years, I have encountered many members of the Living Word community. Each time, I have tried to engage in meaningful conversations, only to encounter a persistent barrier. It seems that instead of responding to me as the person standing before them, they react to a long-standing reputation that has surrounded me for decades.

In our case, I did not know you back in the early days of the church. We’ve only met twice, and our few text exchanges have been about the weather and a simple request. The prolonged time it is taking to receive a simple confirmation from you regarding my request makes me wonder if you, too, are influenced by my reputation rather than by our actual interactions.

I do not know if this is the case with you or not. I understand there might be various reasons for the lack of communication. Whatever the case, I ask you to consider my difficult position and past experiences that compel me to ponder this possibility. It would be profoundly refreshing to be engaged with based on who I am and how I have treated you, rather than on old rumors and innuendos.

What the message says

Dan follows up several times, then interprets the delay through the history of inherited reputation and the church's account of him.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

What begins as a practical follow-up becomes a moral test of whether Isaiah will relate to Dan directly or through inherited assumptions.

The silence may reflect busyness, uncertainty, family dynamics, discomfort, or avoidance. The correspondence alone does not establish which. Repeated follow-up increases pressure before Isaiah has explained the delay.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Why did Isaiah delay?
  • Had he spoken to Bryan?
  • Did the expanding moral significance make a simple response harder?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The page should distinguish the fact of delay from Dan's interpretation of what it meant.
29
Delay explained; interest expressed
Isaiah – July 24, 2024
+

Isaiah apologizes for the delay, says he wants to engage Dan as he is rather than as described by others, asks for the book link, and asks about Dan's business.

ApologyInterestDirect relationshipBook
Original correspondence

July 24, 2024  Isaiah:

Hi Dan,

Sorry to take so long to reply. One, I’ve been very busy (too busy!) and two, I have been thinking how to respond. In general I’m pretty busy with a lot of my own kids and slow to respond, sorry.

I’m as interested in engaging you as you are rather than how you’ve been.

Can you send me the link to the book you sent to my dad? I’m not sure if he had it or not anymore when I chatted with him. He just said things got frayed between the two of you and so we didn’t really talk about it any further than that it was a link to a book.

I’m interested to hear more about your business. How long have you been doing IT work? And how many employees do you have?

Hope all is well.

What the message says

Isaiah apologizes for the delay, says he wants to engage Dan as he is rather than as described by others, asks for the book link, and asks about Dan's business.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Isaiah directly answers the concern that he might rely only on inherited reputation. He expresses a desire to know Dan through their own contact.

The response should be treated as meaningful evidence of openness, not merely as a promise later broken.

What it answers or contributes
  • Apologizes for delay
  • Requests the book link
  • Asks about Dan's life and business
  • States a preference for direct judgment
What remains open
  • Whether he later read the material
  • What caused the eventual end of communication
30
The book as an appeal to be heard
Dan – July 25, 2024
+

Dan explains his business and family history, why he contacted Bryan, and why he wants Isaiah to hear a chapter and understand the wider story.

BookFamily historyBusinessAppeal to understand
Original correspondence

July 25, 2024:  Dan

Hi Isaiah,
Thank you for getting back to me. I often marvel at how you all manage it. Each of my siblings has children—quite a few, in fact. The responsibility is immense. I frequently wonder how different my life might have been, even with just one child. The picture you sent is wonderful; I’ve always cherished the company of children.
Reflecting on my past, I often consider the compromises one must make to keep a family together. I question whether it’s possible to maintain one’s integrity and live an honest and honorable life while also ensuring there’s food on the table, a roof over your head, and a harmonious family environment.
These reflections often lead me to think about my business. It, too, resembles a family with its many members. Throughout the years, I’ve faced numerous challenges and temptations to breach my integrity, to cheat, to lose faith that hard, ethical work alone will sustain my business family. Yet, somehow, by relinquishing the need to understand every step toward the finish line and focusing instead on the process, I’ve managed to thrive.
This gives me hope and a sense of reassurance. Had I chosen to have a family of my own, I might have been a good father. My journey in business, fraught with ethical challenges and steadfast perseverance, suggests that the values I hold dear could have guided me well in parenthood.
Now, turning to the reason for my letter, it is less personal and more related to matters of faith and leadership. Your father has said on numerous occasions that I am obsessed with him, given that I have written to him repeatedly over the past several decades. The truth is, I reach out to him not out of obsession but because of his influential position—first as an assistant pastor and now as a pastor. My intention in seeking his attention was not to be seen as merely Dan Mazur, but as the founding pastor’s son who holds unique insights and has been involved in numerous interactions shaping the lives of current and past church members.
It is also this person, the founding pastor’s son, that I wish to introduce you to. I hope to provide you with information that could be relevant and beneficial to your life, especially given your significant role and dedication to the church and school. I believe this perspective could offer you a richer context and a deeper connection to the community you so diligently serve.
The link I provided to your father, which I asked to be passed on to you, is the audio recording of chapter 19 of my book, titled “Good Times Together.” In the brief moment we spent together when we first met, we discussed my decision to no longer attend the church. I found myself unable, in that short time, to adequately explain my reasons. Of the fifty chapters in my book, I thought this one, which speaks of the joyous moments of family life and how they ended, would best encapsulate what has kept me away from the church.
What most people are unaware of is that I have been fighting for decades to reunite my family. Whether this endeavor is an imposition of my will on others or a worthy, honorable course to take, it is a road I’ve traveled that is at least worthy of noting and addressing. My entire book charts the course of my life, from childhood to adulthood, from being part of a large loving family to losing that connection, and the subsequent separation of its members. It details my lifelong effort to bring them back together, and myself to them. Whether this journey was the right one or not, it is significant, it happened, and it deserves to be heard.
And this is where my dilemma lies. My story, whether true or perceived as lies, has been brought to the attention of those influential in the organization of your life’s endeavors and occupation, such as your father. Yet, for decades, I have been turned away, my words and concerns never willingly heard or addressed. My own father, the first person I approached with these matters, has refused to hear me. I have even gone to the extremes of contacting pastors in your community for help, who have reached out to my father and others. Yet, they too were told by my father that he would not participate in addressing any of my concerns.
This continuous dismissal has left me in a profound state of isolation and longing, and even more concerned for the many others I’ve observed suffering similar consequences from the same processes. The recording of chapter 19 is not just a recounting of past joys but a testament to my relentless hope and the pain of being unheard. It is a piece of my soul, laid bare, in the hope that someone will understand the depth of my struggle. I am reaching out to you, Isaiah, because I believe in the power of faith, leadership, and empathy. By listening, you might gain a deeper understanding of my journey and inform others, potentially offering a bridge where there has been a chasm.
I do not seek pity or agreement, but acknowledgment. A simple recognition that my efforts, struggles, and truths are worth considering. I believe this perspective, this human story of perseverance and longing for reconciliation, could offer a richer context and a deeper connection to the community you serve.
My mother, whom you of course know, has come to understand and acknowledge a bitter truth about our past. She now realizes that her separation from her parents, her sister, her cousins, me, and many others was never necessary. It was a wrongful determination caused by forces she found herself unwilling to confront, and she regrets this decision of her past to such a degree that I labor to convince her she was not a bad person, not a bad mother. She has told me many times recently, and again during my visit at my niece’s wedding, that she feels she failed us. I reassure her that she was a good mother, but the forces she faced were formidable and overwhelming.
I understand these sentiments may sound foreign to you, perhaps even as an attack against the will of God or the principles of Christianity. But I assure you, it is not. My story, documented in the book, is a chronicle of events with no intent to assign blame. It is simply an account of what has transpired, meant to be reflected upon for any conclusions or judgments one may choose to make.
Today, my failure to have a relationship with my brother David, and consequently with his children and grandchildren, is a poignant example of the undesirable consequences that I see being handed down from one generation to the next. This outcome stems from the concerns I’ve voiced for decades, concerns that have consistently been ignored. These are the same concerns I now bring to you.
I am not trying to convince you that all my choices were correct. Instead, I seek acknowledgment that what has transpired deserves attention. For this reason, I am providing you with the text and audio of my entire book. I hope you will see the value in reading or listening to it. This work, compiled over thirty-six years with careful consideration, aims to address my deepest desires: to reunite broken families.
I trust you will find it within your heart to dedicate a portion of your time to hearing my story and to offer what has been denied to me all my life: an empathetic ear to my concerns for our families and community.

What the message says

Dan explains his business and family history, why he contacted Bryan, and why he wants Isaiah to hear a chapter and understand the wider story.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message gives Isaiah substantial context and treats the book as Dan's record of a life that others may know only through inherited accounts.

It also places a heavy moral and emotional burden on a relatively new relationship. Isaiah is asked not only to learn about Dan but to reconsider his father, grandfather, church, and family structure.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • What portion did Isaiah read or hear?
  • Did he agree to take on a mediating or leadership role?
  • Was the volume of history proportionate to the relationship at that stage?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The appeal is understandable, but Isaiah's adult autonomy includes the right to decide how deeply and how quickly to engage.
31
Leadership and silence
Dan – August 22, 2024
+

Dan argues that Isaiah's position as academy principal gives him responsibilities that silence does not satisfy.

LeadershipSilenceAcademyAccountability
Original correspondence

August 22, 2024:  Dan

Isaiah,
I have taken great care in conveying my deep concerns about the environment in which you now hold a pivotal leadership role—not as a pastor like your father, and as my father once was, but as the principal of the academy closely tied to the church. This role is no less influential, carrying with it immense responsibilities and a profound impact on the community. For many years, I have meticulously reflected on these concerns, investing countless hours in crafting them into detailed writings. After meeting you for the first time at my niece’s wedding, I made a deliberate effort to present these matters to you with even greater clarity.
It has now been a month since I entrusted you with these concerns, and during this time, I have waited patiently for any form of acknowledgment or response. Yet, the silence from your end has been deafening— a silence that, regrettably, has become all too familiar. This silence is not just disheartening; it is profoundly troubling, given the weight of the issues at hand. The position you hold, coupled with your father’s role as pastor, demands far more than silence; it demands a thoughtful and decisive response.
When you choose to reply, I can’t help but wonder: will it be with the same dismissive words I’ve heard before—that I am not a priority—or with the claim that my concerns are mere hearsay, unworthy of serious consideration? Isaiah, I urge you to reconsider the path you’re on. Your moral obligations, rooted in the very Christian faith you profess, compel you to act with integrity and conviction. This is not a matter to be brushed aside; it requires your full attention and a response that genuinely reflects the values you claim to uphold.
In the end, it is our actions—or our inactions—that define us. Whatever you choose to do, or choose not to do, will reveal who you truly are, both to me and to everyone else.

What the message says

Dan argues that Isaiah's position as academy principal gives him responsibilities that silence does not satisfy.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Dan shifts Isaiah from private family member to institutional leader. That role may make certain concerns relevant, especially if they involve the school or present practices.

But holding a leadership title does not automatically make Isaiah responsible for every historical grievance involving previous generations or the church. The page should separate current institutional duties from inherited moral symbolism.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • What current conduct was Isaiah being asked to address?
  • What authority did he have over church history?
  • Did he understand the correspondence as personal, institutional, or both?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Silence may be avoidance, but it may also reflect uncertainty about scope, authority, or appropriate boundaries.
32
The gym encounter and the broken promise
Dan – November 5, 2024
+

Dan describes confronting Isaiah after a basketball game, says Isaiah promised to resume the discussion, and interprets the later silence as repeating the conduct of both fathers.

Public confrontationPromiseSilenceIntergenerational pattern
Original correspondence

November 5th, 2024: Dan

Isaiah,

Five weeks ago, you crossed the gym floor at Liverpool High, coaching your team after their victory over my old high school. You came over, perhaps hoping for a simple greeting, an easy exchange. But I could not meet you halfway. To some, that might seem harsh, even unkind. But the truth runs deeper.

My decision not to approach you wasn’t a matter of indifference; it was an act of integrity. I could not offer a gesture that would deny the reality of what stands between us. If there had been mutual respect in our last exchange, I would have welcomed the chance to reconnect. But you left my words unacknowledged, abandoned the conversation as if it held no weight, choosing silence over engagement. In that choice, you showed thoughtlessness where thoughtfulness was needed most.

Yet there you were, approaching me as though nothing had transpired between us, as though time and silence could erase the past. But I would not join in that pretense, would not gloss over the truth to appease an audience—not even for the comfort of those watching, including my brother Paul. For me, such moments call for honesty, not the empty gestures that soothe observers without ever touching the heart of what is real.

I called out your actions, named them for what they were: cowardly. As my words settled, the crowd shifted, a few hisses and murmurs rippling through them, as though I had spoken out of turn. But I stood firm. “He’s a coach, a leader,” I told them, looking each of them in the eye. “He can handle this.” And to your credit, you remained composed. You listened as I detailed what you had done, why it was wrong, and finally, with others watching, you admitted it: “I owe you one.”

“No, you don’t,” I replied, making it clear that I expected no repayment, only the courage to face what you had done and commit to a better path. And when you suggested that we pick up the conversation where you had left it unfinished, I thought, for a moment, that you might finally be ready to engage with truth. I was leaving town the next day, so we agreed to continue through written exchange—the one you had previously abandoned. For a brief moment, I believed we might rebuild on a foundation of mutual respect. I extended my hand as a gesture of good faith, an invitation to let the past lie if we could rebuild on honesty. You took it.

And yet, here we are again. Your words have proved hollow, your silence resounding. I see in you the same silence I’ve seen in my father, and in yours. Only a few months ago, your father stood before the congregation, pledging to make amends with those he had wronged. He offered his number to anyone seeking reconciliation, an invitation as public as it was bold. But when I reached out, hoping he might engage honestly, might listen and respond to the specific harms he had inflicted—what I found was denial, a swift dismissal, and an abandonment of the conversation. It is the same void you leave me with now.

So I must ask: when your father made that promise, who was he speaking to? And when you, in that gym, approached me with a pretense of humility, who were you really addressing? The answer is painfully clear—you were both speaking to the crowd. Your father wanted his congregation to believe he was a humble, caring pastor. And you wanted those around us, including my brother, to believe you were genuine, ready to face your mistakes. But these gestures are empty. You are not humble, nor are you caring. You wield truth as a tool, bending it to suit your convenience, offering a different face to each audience.

If you genuinely wish to change, if you truly want to set things right, it begins with a simple commitment: live honestly. The message I wanted to share with you, the same message that threads through the book I’ve written, is this—lay down your agenda, relinquish the comfort of appearances, and seek truth above all else. This is not about appearances; it’s about a way of living that could bring healing not only to you but to those around you.

When I called you a coward that day in the gym, it was as much for those watching as it was for you. They needed to witness someone speaking plainly. And now, with my brother Paul aware of your failure to honor your word, the truth of your continued deception is exposed. It’s a hard truth, one that mirrors the same behavior I’ve seen in our fathers—the same behaviors that have torn apart families, fractured communities, and left scars where trust should have been.

This cycle—the same hollow pattern that you, your father, and my father perpetuate—lies at the heart of so much pain. It’s why I remain distant from my brother David, from my sister Pam. It’s why honesty, the one thing that could bridge these gaps, has been left to gather dust, abandoned in favor of hollow facades. And now, this pattern has touched you, taken root, become your way of moving through the world.

This, Isaiah, is what my book is about. It’s what I hoped to discuss with you—not as a reprimand, but as a plea. Choose truth, Isaiah. Embrace it as the foundation for all else. In truth, there is freedom, there is healing, and there is the possibility of real connection. Break the cycle that has haunted our families. Let honesty be the path that leads us forward, away from the shadows of pretense and toward something real.

What the message says

Dan describes confronting Isaiah after a basketball game, says Isaiah promised to resume the discussion, and interprets the later silence as repeating the conduct of both fathers.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The account is important because the contact occurred in Isaiah's professional or community setting rather than by private invitation. Dan sees the encounter as a necessary appeal after silence; Isaiah may have experienced it as pressure in a place where he could not freely engage.

Dan interprets the broken promise through a generational pattern. The fact of no further response is clear; the motive and meaning remain uncertain.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • What exactly did Isaiah promise?
  • How did he experience the public encounter?
  • Why did he later stop responding?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The page should acknowledge Dan's persistence and Isaiah's withdrawal without assigning motive as fact.
33
No further reply
Editorial outcome – After November 5, 2024
+

The page reports that Isaiah did not respond further and blocked future messages.

OutcomeBoundaryNo reply
Original correspondence

Narrative note — Dan’s account

There was no response, only Isaiah blocking any future messages from me. Nearly three months later, I sent Isaiah’s father, Bryan, links to two podcasts where I discussed my books, COR Values and Beyond the Morning Light. His father wrote back.

What the message says

The page reports that Isaiah did not respond further and blocked future messages.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is an outcome, not a message. It should be labeled as an editorial note rather than presented as part of the original correspondence.

The block establishes a clear boundary. It does not by itself explain whether the cause was inherited loyalty, discomfort, pressure, disagreement, advice from others, or a wish to protect professional and family life.

What it answers or contributes
  • Establishes that direct communication ended
What remains open
  • Isaiah's reasons remain unknown unless he chooses to provide them
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Include a direct right of reply for Isaiah and place this correspondence in a companion section so it remains subordinate to the primary Bryan exchange.

Part Five – The exchange reopens

Months later the exchange reopens around unwanted contact, the coattails remark, spiritual healing, earlier character judgments, and Dan's long answer to why he does not believe.

34
Stop, coattails, and conditional contact
Bryan – February 1, 2025
+

Bryan tells Dan to stop, says Dan is not the church's teacher, attributes his limited influence to his father's reputation, asks to be removed from promotional mailings, and leaves a channel open for possible future need.

Stop requestCoattailsBoundaryReligionConditional contact
Original correspondence

February 1, 2025 6:47PM  Bryan: 

Hi Dan, Bryan Rocine here. You should stop. You’re not our teacher. Ironically the only shred of influence you have on a couple people is granted to you because you ride on your father’s coattails.

I love you. I would be very happy to have you as my brother in Christ. He is your Healer.

On the other hand, I always unsubscribe from merchandizers who pester me with ads. Please take me off your mass mailing list.

I really don’t want to block your number because we may need to communicate one day, right?

What the message says

Bryan tells Dan to stop, says Dan is not the church's teacher, attributes his limited influence to his father's reputation, asks to be removed from promotional mailings, and leaves a channel open for possible future need.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message contains three boundaries: against instruction, against promotion, and a partially open personal channel. These should not be collapsed.

The coattails remark evaluates Dan's significance and is understandably experienced as belittling. A narrower reading is that church-connected people notice Dan largely because he is the founder's son, not that his entire adult life depends on his father.

What it answers or contributes
  • Rejects Dan's teaching role
  • Asks not to receive promotional links
  • Keeps a limited channel open
What remains open
  • Who decides which future subjects justify contact?
  • Does the request cover all accountability-related communication or only promotions?
  • What exactly does Bryan mean by coattails?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may be distinguishing unwanted advocacy from necessary family contact. Dan sees control over when communication is permitted.
35
Who decides when the conversation ends?
Dan – February 1, 2025
+

Dan rejects Bryan's authority to determine when he must stop speaking, denies seeking influence, and turns the coattails accusation back toward Bryan.

AuthorityVoiceInfluenceCoattailsBoundary disputed
Original correspondence

February 1, 2025 7:00 PM Dan: Hi Bryan,

Thanks for the clarity. It’s interesting—you say I should stop because I’m not your teacher, yet you seem quick to lecture me on who I am and why my words matter. I don’t recall asking for influence; I only spoke from conviction, something I thought a pastor might respect, even if he disagrees.

As for riding on my father’s coattails—if that’s truly the only reason people listen, maybe that says more about the legacy you’re standing in than about me.

But I appreciate your love. I offer the same in return, though I believe healing starts with honesty and open dialogue, not closing doors. Blocking my number now would just formalize a boundary that’s already been there from the start.

Take care, Bryan. I’ll stop when I believe it’s right—not when it’s convenient.

What the message says

Dan rejects Bryan's authority to determine when he must stop speaking, denies seeking influence, and turns the coattails accusation back toward Bryan.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Two questions should be separated: Dan's right to write and speak publicly, and Bryan's right to control direct messages he receives. Dan unquestionably controls the first; Bryan has a legitimate interest in the second.

The message merges them by treating a request to stop direct contact as an attempt to control Dan's broader speech. The line that Dan will stop when he believes it is right is powerful for public testimony but more complicated for repeated direct outreach.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • What form of speech was Bryan trying to limit?
  • Can public accountability continue without repeated direct contact?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Dan sees a conscience-based duty to persist. Bryan may see refusal to honor boundaries unless he blocks communication.
36
Healing through surrender
Bryan – February 1, 2025
+

Bryan answers Dan's reference to healing by describing relief from anguish after surrendering to Jesus.

ConversionHealingTestimonyTheology
Original correspondence

February 1, 2025 7:09PM  Bryan: 

Hi Dan, I think Jesus disagrees with your healing technique. Healing happens when we surrender to Him. I experienced unspeakable healing when I came to Jesus. I can’t forget it. I was so in pain. Anguish, really. But I have never felt that anguish again since I have walked with Him.

What the message says

Bryan answers Dan's reference to healing by describing relief from anguish after surrendering to Jesus.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Bryan offers personal testimony rather than a direct defense of earlier conduct. From his worldview, reconciliation with Christ is foundational rather than a change of subject.

Dan hears the response as a spiritual diagnosis offered in place of interpersonal accountability. Both readings are relevant.

What it answers or contributes
  • Explains Bryan's understanding of healing
  • Offers his own conversion experience
What remains open
  • Does he also believe honesty, dialogue, and interpersonal repair are required?
  • Does spiritual healing substitute for accountability or accompany it?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The response may be sincere and still function as deflection from the immediate issue.
37
Spiritual prescription or deflection?
Dan – February 1, 2025
+

Dan rejects Bryan's religious answer as performative and accuses him of using faith to protect self-interest.

ReligionDeflectionMotive accusationEscalation
Original correspondence

February 1, 2025 7:17 PM Dan: Hi Bryan,

It’s fascinating how quickly you pivot from blocking me to offering spiritual prescriptions, as if your selective memory could rewrite history. You know I’m not a Christian, so spare me the performance. I’ve watched you long enough to see that your surrender isn’t to any higher power but to your own self-interest, cloaked in the language of faith.

If your version of Jesus truly healed you, I wonder why dishonesty and manipulation still seem to thrive in your actions. Perhaps it’s not my healing technique that needs re-evaluation, but yours.

Take care, Bryan. Reflection is free, and unlike healing, it doesn’t require surrender—just honesty.

What the message says

Dan rejects Bryan's religious answer as performative and accuses him of using faith to protect self-interest.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message moves beyond saying the theological answer is inadequate and states that Bryan's claimed surrender is fraudulent. That is an assertion about inner motive not established by the exchange.

A more supportable distinction is that Bryan may sincerely believe his testimony while using it, consciously or not, to avoid the concrete accountability question.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Is Bryan's faith language sincere?
  • Even if sincere, does it answer the interpersonal issue?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The page should evaluate the function of the response without claiming certainty about Bryan's spiritual sincerity.
38
Was "tortured soul" a belief or an attack?
Dan – February 4, 2025
+

Dan revisits a 2007 email containing severe psychological and spiritual descriptions and asks whether Bryan believed them, projected his own story, followed doctrine, or used them as character attack.

Earlier emailTortured soulSpiritual judgmentCharacter attackDirect question
Original correspondence

February 4, 2025 11:17 AM Dan: Bryan,

I find myself writing to you again, driven by a sincere curiosity and a desire for understanding. I believe there’s a chance you might offer me an honest answer to what I’m about to ask.

Just yesterday, you wrote to me saying that before your ‘coming to Jesus,’ you endured much pain and anguish. That brought to mind an email you sent me back in August 2007—words that have stayed with me, not for their insight, but for their sharpness. You labeled me narcissistic, a rebellious teenager, an unhealthy man you pitied, a god-hater, prideful, a loser, a wretch, and psychologically twisted—quite an array of personal attacks for one email. But more importantly, and for the reason I bring up this past letter, after this barrage, you spoke of how Jesus could make me whole. You wrote, “Find peace for your obsessed soul… You are so tortured in your soul… In desperation, lay down your devilish arrogance, and embrace the Savior, who can heal the hurt and bring peace to your writhing, restless soul.”

Reading your recent words, it seems this pattern continues—as though, because your soul was once tortured before finding faith, you now, as you had in the past, see mine as similarly afflicted.

So, I find myself wondering: Do you believe I am a tortured soul because I don’t have Jesus in my life? Or is it because your own experience—and those of others we know, like my father and Bob Dean—have led you to assume that anyone without this faith must be suffering, must be tortured? Both my father and Bob Dean, as you know, spoke—even preached—openly about the void, emptiness, and inner torment they experienced as non-believers before their conversions. Or perhaps, does your understanding of scripture compel you to see me this way, regardless of the actual experiences I have, and am about to again express?

I ask because, when I look at my life, my most difficult moments weren’t born from a spiritual void but from tangible, human struggles—being institutionalized, pushed out of my family, disowned, and left to navigate the world alone. And yet, in that darkness, I found peace. Not through divine intervention, but by facing reality, accepting what I could not control, and rebuilding my life on my terms. I became functional again, a contributing member of my community, an employer, a friend. I found fulfillment in helping others, in empathy, in simply being present.

I am not a tortured soul, Bryan. Nor am I seeking to be a teacher or to sway anyone in your congregation as you’ve expressed. I don’t offer advice or prescribe paths. My words, my books don’t preach; they narrate. They are honest accounts of what I’ve lived and seen. And that’s precisely what I’m doing with you now—sharing my experience, just as I have about my father and the Church. My brief conversations with you, and the letters—including this letter—are part of that record.

One day, likely beyond the walls of your community, these writings will serve not to teach, but as a case study of how prioritizing self-serving interests and intentions over the well-being of others can cause harm. The lives of my father, yours, and others will stand not as indictments, but as evidence of the dangers that arise when personal gain overshadows compassion. I will ensure that the truth—with all its complexities—is brought to light, whether in our lifetime or beyond.

So, you may continue to see me as a tortured soul, a misguided teacher, or whatever label feels most comfortable. But I offer you this—a window into who I truly am and what I’m doing—for your consideration.

Yet sincerely, Bryan, I’d like to know what you have to say: do you truly believe I am a tortured soul, really? And if so, is it because of my lack of faith, your understanding of scripture, or perhaps, was it never that deep at all? Was it simply a character attack, a form of hyperbole in the heat of conviction? I ask not out of confrontation, but because understanding the truth is what matters to me. Your honesty in this will help me better understand not just you, but the broader framework of beliefs and assumptions we both navigate.

Daniel

What the message says

Dan revisits a 2007 email containing severe psychological and spiritual descriptions and asks whether Bryan believed them, projected his own story, followed doctrine, or used them as character attack.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is one of Dan's clearest and most answerable inquiries because it quotes the exact language and offers several possible explanations.

If Bryan believed the judgment, the evidentiary basis matters. If it was hyperbole in anger, the issue becomes use of claims about another person's inner life as a weapon. If doctrine supplied the category, the question is whether doctrine prevented contrary evidence from being seen.

What it answers or contributes
  • Quotes the language at issue
  • Invites clarification rather than only confession
What remains open
  • What did Bryan believe then?
  • What does he believe now?
  • Does he retract the substance or only the tone?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The announcement that the correspondence may become a public case study also makes candid self-disclosure less likely.
39
A renewed apology and a theological answer
Bryan – February 6, 2025
+

Bryan apologizes again for harsh language, declines to judge Dan's inner condition, describes his own need for Christ, and asks why Dan does not believe.

Renewed apologyNonjudgmentConversionBeliefUnanswered distinction
Original correspondence

February 6, 2025 7:09PM  Bryan: 

I apologized for those harsh, sharp words last time we had a chat about forgiveness. I’m sure you remember. But I apologize again. Please forgive me.
Do I think you’re a tortured soul? A man with your own anguish? That’s not for me to say. It doesn’t matter what I think. I do believe that every person lives under a law of sin and death until freed by Christ.
In my own experience with Christ, I received a sudden and long-lasting change from darkness to light and pain to peace. I was “dead in sins”, but God gave me His wonderful life. I wish the same for everyone I meet. It did me such good to open my needy soul to the Lord.
Are you in as needy a state as I was? I was a tortured soul. It doesn’t matter what I think of you. What matters is what you think of you.
Do you need the Savior? I did and do.
Why don’t you believe in Jesus and His Father? I wanna help you believe if I can.

What the message says

Bryan apologizes again for harsh language, declines to judge Dan's inner condition, describes his own need for Christ, and asks why Dan does not believe.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Bryan gives a meaningful direct answer by saying that whether Dan is tortured or anguished is not for him to decide. This withdraws the certainty of the earlier judgment.

He does not fully explain whether the 2007 statement was belief, projection, doctrine, or exaggeration. The response clearly regrets harshness but only partly addresses the substance.

What it answers or contributes
  • Repeats the apology
  • Declines current judgment of Dan's inner condition
  • Opens a theological conversation by asking why Dan does not believe
What remains open
  • What was the basis of the 2007 judgment?
  • Does Bryan now consider it false?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The next long response shows that Dan takes the theological question seriously rather than dismissing it.
40
An apology is a beginning
Dan – February 8, 2025
+

Dan accepts the renewed apology, then answers Bryan's question about belief through family separation, inherited narratives, control, his father's final days, and what Christian integrity would require.

Apology acceptedFamily separationControlFatherBeliefReconciliation
Original correspondence

 

February 8, 2025

Bryan,

It is a welcome change to receive a letter from you that is not weighed down by accusation. And yes, you have apologized more than once now for the disparaging remarks you made about me years ago. I hear you, and I do not take your words lightly.

Yet, as I read your letter, something stirs, a feeling I cannot ignore. A sense of déjà vu.

I have been here before.

Let me take you back.

It was 1983, maybe ’84—the last year my grandparents and aunt remained in The Living Word Church. A Friday afternoon. I had just finished building my remote-control plane, something I had worked on for weeks. Excited, I called my brother Paul.

“Hey, I finally got it working. Grandpa’s meeting me at the park to see it fly. Want to come?”
“Wait… Grandpa’s going to be there?”
“Yeah, I thought he’d enjoy it too.”
“Then I can’t go.”
“What? Why not?”
“Grandma and Grandpa were told to leave the church. We can’t see them anymore.”

His words caught me off guard. Until that moment, I had understood, at least in the abstract, that things were changing. But I had not yet reckoned with what that change would take from us. Our grandparents, who had been a steady and unwavering presence in our lives, who had given us nothing but kindness, love, and support, were now gone. Not by death. Not by distance. But by decree. Just like that.

For years, my father and I had talked. Long conversations where he unburdened himself, confiding in me about the struggles of leading a church, the tangled web of loyalties, the fractures forming beneath the surface. He spoke of the pressures, the weight of expectation, the difficult decisions placed before him, decisions that determined who was in, who was out, who could stay, and who had to go. He would ask for my thoughts, and I would offer them, carefully and earnestly, as though my reasoning could shift the course he was set on. And yet, no matter how much I listened, no matter how much I tried to understand, his decisions always followed a different path, one that had already been chosen before he ever sought my counsel.

I often wondered why he kept asking. Maybe he wanted reassurance. Maybe he wanted absolution. Or maybe, deep down, he wished he could choose differently.

From these conversations, I had already come to understand why so many of our cousins had drifted away. I knew tensions were growing between my father and my grandmother. But I had not yet grasped the finality of it all, the quiet and effortless way a relationship could dissolve—not through argument, not through some defining moment of betrayal, but through a slow, silent erosion. A decision made. A line drawn. And once crossed, it could never be undone.

That realization settled in me like a weight I could not shake. It was not just about my grandparents. It was about something much larger, something I had not yet been able to name.

So instead of heading to the park to fly my plane, I got in my car and drove straight to the church. My father was in his office, preparing for the evening service, surrounded by the burdens he had chosen, the authority he carried, and the expectations that had shaped him.

We talked. For a long time.

I spoke to him not just as a son, but as someone who had listened, someone who had spent years trying to understand the burdens he carried. I did not confront him in anger. I appealed to him, reasoning with him, holding up a mirror to the choices he had made, urging him to see the cost. Not in doctrine. Not in obligation. But in the quiet unraveling of the very people we loved.

I pressed him to look beyond the justifications, beyond the language of faith and righteousness that made it all easier to accept. This was not about belief. It was not about principle. It was about something else entirely, something unspoken, something neither of us wanted to name, yet both of us knew was there.

At some point, something I said must have reached him.

His composure cracked. His shoulders sank. And then, he broke.

Tears filled his eyes as he admitted he had been wrong. His voice, so often steady and certain, wavered as he promised to make things right.

I wanted to believe him.

And for a moment, I did.

I wrote about this conversation, and everything surrounding it, in COR Values. I documented not just what was said, but what it meant—the deeper implications of what it revealed about my father, about the church, about the way we sometimes convince ourselves we are acting in faith when we are really acting in fear, in control, in something else entirely.

But as I would soon learn, recognizing a wrong is not the same as making it right. An apology is not an endpoint. It is supposed to be a beginning.

But I took what I could get.

Shortly after, I found myself standing in the school gym, listening as Lou Levante rebuked me—telling me I was a burden to my father, that I wasn’t supporting him, that I didn’t understand the weight of his responsibilities. My father had left us alone to return to his office, and Lou took that opportunity to set me straight. I said nothing. I let the words land, absorbed them as I had so many others, and then I walked out. I got into my car and left.

A few days later, I pulled into the driveway after work and saw my father tinkering with his boat. It was a rare, quiet moment, just the two of us, and I saw an opportunity.

“Hey Dad, is everything good with you and Grandma now? Did you talk with her?”
“Uh, yeah. Everything’s good.”
“Yeah? Great. What did you do? Did you sit down and talk things through?”
“Look, son… no, but I sent her flowers.”

Flowers.

“Flowers? But Dad, you need to talk!”

His expression hardened. The openness I had seen in his office days earlier vanished.

“Son, now mind your place. You’re an unbeliever and have no understanding of these things of God.”

And there it was.

In that moment, I knew—there would be no lasting peace. The words we had spoken in his office had been just that—words. The tears, the regret, the realization of wrongdoing… all of it meant nothing if it wasn’t followed by action. And without action, the rot that had already taken hold would remain, deepening, spreading.

And so it did.

Right up until the day my grandparents died—estranged from us. Right up until the day my mother lost them, never to see them again, despite my years of pleading for reconciliation.

The Déjà Vu Moment

So what is the déjà vu moment, you might ask?

It is the pattern, the cycle I have seen before, and now, here it is again.

With my father, it took years of difficult conversations before he finally saw the truth. And in the end, he did. He broke down, admitted his mistakes, and offered a heartfelt apology.

But the problem, the thing he never understood, was that an apology is not the conclusion. It is not the final word.

It is supposed to be the beginning.

Recognition without action is nothing more than sentiment. A realization that does not lead to change is just another moment lost in time.

And now, Bryan, here we are.

I haven’t had the years of verbal conversations with you that I had with my father, but we’ve had written ones. And now, after all these years, you’ve realized you were wrong in how you spoke about me. You’ve apologized, and for that, I am genuinely grateful.

But maybe you are wondering, Why can’t Dan just let this go? Why bring it up again? Why not leave it in the past?

I do not want to put words in your mouth, but I have stood in this moment before.

I have had this conversation in different ways, with different people, across different years of my life. And through all of it, a few truths have become undeniable.

Realizing wrongdoing and offering an apology opens the door to reconciliation, but too often, reconciliation is mistaken for something else. It is framed as a matter of victory or defeat, as if one must win and the other must concede.

But it is not about proving who was right and who was wrong.

It is about understanding.

And within every apology lies an opportunity for forgiveness. That is, if one is willing to release resentment and let the past go.

Resentment serves no purpose.

When two minds meet in truth, when we can finally see one another, not as adversaries, not as symbols of past wounds, but as people, then we can move forward. We can look ahead rather than behind.

That is, when looking ahead is truly possible.

Because I have also learned that sometimes, before we can move forward, we must first look back.

With my father, I knew that before there could be a future to move toward, we had to confront the past. Not to dwell in it, not to assign blame, but to understand how we got here.

Because if we do not understand how we arrived at a place of brokenness, how can we ever hope to truly leave it behind?

Looking Back to Move Forward

So here we are, Bryan—a starting point.

You’ve apologized, more than once, for the disparaging things you said about me. And for that, I want to be clear—I am truly grateful. It means something to me. But now, I have to ask: Can we take a moment to look back?

Not to dwell, not to reopen wounds for the sake of pain, but to understand. To truly leave something behind, we have to first acknowledge how we got there.

Judgment

Judge me, Bryan. If you must, judge me day and night. I welcome it.

I’ve heard people say the Bible warns against judgment, but when I read it, I don’t find that message. What I see is that it warns against hypocrisy and unfair judgment, not discernment. The emphasis is on self-awareness, on humility, on ensuring that our judgments are rooted in truth rather than assumptions.

“Judge not according to the appearance, but judge righteous judgment.” — John 7:24

That settles well with me. In life, judgment is necessary. To navigate this world, we must assess people, situations, and choices. So if I judge others, then I must also accept being judged. But I ask that the judgment be fair—based on truth, not hearsay.

The Weight of Innuendo

How does this relate to you and me?

Back in 2007, I wrote to you, urging you to judge me not by rumors, but by experience—by what you had seen and known for yourself, not by what had been handed to you by others.

At the time of your accusations against me, we had never even had a real conversation—if we had spoken at all. The only “experience” you had of me wasn’t mine to give. It wasn’t drawn from any interaction between us.

It was borrowed—filtered through the words and perceptions of others.

Yet, despite never having truly known me, you formed a strong opinion of who I was, of what I was. But I was never part of the equation.

That’s why I offered you something simple:

Come meet me. See for yourself.

I was willing to fly you down, to put you up in a hotel for as long as you needed. Not to debate, not to argue, but to let you sit across from me, talk with me, meet the people who had truly known me for years. I wanted to give you the chance to judge me based on reality, not reputation.

That offer still stands, by the way.

Where Did Your Idea of Me Come From?

But here’s the question I’ve had to ask myself: Where did these ideas about me come from? If they weren’t true, if they weren’t based on any real interactions between us, then who planted them?

Lou Levante never put his disparaging words in writing as you did. He spoke them directly to my face. That day in the gym, after my father left us alone, Lou saw his opportunity and took it. He did not hold back. He let me have it.

He called me a burden. A disappointment. A terrible son.

And yet, as he said these things, he had no idea how hard I was working to hold my family together. How much I was fighting for my father. How deeply I cared.

It was a surreal moment. One I later wrote about in COR Values, comparing it to that experience of watching a movie where a character does something so cringeworthy, so misguided, that you physically feel it in your bones. Except this wasn’t a movie. It was real. And I was in it.

Then there was Paul.

About a year or two after that day in the gym—after I had been told to leave my home and family—I crossed paths with my brother Paul at Lincoln Bank in Liverpool.

The moment he saw me, he didn’t just acknowledge my presence—he announced it to the entire room.

“Hey, there’s my brother! Big man, big shot, has all the answers…”

His voice carried across the bank lobby, drawing the attention of everyone around us. He didn’t stop there. He kept going, his words cutting deeper, his tone growing louder, the weight of his disdain filling the space between us.

I didn’t respond. I didn’t argue.

Without a word, I turned and walked out—leaving the building, stepping into my car, and driving away.

But time has a way of shifting perspectives.

You likely know that today, at least for now, my brother Paul and I have a relationship. In an effort to reclaim even a fraction of what was lost, I treated him and his family to a playoff game—Dolphins versus some other team (I don’t follow football, but his son Jacob is a fan).

But it was never about the game.

It was about the moment—a single shared experience, a step toward something larger. A way to begin bridging the years that had been stolen from us.

Paul remembers that day at Lincoln Bank.

We’ve talked about it.

He feels bad about it.

And I’m grateful—not just for the apology, but because today, he sees me differently.

After the day my father told me to leave our home, I reached out to everyone—both my brothers, my sisters, my mother.

I asked them to let me be their brother. Let me be a son.

I tried to have lunch with Debbie. I tried to see my siblings. I reached out, again and again, only to be met with the same response:

“We can’t have anything to do with you until you get things right with Dad.”

I pleaded with them.

“What’s between me and Dad is between me and Dad. I’m doing my best with it, trying to work through it. But can’t you just be my brother? My sister? My mother? Can’t we keep that separate?”

But the answer never changed. No matter how much I reached for them, they remained just beyond my grasp.

And in the midst of it all, I continued reaching for my father.

I wrote to him. I called him. I begged him to talk to me.

He never did. Never would. Always refused.

Not for thirty-six years.

Until, at last—just days before he died—my phone rang.

His voice was quiet, hesitant.

“Son, I know you won’t want to see me, and it’s okay, I understand.”

I froze.

“Wait—what? What are you saying? Do you want to see me?”

“Son, I just want to put my arms around you and tell you I love you.”

For so long, I had imagined this moment. I had gone over it in my mind again and again, rehearsing every conversation, preparing for every possibility. What I would say. What I would demand to know when we finally faced each other.

Now, I had an entire plane flight ahead of me to think about it all.

“Okay, Dad. I will see you tomorrow.”

And when we finally met face to face, all the questions I had carried for so many years did not find answers. They simply faded into silence.

But my search for understanding did not begin or end there.

For years, I tried to make sense of it all. I spoke with anyone who would listen. I asked questions. I searched for clarity in places where clarity was rarely given.

When I asked my mother or my father why things had unfolded the way they had, the answers were always vague, shifting, circular.

“Oh, you don’t know how disrespectful he was to your father.”
“It was so bad—you just don’t understand.”

“Okay—but what did he do?”

“He was just… Gary’s so much younger than your father. It was wrong.”

No real explanations. No concrete reasons. Just fragments of accusations, repeated again and again, yet never anchored in anything real.

So I kept asking.

I turned to my aunt, my uncle, my grandparents. At first, they hesitated. Not out of secrecy. Not out of deception. Out of protection.

They were not withholding the truth. They were shielding it.

Not to rewrite history, but to soften its sharpest edges. Not to turn me against my father, but to preserve whatever remained of our fragile relationship. They did not want me to look down on him, to lose my respect for him, to see him in a way that would make reconciliation even more impossible than it already seemed.

But I could not stop searching.

And as the conversations stretched on, as I pressed for answers, as I refused to accept half-truths, the truth began to emerge.

Not through anger.

Not through resentment.

But simply through the facts of what had actually happened.

Maybe at this point, you are thinking, Wow, that is a lot, Dan. Where are you going with this?

I am telling the story of my past, the story of how this character you came to believe in was shaped. The persona you identified did not come from me. It was constructed, molded by the words of others, passed down until it became a version of me that never truly existed.

And I could go on for hours about how I know my personality was presented to you and to others. I could lay out the consequences of those mischaracterizations, the weight they carried, the damage they caused.

I could name those who misjudged me, those who cast their verdicts before ever knowing me. Those who reduced me to nothing more than a caricature, the wayward son, the unbeliever, the one lost in sin.

I could remind you of the words spoken from the pulpit, of how I was painted in broad, unforgiving strokes, labeled and condemned before I ever had the chance to speak for myself.

If I wanted, I could even provide recordings, proof of the way my name was spoken, not in conversation, but as a warning.

But let us get to the heart of it.

The way you once saw me, the words you have now apologized for. The way my family saw me. The way so many of them still do.

It all traces back to one source.

My father.

And here’s the truth, plain and simple: I am not the person you all were told I was.

The Beginning, Not the End

So yes, Bryan, your apology is meaningful. I accept it fully.

But I ask you—is that the end of it, or should it be the beginning?

The day I finally met with my father in his last few days on this earth was one of the hardest of my life. As I sat on the plane heading to him, questions swirled in my mind.

Why now?

Why had he waited until the very end to finally see me?

Was it because he wanted to talk?

Was he hoping to make peace?

Or was this about securing his place in heaven, seeking a final moment of absolution? Was he hoping to make peace with the years of silence, with the things we both knew he had allowed to be said about me, with the lies he had spread?

I spent eight hours alone with him that day. Not by choice, not by some intentional family decision, but because of the simple reality of the time. COVID protocols allowed only one visitor at a time.

And in those eight hours, there was no confession.

No moment of reckoning.

No acknowledgment of the decades lost or the damage done.

No mention of my siblings. No concern for my mother. No words of support or regret about the family he was leaving behind, no recognition of the fractures that remained.

Not once did he speak of helping to restore what had been broken, of ensuring that I could reconnect with those I had lost.

And what did I do when I realized there would be no resolution? When I understood that the words I had waited to hear would never come?

Did I lash out? Did I demand answers? Did I confront him, saying, See? You never cared. You have been wrong all these years. What kind of man, what kind of pastor does this?

No.

Because what would have been the point?

He was dying.

What good would it have done? What would anyone have gained from that?

So instead, I gave him what I could. I made him comfortable. I made him feel cared for.

It was the hardest thing I wrote about in COR Values. Even now, as I bring it up again, I feel the weight of it pressing down.

I tried so hard for so many years to reach my father.

And in the end, I failed.

Control

And there it is.

After all these words, all this reflection, I can reduce everything to one—control.

This is where it all began. This is where it has remained.

You asked me in your last text, “Why don’t you believe in Jesus and His Father? I wanna help you believe if I can.”

Having read everything I have written to this point, would it sound outrageous if I told you that my experience with my father, with the church, and even, at times, with you has convinced me that if there is a God, a just and true God, he cannot be found in the place I came from?

There is much I do not know. But I have lived enough, witnessed enough, and experienced enough to make some quality judgments. And if I were to take your question literally, “I want to help you believe if I can,” then the most you could do for me is not to argue, not to preach, but simply to be an example of what I have always known a Christian is supposed to be.

And what is that?

With all honesty—and, yes, a touch of irony—I would say: A person like me.

A seeker of truth.

Someone who understands the necessity of relinquishing control, of surrendering to the unknown, of having faith that, in the end, he will land where he is meant to be.

The Illusion of Control

Do I have an agenda?

Yes. I won’t deny it.

What is it?

It has always been to see my family united.

But even in that pursuit, one that seems noble and right, I have wrestled with the very thing that I now recognize as the source of all this pain. Control.

In my twenties, I thought I was smart—smart enough to make my family see. To make them come to their senses, to realize the destruction their choices had wrought. I thought that if I just laid it out plainly enough, if I just made them see the obvious, they would understand how antithetical their actions were to the Christianity they claimed to uphold.

I thought I could change them.

But I couldn’t.

I failed.

And my inability to accept the course they had chosen, my inability to relinquish my grip on what I wanted reality to be, led to my own downfall. It consumed me. And in the end, it broke me, so much so that I was institutionalized.

That was my reckoning with control.

But in time, I made peace with that struggle. I learned that control is an illusion. That life is best lived when we let go, when we play the cards we’re dealt rather than trying to reshuffle the deck, when we see the glass as half full instead of lamenting that it is not overflowing.

The Cycle Continues

Bryan, we have to give up control. We have to follow the truth wherever it leads us, even when it takes us to places we would rather not go.

The story I tell about my father is not flattering. It does not reflect the virtues of a pastor, a leader, or even, at times, a father. But it is the truth.

And it is his truth, the version of me he worked so hard to construct, that shaped the very words you once spoke against me, words you now regret.

It is this same falsehood that still holds my brother David captive, binding him to a perception of me so deeply ingrained that it leaves no room for reconciliation.

It is this pattern of speaking and living, built on distortion and control, that has driven my sister Pam to sever all ties—not just with me, but with every one of her siblings—pulling her into the same fate, and dare I say, the same curse that once consumed our mother.

It is these fabrications, these inherited deceptions, this way of being passed down from my father, that led Pam to speak the very same words I once heard from my mother’s lips about our grandmother.

“Mom is dead to me.”

I heard Pam say it, and the words rang in my ears, echoing those I had heard years before from my mother. Now, Pam has vowed to never have anything to do with our mother again.

History is repeating itself, Bryan.

I watched my mother live an entire life clutching those words, embodying them, fulfilling them, turning estrangement into permanence, into finality.

And now, here I am, caught in the same cycle, watching my sister follow the very same path.

So you ask, What can I do to help you believe?

Follow the truth, wherever it leads you.

Let go of control.

And know this. I am not the enemy, Bryan. But I was made to be one.

I was not condemned in private, nor was I the subject of mere personal grievances. My name was spoken from the pulpit of your church.

“Do not have anything to do with my son. He is poison. Do not be bitten by the snake, or you will backslide.”

And for years, that was enough. A few words from a place of authority, and suddenly, I was no longer a person—I was a warning.

So what will it take for me to believe in God?

I don’t know. But if there is a God, God knows.

And in the meantime, my focus is not on chasing a belief, not on trying to force an answer where there is none, but on something far more tangible.

Doing my best to follow the truth, wherever it may lead.

And just as importantly, I need to give myself room to breathe, to rest, to stop tearing myself apart for not having all the answers. I need to remind myself that it is okay not to know. That searching is enough. That putting in an honest effort is enough.

Because that is what gives me peace, keeps me grounded, and allows me to hold on to myself.

I move forward, one day at a time, not trying to bend reality to fit my desires, not trying to rewrite what has already been written, but focusing on the only thing that truly matters.

My character. My integrity.

And when I met you at my father’s funeral, in that quiet moment at the cemetery, I told you:

“I have something of value to offer you, and you have something of value to offer me.”

That was not just something to say, it was something I believe.

It was a realization, one that took shape during my final conversation with my father in the hospital, a conversation that, despite everything, I will carry with me for the rest of my life.

So here it is, Bryan. Here is that something of value.

Let us stop pretending the past is not right in front of us.

Let us face it so we can finally move beyond it.

For now, today, I am not a Christian.

Tomorrow? Who can say.

But today, I am also not the villain I was made out to be.

Maybe, just maybe, I am someone worth listening to.

And maybe, if one day I seek a church, I will find one that does not define me by labels, that does not see an atheist or a Christian, but simply a man.

A man whose voice is not dismissed, whose story is not just heard but truly valued and understood.

What the message says

Dan accepts the renewed apology, then answers Bryan's question about belief through family separation, inherited narratives, control, his father's final days, and what Christian integrity would require.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is one of the most important messages and should be divided into thematic subsections rather than displayed as one wall of text.

Dan examines not only what others did but his own attempt to force understanding. He says his desire for reconciliation became entangled with control and contributed to his breakdown.

His account of caring for his dying father distinguishes wanting acknowledgment from recognizing that another person cannot be forced into sincere remorse. Yet the letter still tells Bryan what his faith, apology, and future conduct should require, illustrating how difficult it is to separate moral appeal from control.

What it answers or contributes
  • Accepts that Bryan's apology matters
  • Explains why Dan does not presently believe
  • Acknowledges Dan's own controlling impulse
  • Presents mercy without revision of history
What remains open
  • Does Bryan accept Dan's family history?
  • Does he see a role in reconciliation?
  • Will he engage the memoir or evidence?
  • Can he distinguish spiritual appeal from accountability?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Use subheadings: family separation; inherited account; Dan's struggle with control; final encounter with father; what Bryan could do; assumptions the letter still makes about Bryan.

Part Six – Privacy, knowledge, and complicity

Publication and privacy become central. Dan interprets Bryan's knowledge of the father's faults as complicity; Bryan rejects that inference and withdraws.

41
Guardedness, privacy, and a defense of the church
Bryan – February 11, 2025
+

Bryan says possible publication prevents unguarded conversation, cites his refusal to publicize Dan's words, says he knew the father's faults, defends loyalty to the church rather than the man, and again disputes that Dan is a major subject in the community.

PrivacyPublicationFatherChurchMemoryGuarded speech
Original correspondence

February 11, 2025 6:28PM  Bryan: 

Unfortunately, Dan, I have trouble having an unguarded conversation with you.  I feel like I need to keep my cards close to my chest because I never know if you will publish something I say that I considered private.  I do not publish anything you say either in writing or in public address.  I never have.  I don’t plan on it.  You, on the other hand,  have publicly maligned me as a hypocrite and a pawn.  My phone and computer discard your texts after 30 days.  I am not documenting anything.  1 Corinthians 13:5 says that love keeps no record of wrongs. 

You cannot reveal anything, anything whatsoever, to me about your dad.  I worked with him closer than anyone else for 45 years.  I’m not stupid.  I am rather thoughtful, a bit educated, fairly well-read, independent, and diligent.  I knew all his faults.  I did not live for him or give my life to him.  I gave my life to the church.  I remained determined to stay with the church and make it the best I could.  I love the generous, beautiful people in the church.  I want more people to experience the goodness of Christ that we have experienced together.

I tried to distinguish myself from your dad when he was alive without fighting with him.  God told me not to fight.  Now that your dad is gone the distinction between me and him is more apparent and becoming clearer as time goes by.  As the book of Joshua says, “Moses is dead” (Emphasis on “dead,” not “Moses”).

You worry way too much about people around here talking about you.  I don’t talk about you.  No one I know talks about you with one rare exception. Once in a while, like once every two-four years, someone in your family may give an update.  It is not a sinister conversation.  It is the kind of conversation that lots of normal friends have about their families.  You are not a “big deal” around here.  You are certainly not public enemy number one.

I hope I am showing you Christ’s love in this sincere note.

What the message says

Bryan says possible publication prevents unguarded conversation, cites his refusal to publicize Dan's words, says he knew the father's faults, defends loyalty to the church rather than the man, and again disputes that Dan is a major subject in the community.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This message contains four arguments: publication prevents candor; Bryan does not keep a record; he knew the father's faults; and his loyalty was to the church and its people rather than to the father.

The phrase "I knew all his faults" is consequential but ambiguous. It does not specify which faults, when Bryan knew them, how he understood them, or what power he had to intervene.

The privacy concern must be presented prominently. Public leadership may justify scrutiny of official conduct, but it does not eliminate all expectations of privacy in personal communication.

What it answers or contributes
  • Explains guardedness
  • Distinguishes church loyalty from personal loyalty to the father
  • States that he knew the father had faults
What remains open
  • Which faults did he know?
  • When did he know them?
  • What did he do to distinguish himself?
  • Could outsiders access the accountability process?
  • Which communications did he consider private?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Dan sees guardedness as suppression and awareness as complicity. Bryan may see publication plans as proof that the exchange is being gathered for public judgment rather than private reconciliation.
42
From knowing faults to alleging complicity
Dan – February 12, 2025
+

Dan interprets Bryan's statement that he knew the father's faults as an admission that he knowingly allowed deception, family separation, and institutional harm to continue.

ComplicityInferenceScripturePublicationAccountability
Original correspondence

February 12, 2025 3:30 PM Dan: 

Bryan,

Your recent response is deeply disturbing. You now openly acknowledge that you “knew all my father’s faults” and assert, “I tried to distinguish myself from your dad when he was alive without fighting with him.” You even go so far as to declare, “You cannot reveal anything, anything whatsoever, to me about your dad. I worked with him closer than anyone else for 45 years. I’m not stupid.”

After years of my writing to you, after years of exposing his lies, the harm he inflicted, and the divisions he created, you now admit that you knew it all along. This is not merely an acknowledgment of awareness. It is an admission of complicity. You were not unaware. You were not deceived. You knew. And yet, you remained silent. You knew, and yet you allowed harm to continue. You knew, and yet you stood by as lives were upended, as families were torn apart, as deception and abuse were carried out under the guise of faith.

This is not the response of an innocent bystander. This is the response of a man who had every opportunity to speak out, to intervene, to defend those who suffered—and chose not to.

For years, you ignored the truth when it was placed directly before you. Yet you did not merely remain silent—you spoke against me. Rather than standing for those who suffered under my father’s influence, rather than defending those who were cast aside and separated from their families, you chose to oppose the messenger rather than confront the source of the harm. You had every opportunity to speak, to intervene, to stand for truth, to offer empathy and understanding.

But you did nothing.

Worse than nothing, you aligned yourself against the very people who sought justice and clarity. Instead of using your voice and position to confront wrongdoing, you wielded them to discredit those who dared to speak the truth. Instead of defending the wounded, you defended your own comfort. Instead of standing for righteousness, you shielded those who thrived in deception.

And now you sit with the full weight of knowledge you have carried for decades, yet still refuse to acknowledge what that makes you.

And now, as if to sweep it all away, you cite 1 Corinthians 13:5, telling me that “love keeps no record of wrongs” as if those words were meant to erase history, absolve you of responsibility, and eliminate the consequences of silence in the face of evil. You do not invoke Scripture to uphold truth, but to distort it into a refuge for wrongdoing, an excuse for inaction, a justification for cowardice.

But love does not ignore truth. Love does not conceal injustice. Love does not shield the guilty by pretending harm never occurred. Love does not stand idly by while others suffer and call its indifference virtue.

Your misuse of Scripture is not just desperate—it is deceitful. 1 Corinthians 13:5 does not command that sin be ignored, forgotten, or dismissed. It speaks of love’s nature, which does not cling to grievances out of bitterness or seek vengeance for its own sake. But love does not erase truth. Love does not silence the voices of the wronged. Love does not excuse injustice by pretending it never happened.

The very Bible you claim to follow does not call for silence—it calls for justice, repentance, and accountability. If your interpretation were correct, we would have to discard every record of

wrongdoing in Scripture. We would have to erase the sins of Israel, the failures of kings, and the betrayal of Judas. Yet the Bible does not whitewash these events. It records them not to dwell in bitterness, but to expose corruption, to warn others, and to call people to repentance.

Ezekiel 18:30-32 makes it clear that God Himself reminds people of their sins, not to condemn them, but to urge them to change. He does not erase the past, nor does He absolve without repentance. Jesus, too, confronted the Pharisees openly, condemning their hypocrisy and holding them accountable for their corruption (Matthew 23). He did not excuse their deceit with platitudes about love. He did not suggest that righteousness required forgetting. He demanded truth.

To love is to stand for truth. To love is to bring wrongdoing into the light. To love is to hold accountable those who harm others.

Anything less is not love—it is complicity.

Keeping a Record of Wrongs is Necessary

1. For Protection – Nowhere in Scripture are we commanded to erase wrongdoing from our awareness, especially when it brings harm to others. Forgetting does not protect the innocent—it enables the guilty. Paul himself warned believers about dangerous individuals (2 Timothy 4:14-15), remembering their actions so that others would not fall victim to them. Ignoring past wrongs does not safeguard anyone. Recognizing them does.

2. For Justice and Repentance – True repentance is impossible without acknowledging the wrongs that have been committed. Without recognition, there can be no accountability, no correction, no change. God does not simply dismiss sin as if it never occurred. Proverbs 28:13 states, “Whoever conceals their sins does not prosper, but the one who confesses and renounces them finds mercy.” Mercy is not given to those who cover their transgressions, but to those who confront them, confess them, and turn away from them.

3. For Truth – Scripture commands us to expose wrongdoing, not to conceal it. Ephesians 5:11 instructs, “Have nothing to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness, but rather expose them.” Love does not mean overlooking evil or allowing harm to continue under the guise of grace. Love seeks truth, justice, and restoration. To silence the truth is to side with the oppressor. To expose wrongdoing is to stand with the innocent.

The difference between us.

You claim to have known the truth about my father all along. That means every time you heard the stories of people being harmed and dismissed them, you were not simply ignorant—you were willfully ignoring the truth.

That means every time you saw division sown and chose to remain silent, you were complicit in it.

That means every time you accused me rather than confronting the real source of wrongdoing, you aligned yourself with injustice.

There is no honor in that. There is no integrity in that. There is no righteousness in allowing harm to continue when you had the power to stand against it.

A man of character does not turn a blind eye to evil when it is within his power to stop it. A man of character does not let the innocent suffer while he remains comfortable in silence. A man of character does not accuse those who speak truth while protecting those who commit wrongdoing.

So I ask you, Bryan, now that you have admitted to knowing the truth, what does that say about you?

What kind of man chooses silence over justice? What kind of man watches people suffer, knowing the cause, and refuses to act? What kind of man condemns the messenger of truth rather than the source of harm?

What kind of man—what kind of pastor—stands complicit in wrongdoing, shields the guilty, enables evil, and yet dares to speak of righteousness?

You have the audacity to preach “keep no record of wrongs” while, in blatant hypocrisy, you cling to the memory of others’ transgressions, judge, and condemn. You stand in the pulpit and declare with certainty that “Christians in other churches in our own community are under the heavy influence of Satan, of Lucifer”—yet you shield the wrongdoers in your own midst, erase the truth when it implicates you, and silence those who expose it.

And yet, you stand here, knowing the full depth of the corruption you defended, the lives destroyed by your silence, the harm inflicted under your watch, and you have done nothing.

What kind of man does this? What kind of pastor aligns himself with deception while speaking of truth? What kind of Christian proclaims the influence of Satan in others while turning a blind eye to the evil he has witnessed firsthand?

A good Christian? A wise pastor?

And what does it say, Bryan, that an atheist, someone outside of your faith, grasps these moral imperatives with greater clarity and conviction than you do?

What does it say that I, a non-believer, still uphold truth, justice, and accountability while you, a pastor, twist Scripture to shield yourself from discomfort?

Should it not be the man of God who leads the charge for righteousness, for honesty, for the defense of the innocent?

Should it not be the pastor, the one who claims to stand on divine authority, who champions justice rather than evades it?

Yet here we are, and it is not you holding truth above self-preservation.

It is me.

You preach of morality, yet when faced with injustice, you choose silence. You claim to follow a God of truth, yet when confronted with deception and harm, you seek refuge in misused Scripture rather than in integrity. You claim that faith makes one righteous, yet here stands a non-believer, pointing out what should have been obvious to you all along.

I have no divine command to pursue justice, yet I do.

You claim to have one, yet you ignore it.

Shame on you, Bryan.

You knew better. You still do. And yet, rather than standing for what is right, you have chosen to manipulate even the Word of God itself, twisting it to serve your own interests. If that is faith, what is it worth? If that is righteousness, what does it even mean?

And if an atheist must be the one to remind a pastor of his duty to truth, then what does that say about you?

Shame on you, Bryan. I believe you know better, yet you are willing to pervert even Scripture itself to justify your own inaction, to cover your own complicity, to protect your own comfort.

You cite Scripture as though it erases wrongdoing, as though it can wipe away your silence, your failures, your deliberate refusal to act. But Scripture does not call for silence. It calls for justice.

Proverbs 24:11-12 commands us to rescue those being led to slaughter, to act when we have the power to do so. It warns that we cannot claim ignorance, that God weighs the heart and repays each person according to their deeds.

You had the knowledge. You had the ability. And you did nothing.

And now, you expect me to believe that you are concerned about me sharing your words with others? That this is what troubles you?

Am I supposed to be surprised that you delete your texts, that you carefully erase your own words, that you bury them before they can be exposed?

Why would a man who claims to speak for God need to hide his own words?

Why would someone who stands at a pulpit, delivering sermons before an entire congregation, be so afraid of his own responses being known?

You do not erase your messages because they contain righteousness, wisdom, or truth.

You erase them because they betray you.

You erase them because they reveal what you cannot afford the world to see. You erase them because they expose you.

They are not the words of a man who upholds justice. They are the words of a man who has spent years avoiding it.

You claim you will not bring my words to the public, as if that is some act of nobility, as if withholding them is a display of integrity.

But why would you?

What could you possibly gain from revealing them?

My words do not implicate me in wrongdoing. They do not expose deceit. They do not reveal hypocrisy. They do not uncover complicity in harm.

That is what your words do.

Unlike you, I do not fear my words being made known. I do not delete them. I do not bury them in secrecy.

I do not need to.

You are free to share anything I have ever said to you, anywhere, at any time. You have my full permission.

Because I have nothing to hide.

That is the difference between us.

You claim to walk in the light, yet you scramble to conceal your own words in darkness. I do not stand behind a pulpit and pretend to hold divine truth, yet my words can withstand the scrutiny of the world.

Yours cannot.

You preach before an audience that is expected to listen in silence, yet in a true dialogue, where you are questioned, where your words must hold their own weight,

You tremble. You erase. You cover your tracks.

You fear exposure not because my words are dangerous— but because yours are.

You fear them being seen because they reveal exactly what you have tried to hide. You fear them because they tell the truth.

And you know it.

What happens now?

The last time someone attempted to silence me, the police arrived at my door. They were told I was building a bomb and planning to blow up the Living Word Church.

Before that, it was the FBI, questioning me over yet another false accusation.

Each time, a desperate attempt was made to paint me as the villain, to brand me as dangerous, to force me into silence through intimidation and lies.

And now, you, Bryan— You subtly suggest, once again, that I should be quiet. That I should stop speaking, as I do not matter, I’m “no big deal” in your community. That my words should vanish, and with them yours, just as you make yours disappear.

You do not arrive with the police this time, at least not yet.

You have not summoned the authorities—at least, not that I am aware of.

Not yet.

But instead, you attempt to silence me in a different way—through suggestion, through implication, through the calculated weight of your carefully measured words.

But I will not be quiet.

I was not silenced by false accusations. I was not silenced by the police. I was not silenced by federal agents knocking on my door.

And I will certainly not be silenced by you.

The truth does not die because it makes you uncomfortable. It does not fade because you wish it would. It does not disappear simply because you demand it.

You may delete your words. You may erase your messages. You may attempt to bury the past.

But I will not.

I have already told you in writing that my words here may not serve to teach in the traditional sense, but they will not be lost. They will not be buried. They will not be erased like yours.

Our correspondence—every exchange, every revelation of your complicity—will stand as a case study.

A case study on the cost of silence. A case study on the devastation caused by unchecked authority. A case study on the consequences of moral cowardice.

It will serve both believers and non-believers alike, not as a theological debate, but as a lesson in human nature, in the corruption of power, and in the destruction wrought by those who claim to serve righteousness while shielding those who do harm.

It will stand as a warning.

A warning against control, against those who place obedience over conscience. A warning against submission without accountability. A warning against silence in the face of injustice. A warning against those who would rather protect their own comfort than stand against what is undeniably wrong. A warning against self-preservation at the cost of truth, against the willingness to distort, erase, or suppress reality simply because the truth is inconvenient or damning.

For years, I have spoken to you about the harm my father inflicted— The lies. The manipulation. The division he created.

You knew. You admitted it. You were closer to him than anyone.

You witnessed what he did, yet for decades, you remained silent.

And now, after all this time, You still refuse to acknowledge the depth of your inaction. You still attempt to twist Scripture as a means of justifying your complicity. You still seek to suppress rather than confront.

But our dialogue will not be hidden. It will be studied. It will be examined. It will be remembered.

It will serve as a testament to what happens when truth is sacrificed for power, when faith is used as a weapon to control rather than to heal, and when those who stand in positions of spiritual authority choose cowardice over courage.

This case study will show exactly what happens when a man like my father is allowed to rule unchecked, and when a man like you enables it through silence.

It will reveal how manipulation thrives under the guise of faith. It will serve as evidence of how wrongdoing is allowed to continue when men like you prioritize their reputation over righteousness.

And it will leave a question for those who read it, those who study it, those who seek to understand how such corruption can endure.

What if you had spoken?

What if, years ago, instead of allowing my father to wield his influence unchecked, you had chosen to stand against him?

What if, instead of aligning yourself with power, you had aligned yourself with truth?

What if, instead of defending your silence, you had confronted the harm that was being done?

Would lives have been different? Would families have been spared the pain of separation? Would the people who placed their trust in you have found refuge rather than betrayal?

These questions will linger in the study of our dialogue.

And, Bryan, when the case study is written, when your words are held up to scrutiny, when those who seek to understand how deception is allowed to thrive look upon your role in all of this,

What will they see?

Will they see a man of faith, a man of integrity, a man who upheld justice when it mattered most?

Or will they see exactly what you have shown me— A man who knew. A man who chose silence. A man who, even now, when faced with the undeniable truth of his own complicity, still seeks to suppress rather than to confess.

So tell me, Bryan, what happens now?

What will it be this time? Another whisper in the right ear? Another carefully placed suggestion? Another shadowed attempt to silence me?

Will you once again let false accusations rise, hoping they will make me disappear? Will you once again erase your words, hide behind your pulpit, and hope that the weight of truth never fully reaches you?

I have spent years writing to you. Years exposing the truth. Years pleading for accountability. Years offering you every opportunity to do what is right.

And after all this time, what have you given in return?

A hollow admission that you already knew. A feigned detachment from the very man you stood beside for decades. A single verse—ripped from Scripture, twisted into a shield, wielded not for righteousness, but for your own self-preservation.

No remorse. No responsibility. No courage.

You were given every chance to stand. Every chance to speak. Every chance to redeem yourself.

And yet, you have done nothing.

This is not love. This is not faith. This is not righteousness.

This is cowardice. This is complicity. This is a betrayal of the very principles you claim to uphold.

And so I leave you with this, Bryan— Not just my words, but your own.

Your silence. Your erasures. Your refusal to confront the harm you have allowed to persist.

You may continue to hide. You may continue to delete. You may continue to whisper in the dark, hoping that the truth will fade into nothingness.

But I will not fade.

And the truth will not disappear simply because you wish it would.

Shame on you, Pastor Bryan.

Shame on you.

What the message says

Dan interprets Bryan's statement that he knew the father's faults as an admission that he knowingly allowed deception, family separation, and institutional harm to continue.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Dan's moral principle is sound in general: knowing serious harm is occurring and possessing meaningful power to prevent it may create responsibility.

The factual bridge is the problem. General knowledge of "faults" does not automatically establish knowledge of each specific allegation, understanding it as wrongful, power to intervene, failure to act, or active reinforcement.

Dan's case is strongest where he identifies Bryan's own actions – harsh emails, judgments, defense of inherited accounts, and refusal to engage evidence – rather than inferring complete knowledge of everything the father did.

What it answers or contributes
  • Distinguishes documentation for accountability from record-keeping for retaliation
  • Announces publication as part of the intended accountability process
What remains open
  • What did Bryan mean by faults?
  • Which specific acts did he know?
  • What authority did he possess?
  • Did he actively reinforce or merely fail to challenge?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The finished page should say Dan interpreted the phrase as broader awareness and Bryan later rejected that interpretation as a lie.
43
"Complicit?" and "Stop bashing"
Bryan – February 13, 2025
+

Bryan rejects the complicity accusation as a lie, warns Dan about bitterness, and asks him to acknowledge the substantial good accomplished by his father.

DenialBitternessFather's good worksComplicity disputed
Original correspondence

February 13, 2025 7:32 AM  Bryan: 

Complicit? Oh, Dan! Such a lie. Beware of bitterness-blindness.

Another matter: Your father made an enormous contribution to good in this world by serving the Lord. How about some credit for that? Stop bashing.

What the message says

Bryan rejects the complicity accusation as a lie, warns Dan about bitterness, and asks him to acknowledge the substantial good accomplished by his father.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The reply is clear as denial but limited as explanation. Bryan does not define which inference is wrong, what faults he meant, what he knew, or what he did when he disagreed with the father.

The shift to the father's good answers a simpler claim than Dan is making. Dan's position is not that the father did nothing beneficial, but that good work does not erase responsibility for harm.

What it answers or contributes
  • Directly denies complicity
  • Introduces the father's good works as necessary context
What remains open
  • What did Bryan know?
  • Why does he regard Dan's inference as false?
  • How does acknowledged good affect responsibility for particular harm?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may regard the premise as so false and accusatory that detailed engagement would validate it. Dan experiences brevity and character judgment as another evasion.
44
The good was already in the record
Dan – February 13, 2025
+

Dan quotes his own praise of the father's food pantry to demonstrate that his account already includes gratitude and admiration alongside criticism.

FatherFood pantryGood and harmMemoirEvidence
Original correspondence

February 13, 2025 8:09AM Dan: Bryan,

You seem confident that I haven’t credited my father or acknowledged the good he has done. But I have—many times. For instance, page 431 of my book COR Values;

“As I listened, occasionally feeding him spoonfuls of rice and portions of chicken, his eyes widened to accentuate key moments in his stories. Every now and then a few grains of rice or other food would escape his mouth, finding their way to his cheek or chin. I would wipe them away, momentarily pausing his narrative.
Perhaps influenced by the heightened focus on his meal, he transitioned into his next topic, one that I had never en­countered before: “the food pantry.” I was about to embark on a journey of discovery, learning about it for the first time. The pride and joy on his face were unmistakable right from the start.
The purpose of the pantry was to provide food for the community, extending a helping hand to those who were less fortunate. It was heartwarming to hear such a positive story and understand the immense value this initiative brought to the community. Witnessing my father speak of it with enthu­siasm filled me with immense pleasure and pride, knowing that he had played a crucial role in its development. I also realized that without his involvement the program may never have come to fruition.
As he continued to discuss the impact of the pantry and its positive contributions to those in need, I became keenly aware of my need to proceed with caution in our conversa­tion, given the precarious nature of our relationship. I under­stood that a single misplaced word or misinterpreted inten­tion could have adverse consequences. With this in mind, as I wanted to express my perspective on what he had revealed, I selected my words carefully.
‘I want you to know that I think it’s wonderful, and I would have been pleased to be here, involved in such a mean­ingful project with you.’
He continued discussing the project, and I remained attentive.  However, a voice of pessimism began to emerge, whispering in my ear, reminding me of the cost associated with this positive occurrence.  The voice demanded recognition, as if to uphold my self-respect and integrity.  Engaged in a harmonious conversation with my father, I yearned to suppress these persistent thoughts that would undoubtedly disrupt our exchange. As my father continued to speak, it felt as if his voice receded into the background, and I became overwhelmed with a flood of persuasive arguments, compelling me to remind my father of the sacrifices made for what he was so proud to have accomplished.”

What the message says

Dan quotes his own praise of the father's food pantry to demonstrate that his account already includes gratitude and admiration alongside criticism.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is an effective documentary response. Instead of merely insisting he gave credit, Dan produces a published passage showing pride in the pantry and the father's contribution.

The passage proves that Dan acknowledged good. It does not prove every later judgment about the father or Bryan. Its narrower point is sufficient: the published record is not based on denying all benefit.

What it answers or contributes
  • Documents prior credit given to the father and pantry
What remains open
  • How should genuine good and genuine harm be weighed without allowing either to erase the other?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
This anticipates a central theme later articulated in WATCH: the good was real, and the harm was real.
45
Questions are not rebellion
Dan – February 14, 2025
+

Dan argues that Bryan responded to reasoning with character judgment, explains why he uses Scripture despite being an atheist, and defends questioning as essential to truthful leadership.

QuestionsScriptureInquiryLeadershipCharacter attack
Original correspondence

February 14, 2025 8:09AM Dan: 

Moving along, to address your other comments…

Your response to my sincere letter—written with care and thoughtful consideration after reading your claim that you already know everything about my father—is to accuse me of lying and warn me about bitterness and blindness. I had thought you were repentant about the disparaging way you’ve been responding to me. Is this truly all you have to offer?

You profess to be a Christian; I am not. The Bible, which you claim as your guiding rule, serves for me as a source of inspiration, filled with meaningful lessons—some I find valuable, others I believe are best left unheeded. My use of scripture when addressing your behavior is not to suggest that I view it as an ultimate authority, but rather to demonstrate the inconsistency between your professed beliefs and your actions. I made the effort to carefully reflect on what the Bible, your own guiding text, has to say about what you’ve done.

In your message, you suggest that you were aware of my father’s wrongdoing—you assert that you’re “not stupid” and knew all his faults. You claim to have “distinguished” yourself from him and that, now that he is gone, this distinction is becoming clearer as time passes. So, I turned to scripture to see what the Word of God—as you claim to follow—teaches regarding such situations. I did not respond with dismissive insults or hollow accusations. Instead, I dedicated myself to researching, organizing, and presenting ten pages of biblical reflections on the nature of responsibility, accountability, and the duty to confront wrongdoing.

Yet, in response, you chose to attack my character. Can you provide scriptural support that justifies your approach? I was specific in referencing passages that challenge your actions, pointing to verses that go so far as to command believers to address wrongdoing within their community. If I have misunderstood or misrepresented these scriptures, would it not be more constructive to correct me by presenting your interpretation, rather than resorting to personal attacks? When you quoted “love keeps no record of wrongs,” I took the time to research and respond with context. I didn’t dismiss you; I engaged with you. Why is it, then, that you feel compelled to respond with derision rather than reasoned discourse?

Perhaps the issue lies not in misunderstanding, but in disagreement. If you simply do not align with what the Bible teaches about this matter, I would respect your honesty if you said so outright. It would, at the very least, be a candid response. But these curt, dismissive remarks—these brief, disdainful lines meant to belittle rather than engage—resemble an admission of defeat more than a defense of your position.

So continue, if you must, to disparage me. But if you choose this path, I ask that you at least provide something substantial to support your words. Can you offer scripture, reasoned argument, or even a coherent explanation? Or will you persist in lashing out, offering nothing but hollow accusations in place of genuine dialogue?

I extended my hand in honest, thoughtful engagement. The question now is whether you will take it or continue to swat it away with empty words.

The Invaluable Pursuit of Questioning: A Day of Discovery

February 14, 2025  4:12PM

Pastor Bryan,

Today, I made the deliberate decision to take the entire day off to research this very topic: the value and necessity of questioning in the pursuit of truth. Our recent correspondence has compelled me to delve into this subject more deeply, as the nature of our dialogue has revealed just how critical this issue is—not only for our interactions but for the broader context of spiritual and intellectual leadership. I have immersed myself in scripture, philosophical writings, and historical insights, finding great joy in the process of discovery. It is a remarkable experience to see how knowledge, when placed against the backdrop of one’s own life and experiences, can illuminate new pathways of understanding. I am more than happy to share what I have learned with you, as I believe it speaks to something essential—not just for us individually, but for the broader practice of spiritual and intellectual leadership.

Your resistance to questions, Pastor Bryan, has not deterred me; instead, it has served as a catalyst for this journey of inquiry. The very nature of our exchanges has underscored how profoundly significant it is to challenge assumptions, to seek clarity, and to measure claims against the yardstick of evidence and lived experience. It is this dynamic that led me to pause my daily responsibilities and devote myself fully to this exploration. In doing so, I have not only gained a deeper understanding of the topic but also a renewed appreciation for the value of curiosity itself.

I write to you with both sincerity and conviction, compelled by a deep concern for the integrity and purpose of the role you hold—not merely as a leader within your congregation, but as a shepherd entrusted with guiding others toward truth. Scripture reminds us: “Test all things; hold fast what is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21). The pursuit of truth is not an act of defiance but one of reverence. Those who question, who seek, who knock, do so in obedience to the command given in Matthew 7:7: “Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and the door will be opened to you.” This pursuit transcends any singular faith tradition and speaks to a universal, human desire for understanding.

Allow me to be frank: You should be thanking me for bringing this matter to light. For decades, your church has maintained a practice, whether overt or subtle, of resisting questions directed toward its leadership. From the pulpit, there have been exhortations to “check the scriptures” and not take anyone’s word at face value. Yet, when sincere individuals follow that advice and come forward with genuine inquiries, they are met with resistance, dismissal, and, at times, personal attack. What good is such counsel if the very act of heeding it invites reproach?

To question is not to rebel; it is to engage, to seek, to learn. It is a demonstration of respect for truth, a recognition that truth has nothing to fear from examination. If something is true, it will withstand scrutiny; if it is not, then the scrutiny serves its rightful purpose in revealing the error. A community that silences questions is not protecting faith; it is undermining it, replacing genuine conviction with fragile conformity. What kind of foundation is built on fear of inquiry? Truth, as it is written, is like a city on a hill—it cannot be hidden (Matthew 5:14). A church that discourages questions is, in essence, placing that light under a basket.

A pastor who shies away from questions does not shield the truth; rather, he betrays his own fear of confronting uncertainty. Truth, if it is indeed truth, need not be guarded from inquiry. It stands, unwavering, against the winds of scrutiny. Consider the Bereans of Acts 17:11, who were described as “more noble” because they “searched the Scriptures daily to find out whether these things were so.” They did not accept the words of Paul—a man who met Christ on the road to Damascus—without question. Instead, they examined, tested, and discerned. And Paul, rather than rebuking their skepticism, commended it.

Pastors, as shepherds of their flocks, should not merely tolerate questions but welcome them with joy. A question is not an attack; it is a sign of engagement, of curiosity, of hunger for truth. And when we encounter a question for which we have no immediate answer, that moment should not stir defensiveness or hostility but humility and eagerness to learn. How can we claim to shepherd others if we ourselves resist growth? Is not knowledge itself an inexhaustible wellspring, one we can never fully comprehend? As it is written: “Oh, the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable his judgments, and his paths beyond tracing out!” (Romans 11:33).

When I ask questions, I do so not out of defiance, but out of a sincere desire to understand. I do not fear the discomfort of unanswered questions; I welcome it, for it is within that discomfort that growth occurs. I relish the moments when scrutiny meets me and I find myself without an answer. In those moments, I am reminded of my own limitations and the endless opportunities to learn. Indeed, today, I decided to take the day off to devote myself to researching this very topic. I have immersed myself in writings both ancient and modern, biblical and secular. I find great joy in this process of discovery, testing what I read against my own life and experiences, and finding insights that resonate with me deeply. What a privilege it is to uncover ideas of value, wherever they may be found.

I am an atheist, yet I have found profound wisdom in the pages of scripture, just as I have in many other sources of philosophical and intellectual thought. Truth is not confined to one book or one tradition; it is woven throughout human history, waiting to be uncovered by those who seek it with open minds and willing hearts. How wonderful it is to encounter understanding that transcends context, belief, and tradition—a testament to the shared human quest for meaning.

Leadership is not defined by the certainty of one’s answers but by the humility to acknowledge one’s limitations and the willingness to seek greater understanding. Jesus Himself, though fully divine in the eyes of believers, asked questions and welcomed them. He never turned away the sincere inquirer, regardless of how challenging the question might have been. As pastors, as thinkers, as humans, we should follow that example.

The church is not weakened by questions; it is strengthened by them. The church is not protected by silence; it is protected by truth. If the truth cannot withstand the weight of inquiry, it was never truth to begin with. The great theologian Augustine once said, “The truth is like a lion; you don’t have to defend it. Let it loose; it will defend itself.” Truth does not need walls of defensiveness or swords of character attacks. It needs open doors, open hearts, and open minds.

Pastor Bryan, I challenge you, with the utmost respect, to reconsider the stance you have taken toward questions and those who ask them. I challenge you to embrace the discomfort of uncertainty, to engage with those who seek understanding, and to model the very behavior that sincere seekers value. If you have no answer, admit it—then seek it. If you are challenged, listen—not to defend, but to understand. This is not merely about me, or you, or your church. It is about the integrity of inquiry itself, and the responsibility of those who claim to lead others in truth.

May we both, in our respective journeys, remain steadfast in the pursuit of truth, no matter how uncomfortable or humbling that pursuit may be. And may the words of Proverbs 27:17 guide us: “As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another.”

What the message says

Dan argues that Bryan responded to reasoning with character judgment, explains why he uses Scripture despite being an atheist, and defends questioning as essential to truthful leadership.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Dan's strongest principle is that leaders should not replace reasoned answers with labels such as bitter, rebellious, or unstable. Honest questions should not automatically be treated as disloyalty.

The message does not fully acknowledge that legitimate questions can be delivered through a repetitive, accusatory, or unlimited exchange. Ending one conversation does not necessarily establish fear of inquiry.

Any quotation attributed to Augustine should be verified or described as "often attributed" rather than presented as certain.

What it answers or contributes
  • Clarifies why Dan uses Bryan's stated authority – Scripture – in argument
  • Defends inquiry as compatible with faith and leadership
What remains open
  • When does a boundary reflect avoidance, and when does it reflect the practical limits of a particular conversation?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The page should examine whether Bryan replaced answers with labels while also examining whether the exchange had become structured so that no answer short of agreement was acceptable.
46
Bowing out and asking why
Bryan and Dan – February 17, 2025
+

Bryan says the exchange is going nowhere and asks to withdraw while leaving open lighter future contact. Dan asks why and offers to articulate what he believes Bryan has left unsaid.

WithdrawalBoundaryFutilityUnanswered questionsInterpretation
Original correspondence

February 17, 2025 7:48 AM  Bryan: 

Hi Dan, I’d like to bow out of this exchange. It’s clear to me we’re not getting anywhere. I love you, and perhaps we can share on some lighter and friendlier matters in the future.

February 17, 2025 8:07AM Dan: 

Bryan,
From the very first day we began our text exchange all those years ago, I have responded to every word you’ve shared with careful thought, integrity, and honesty. I have never ignored you or avoided the anything you’ve presented. In fact, I have delved deeply into every question you’ve asked and every comment you’ve made.
Yet, my questions and reflections have largely gone unanswered. The responsibility to continue this dialogue has rested with you for quite some time now. You are the pastor, the one who believes I need to be led to God—the one who asked what you could do to guide me there. All I ever needed was for you to engage with me sincerely, to respond not with dismissive remarks when faced with difficult questions, but with openness and authenticity.
Now that you’ve chosen to end our communication, can you at least offer me the honesty I’ve always extended to you? Why, Bryan, have you refused to truly engage with me? Why have you chosen disparagement over dialogue when I have laid my heart bare before you?
Must I be left to read between the lines once more, or can you, for once, tell me the truth? Why are you stepping away?

February 17, 2025 8:36AM Dan: 

Would it help if I tried to give voice to what you have left unsaid? I know it could never be exact, because truth, when genuine, must come from within you. But through all our exchanges, I have listened closely—not only to what you have shared, but also to what has remained unspoken. And I believe I have come to understand some of the reasons that keep you from engaging with me.

Would it help if I offered my understanding to you? I am more than willing to take the time to reflect deeply and compose a thoughtful response. My intent is not to accuse, but to understand, and perhaps bring clarity where there has been uncertainty. Maybe, in seeing the words that echo what you have felt but could not express, you might find your own voice. Perhaps it could help you recognize the value that honest and open dialogue can bring.

What the message says

Bryan says the exchange is going nowhere and asks to withdraw while leaving open lighter future contact. Dan asks why and offers to articulate what he believes Bryan has left unsaid.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Bryan clearly withdraws from the subject but does not declare that all future contact is forbidden. Dan wants a deeper reason sufficient to explain the failure of the dialogue.

Dan's offer to articulate Bryan's unspoken thoughts is revealing. He objects when others define his inner life, yet here offers to define Bryan's silence. That parallel touches the page's central question: who has the right to interpret another person?

What it answers or contributes
  • Bryan states that the exchange is unproductive
  • Dan asks for the deeper reason behind withdrawal
What remains open
  • Is there a hidden reason beyond those Bryan already stated?
  • Would Dan accept a reason that did not validate his interpretation?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan had already cited accusations, publication concerns, time, lack of interest in the relationship, and belief that the premises were false. Dan considers those reasons inadequate; they are nevertheless stated reasons.
47
Futility
Bryan – February 19, 2025
+

Bryan declines Dan's offer to interpret his unspoken reasons, says he has no time for futility, and recommends that Dan view the clash the same way.

Final refusalFutilityBoundaryNo resolution
Original correspondence

February 19, 2025 7:27 AM  Bryan: 

No thanks, Dan. I don’t have time for futility. I suggest you view this clash the same way.

What the message says

Bryan declines Dan's offer to interpret his unspoken reasons, says he has no time for futility, and recommends that Dan view the clash the same way.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is the clearest statement that Bryan no longer believes further communication on these subjects can produce value.

He refuses the interpretive offer and the premise that more explanation will bring understanding. He does not say that every question is illegitimate or that Dan may never speak publicly about his own experience.

What it answers or contributes
  • Ends substantive engagement at this stage
What remains open
  • Which particular conclusions made the exchange futile?
  • Could a neutral process have succeeded where direct messaging failed?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Dan treats this as the end of dialogue and begins rendering public judgment rather than seeking explanation.

Part Seven – From unanswered questions to public judgment

After Bryan calls the exchange futile, questions become verdicts, evidence is offered inside increasingly condemnatory messages, and exposure replaces reconciliation.

48
The demand for public correction
Dan – February 19, 2025 – 10:02 AM
+

Dan presents a final assessment, interprets knowledge of the father's faults as complicity, and demands a public correction from the pulpit.

Public correctionComplicityFinal assessmentPulpitUltimatum
Original correspondence

February 19, 2025 10:02 AM Dan: 

Bryan,

As this appears to be the end of our dialogue—though you refuse to allow me to extend a hand in helping you articulate what you already known but cannot bring yourself to say—I will summarize what I have learned about you.

This was never truly a dialogue. I have engaged with you in good faith, answering every question you have posed with sincerity, depth, and care. I have written to you with deliberate thought, providing thorough explanations, laying out my reasoning, and offering you the opportunity to respond in kind. But you have not done the same for me. My questions have gone unanswered, my comments disregarded, and, when you have found yourself without an adequate response, your recourse has been to attack my character rather than engage with my words.

The Shield of Evasion: How You Have Responded to Truth

Every time I have pressed you for an honest response, you have resorted to ad hominem deflection—a tactic used by those who feel threatened by the truth. Rather than addressing the issue, rather than meeting the challenge of actual accountability, you have chosen to attack me.

This is how the ad hominem attack works:

  1. It shifts the focus. Instead of engaging with what is being said, the person redirects attention to the character, motives, or past of the one speaking.
  2. It creates an illusion of superiority. Rather than acknowledging a failure to provide an adequate response, the person attempts to frame themselves as morally or intellectually above their opponent.
  3. It silences discussion. By making the conversation about me rather than the issue, you attempt to avoid the issue entirely.

This is not just a logical fallacy; it is a moral failing. It is dishonest. It is cowardice. And most importantly, it is a sign of guilt. Because when a person has truth on their side, they do not need to attack the one asking the questions. They simply answer.

Bryan, You Knew.

Despite all your attempts to evade, you finally let the truth slip:

“You cannot reveal anything, anything whatsoever, to me about your dad. I worked with him closer than anyone else for 45 years. I’m not stupid. I knew all his faults.”

That is an admission of complicity. It is an acknowledgment that, for decades, you stood by and let it happen.

Let’s be very clear about what you just admitted to knowing:

  • That my father intentionally tore families apart under the guise of righteousness.
  • That he created a doctrine that demanded absolute obedience at the cost of human relationships.
  • That he manipulated people, including his own children, into a false binary: Serve God, or be cast away forever.
  • That he lied—repeatedly, publicly, and with full knowledge of the consequences.
  • That these lies were not just about doctrine—they were personal. That he vilified me, twisted my life into a cautionary tale, and ensured that I would be estranged from my family.

And, Bryan, you watched it all. You stood by while it happened. You stood behind my father. You enforced his doctrine. You contributed to the culture of fear, shame, and control that kept people in line.

And now, years later, you want to pretend that you were different.

You claim that you “tried to distinguish” yourself from him. But what does distinction matter if you stood by and let it continue?

What does it matter that you saw the corruption if you did nothing to stop it?

What does it matter that you knew my father’s teachings were destroying lives if you stood in the pulpit and continued to preach them?

You knew, Bryan. And yet, you did nothing.

The Consequence of Your Silence: My Life Without My Family

And what has your silence cost?

You may think this is just a theological dispute, just a matter of doctrine, just one man’s bitterness toward the past. But that is not what this is about.

This is about the fact that because of my father—and because of you, who upheld and enforced what he taught—I have lived a lifetime without my family.

  • For decades, my mother was separated from me, believing that any relationship with me was sinful.
  • For decades, my siblings were told that I was poison—that to associate with me would put their very souls at risk.
  • For decades, I lived in exile—not because I had done something terrible, but because I would not bow to the doctrine of control that you upheld.
  • I lost my family, my sense of belonging, my entire foundation—all because of the false narrative that you and my father created and allowed to continue unchallenged.
  • I suffered a mental breakdown, institutionalization, deep psychological trauma—not because of personal failure, but because I was forced into a battle for my own identity, my own reality, my own right to exist outside of your control.

And here I am, at 63 years old, only now beginning to piece my family back together—only now, after decades of damage, trying to repair what you and my father destroyed.

And yet, to this day, your church still upholds the false narrative about me.

That is evil.

Yes, Bryan—evil.

Not a mistake. Not a misunderstanding. Evil.

A man does not accidentally tear a child from his family.

A man does not accidentally turn siblings into strangers.

A man does not accidentally stand before a congregation and paint a son as an enemy.

It takes intent. It takes action. It takes deliberate cruelty disguised as righteousness.

And now, the only way forward is for you to do what you should have done years ago:

Tell the Truth. Publicly. From Your Pulpit.

If you are truly a man of integrity, a man of faith, a man who wants to do right, then you must correct the falsehoods that still live within your church—falsehoods you helped create.

You must stand before your congregation and tell them that what they have been taught about me is a lie.

You must tell them that the doctrine that tore me from my family was a tool of control, not of God.

You must tell them that what my father did to me, what you allowed to happen to me, what was preached about me—was evil.

If you do not, then every moment you continue in silence is another moment in which you knowingly uphold a falsehood.

If you do not, then every sermon you preach is built on a foundation of deception.

And if you do not, then let it be known that you are not a man of God—you are a fraud, a coward, and an accomplice to decades of suffering.

The choice is yours.

Daniel Mazur

What the message says

Dan presents a final assessment, interprets knowledge of the father's faults as complicity, and demands a public correction from the pulpit.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is the shift from inquiry to judgment. Dan treats selective engagement as evidence of guilt, translates an ambiguous reference to faults into knowledge of the full alleged history, and presents public confession as the only response consistent with integrity.

The record supports that many questions were unanswered and that Bryan knew the father had faults. It does not establish that he knew every listed act or consequence.

The strongest principle is that established public harm may require public correction. The factual questions underlying that remedy remain disputed.

What it answers or contributes
  • States the remedy Dan ultimately seeks: correction from the pulpit
What remains open
  • What exactly was said publicly?
  • What did Bryan know?
  • What form of correction would be proportionate?
  • Can denial or qualification occur without becoming proof of guilt?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may experience this as a coerced confession to allegations he does not accept, backed by threatened public condemnation.
49
David and the continuing family cost
Dan – February 19, 2025 – 10:48 AM
+

Dan asks whether Bryan will speak to his brother David and argues that the church's account of the past continues to prevent family reconciliation.

DavidFamily estrangementRepairChurch narrativeMotive attributed
Original correspondence

February 19, 2025 10:48 AM Dan: 

Bryan,

And what about my brother, David?

You said it yourself—you are not stupid. You knew all along. You knew the harm my father inflicted, the deception he wove, the damage he left in his wake. You knew what was being done to me. You knew what was being done to others. And yet, you stood by.

So tell me, Bryan—was David also aware? Was he complicit like you? Or do you think he, and all the others who still believe the false narrative you continue to support, are stupid?

You wouldn’t—by chance—want to talk with him, would you? You wouldn’t, by some rare stroke of conscience, want to sit him down and tell him the truth?

Because David will not talk to me.

Not because of anything I have done, but because he harbors the lies your church allowed, encouraged, and reinforced. Lies that our father carefully cultivated. Lies that you—knowing full well they were false—did nothing to dismantle.

And as a result, he has kept his family from me, just as our father kept my siblings from me. You have watched this happen. You have let it happen. And you have done nothing to stop it.

Why would I think of you as anything other than selfish? Why would I see you as anything but heartless?

You do not care if I ever speak to my brother again.

You do not care if these falsehoods keep me cut off from my own family.

You do not care about the immense, lifelong damage you have played a part in.

All of this—all of it—is a direct consequence of the doctrine you upheld, the silence you maintained, the deceit you enabled. And yet, you will not lift a finger to set things right.

Tell me, Bryan—what kind of man watches another be torn from his family, sees the suffering it causes, and chooses to do nothing?

I believe I already know the answer.

You want me to disappear. That is the real desire beneath your final message to me. You wish I would just go away, vanish, stop pressing, stop exposing, stop holding you accountable for what you refuse to confront.

But I will not.

Because truth does not disappear just because you wish it would.

And neither will I.

Daniel Mazur

What the message says

Dan asks whether Bryan will speak to his brother David and argues that the church's account of the past continues to prevent family reconciliation.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The concrete request – Will you speak with David? – should be visually separated from the surrounding accusations. It asks Bryan to use relationship or influence to help reopen a family bond.

The message assumes that church falsehoods are the primary cause and that Bryan has influence David would welcome. It later moves from impact to intention by saying Bryan wants Dan to disappear, a motive claim not established by the record.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Would Bryan speak with David?
  • Had he discussed Dan with him?
  • Did David want Bryan involved?
  • What did Bryan believe caused the estrangement?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Bryan may regard intervention between adult brothers as inappropriate or based on premises he disputes. The lack of response leaves this unexplained.
50
If not a friend, then what?
Dan – February 19, 2025 – 2:08 PM
+

Dan asks whether Bryan should be understood as an enemy because he allegedly knew of injustice, benefited from the system, and refused to act.

EnemySilenceIdentity judgmentInstitutional benefitMoral classification
Original correspondence

February 19, 2025 2:08 PM Dan: 

Bryan,

I have never thought of anyone in my life as my enemy. Not my father, despite all he did to shape the world in a way that left me outside of it. Not my siblings, even as they turned away from me, believing the lies that were handed down to them. Not the church that cast me out, that made me a cautionary tale, that ensured I would live as an exile among my own blood.

But you… I find myself wondering.

Could it be that you are my enemy?

I do not ask this lightly. I am not one to throw words like that around. I do not see life in the simple binaries that you do—good and evil, believer and heretic, saved and damned. But when I strip away the sentimentality, when I peel back the layers of personal history, what am I left with?

An enemy is not merely someone who disagrees with you. He is not merely someone who sees the world differently.

An enemy is someone who knows the truth but refuses to stand by it.

An enemy is someone who sees injustice, sees suffering, sees harm, and chooses silence over action.

An enemy is someone who—knowing full well the damage that has been done—continues to uphold the very system that caused it.

And Bryan, that is exactly what you have done.

You knew. You knew all along. You stood next to my father for 45 years and, in your own words, knew his faults. You knew what he did to me. You knew what he did to others. You knew the ways in which he twisted doctrine into a weapon—not to save souls, but to keep them under his control.

And yet, you said nothing. You did nothing. You let it happen.

And now, even after his death, even after the weight of what he has done still hangs in the air, poisoning relationships, ensuring that my own brother refuses to speak with me, you still do nothing.

Would a friend do that? Would a man of integrity do that?

Or would an enemy?

I have spent my entire life resisting hatred, resisting bitterness, resisting the temptation to see those who have wronged me as opponents instead of victims of their own delusions. I have tried, again and again, to believe that those who stand in my way are not doing so out of malice, but out of fear, out of ignorance, out of an inability to confront the truth.

But you?

You are not ignorant.
You are not afraid.
You are not blind to what has happened.

You are fully aware. And yet, you choose to protect the lie rather than expose it.

So tell me, Bryan—what is the difference between that and an enemy?

If someone seeks to erase you, to rewrite the truth about your life, to perpetuate the very system that tore your family apart—what else can he be?

I do not want to believe this of you. I have spent years resisting it. But you have left me with so little choice. Because if you are not my enemy, then what does that make you?

A friend? A neutral party? A man simply caught between forces beyond his control?

No.

A friend does not sit in silence while lies are told about someone he knows.
A neutral party does not benefit from a system of harm and pretend he has no part in it.
A man who is caught between forces does not preach the very doctrine that upholds those forces.

You may not have built the machine. But you stood beside it. You fed it. You watched it do its work, and you stood by knowing that it was built on deception, that it destroyed lives, that it twisted love into control.

And when the time came to set the record straight, you turned your back.

You would prefer that I did not exist, because my existence makes you uncomfortable. My presence reminds you of what you have done and failed to do. You may not wish me harm, but your indifference has caused it. You may not call yourself my enemy, but your actions—or your refusal to act—speak louder than any title.

So tell me, Bryan. If not an enemy, then what are you?

Because from where I stand, I am running out of other options.

Daniel Mazur

What the message says

Dan asks whether Bryan should be understood as an enemy because he allegedly knew of injustice, benefited from the system, and refused to act.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The deepest question is whether refusal by a knowledgeable and influential person creates a relationship of opposition even without personal hatred.

The message becomes total when it moves from describing function – actions working against Dan's interests – to identity – Bryan as enemy. It also creates a narrow set of categories after criticizing the church for similar moral compression.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • Can Bryan's conduct be described as harmful without settling his inner intention?
  • Does institutional benefit create responsibility, and at what level?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Dan may be naming the practical effect rather than alleging hatred. Bryan may experience the word enemy as confirmation that the exchange has become hostile.
51
Conspiracy and the refusal of the premise
Bryan – February 19, 2025 – time to verify
+

Bryan denies that the church discusses, maligns, or lies about Dan, disputes Dan's account of the father's public statements, and says healthy conversation is impossible when Dan insists on what Bryan regards as conspiracy.

Direct denialConspiracyPublic statementsMemoryConversation ends
Original correspondence

February 19, 2025 7:27 AM  Bryan: 

You believe many things that are not true. We at the church don’t talk about you. We don’t malign you or lie about you. I have never referred to you publicly. Your father did a couple times over forty years ago, only in grief as I recall. He never called you poison in my hearing. But you insist all these things happened and continue to happen. No they didn’t. No they don’t. But you continue to insist. So how can I have a healthy conversation with you? Waste of time. Someone who believes in conspiracies cannot be convinced otherwise.

What the message says

Bryan denies that the church discusses, maligns, or lies about Dan, disputes Dan's account of the father's public statements, and says healthy conversation is impossible when Dan insists on what Bryan regards as conspiracy.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This message contains direct factual denials and should be presented clearly. Bryan says he did not refer to Dan publicly, the church does not currently discuss him, and he did not hear the father call him poison.

The wording "in my hearing" is narrower than saying the father never used the word. A recording may establish that the father said it without proving that Bryan heard it.

The conspiracy label may express a genuine belief that Dan has connected events incorrectly, while also placing Dan's capacity to interpret evidence under suspicion.

What it answers or contributes
  • Directly denies several broader allegations
  • Explains why Bryan believes the conversation cannot be healthy
What remains open
  • Did Bryan listen to the audio?
  • Would he review additional recordings?
  • Did other leaders make statements?
  • Could mistaken memory be distinguished from conspiracy?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Dan sees the label as discrediting without examining evidence. Bryan may see repeated denials absorbed into a theory where disagreement itself becomes concealment.
53
A second witness to institutional harm
Dan quoting a former member – February 22, 2025
+

Dan shares a message from a former member whose family reportedly remains damaged by experiences at the church and school.

Former memberCorroborationThird-party accountFamily harmAnonymous witness
Original correspondence

Saturday, February 22, 2025

Dan: Today, I find myself far from the familiar, nestled in the serene refuge of Homosassa, Florida, where for a brief interlude I am on vacation with my mother and her sister. In this gentle reunion, my mother’s voice has shed the burdens of old secrecy, reemerging as the warm, unguarded presence I cherished when I was merely eleven—a time when her love was pure and unblemished, unsullied by the corrosive influences of you, my father, and the church.
It is profoundly moving to engage in such unfiltered conversation, so starkly different from those rare, furtive calls of a decade past. I vividly recall those moments when, from Syracuse, my mother’s voice would reach me in Miami, only to be abruptly silenced by a whispered, “I’ve got to go, your father is coming.” These clandestine exchanges, shrouded in mystery and unspoken sorrow, have long served as painful reminders of a bond fractured by hidden truths.
And yet, in a cruel twist of fate, it was only after my father’s passing that our genuine connection began to reawaken. Still, the scars remain—not only in the echoes of our lost past but also in the enduring shadow cast by the church you now shepherd as pastor. The letter I include, received this very morning, comes from a former member whose own family was shattered by that very institution—an institution that, under your stewardship, has similarly contributed to the ruin of my family and the fragile remnants of the bond I once shared with my mother.
Bryan, though you may remain indifferent to this tender transformation, I refuse to let the darkness of your deeds—and the insidious legacy of that church—fade into oblivion. In this bittersweet symphony of memory and revelation, the past and present intertwine, urging us never to overlook the devastating cost at which healing sometimes comes.
The Letter…
Good morning Daniel. Wanted to let you know that I’ve read both of your books. Read Cor Values twice.
Thank you for writing them. I’d like to say I’m so sorry for all the pain you’ve endured through the years.
My family till this day are still broken because of the things that happened to them at LW over many years. And things that happened to them at the LWA school.
Those who were supposed to love and protect them did the opposite by those who said they were and are Christians. I love you and always have loved you. Love XXXXX
Now, what will you say? Will you dismiss these truths as mere conspiracy and fabrication, accusing me of lying—while you continue to conspire solely to serve your own interests? Let these words lodge deep within you as you deliver your Sunday sermon, a constant reminder of the accountability you cannot escape. Even as you pursue your self-serving agenda, know that I watch, and these words will remain with you—a silent witness to the path you have chosen, one that defies the very message of the Bible calling for peace and unity.
In this convergence of memory, truth, and revelation, let it be known that the price of healing is measured in irrevocable loss, and the voices of the betrayed must never be silenced.

What the message says

Dan shares a message from a former member whose family reportedly remains damaged by experiences at the church and school.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The statement supports a narrow but meaningful proposition: Dan is not the only person who reports serious harm associated with the institution.

It does not establish details, responsible individuals, Bryan's knowledge, or whether the events resemble Dan's. The testimony will be stronger if separated visually from Dan's condemnatory framing.

What it answers or contributes
  • Adds another first-person report of institutional harm
What remains open
  • Has the writer consented to publication?
  • What events, dates, and responsible actors are involved?
  • What part, if any, did Bryan play?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Label redactions and permission status. Take the witness seriously while also asking for sufficient detail to evaluate the claim.
52
The recording as evidence
Dan – February 19, 2025 – 3:49 PM
+

Dan responds to the conspiracy accusation by offering a digital recording of his father and argues that denials cannot erase what was said.

Audio evidenceFather's wordsMemoryContextIntent attributed
Original correspondence

February 19, 2025 3:49 PM Dan: 

Subject: The Truth Stands, Unshaken

Bryan,

You call it conspiracy. I call it memory—clear, unwavering, and undeniable. Do you mean to say that my own firsthand experiences, the things I saw, heard, and endured, are false? That I imagined the words spoken against me? That I fabricated the warnings, the condemnation, the label of poison that stained my name?

You claim my father spoke of me only in grief, only a couple of times. But his words were not born of sorrow. They were filled with rage, with contempt, with a deliberate warning to others to keep their distance from me. You dismiss this as if I did not hear it with my own ears. But I did. And unlike you, I do not rely on hollow denials. I have proof. The past was not only etched into my memory but captured on cassette tape. I no longer have a cassette player, but I do have digital recordings. I am attaching a snippet here.

What will you say next? That I fabricated his voice? That I forged the evidence? You will not retract your false claims. You will not apologize. That would require integrity—something you have never shown.

This is not about what is being said today. The past remains unresolved because the damage was never corrected. The wounds you and others inflicted were never mended, and so they persist. Because of this false narrative left unchallenged, those like my brother David still do not see me as I am, as I always was.

I have laid this before you in painstaking detail, not once, but many times. You refuse to acknowledge it because you know it is true. You say nothing because to do so would mean dismantling the falsehood you have helped preserve. Your silence is not ignorance. It is intent.

You do not care whether I have a relationship with my family, and you certainly will not lift a finger to assist in the justice that could restore what was taken. Instead, you retreat further into denial, as if mere words could erase the truth. But truth is not so easily undone.

For decades, you have been complicit. You refuse to acknowledge it. You, who claim the title of pastor, have an obligation to seek justice, to right wrongs, to act in the spirit of Christ. Instead, you dismiss the harm, you shield the guilty, you twist the truth to serve your own convenience.

So tell me, Bryan—what does that make you? A man of God? Or a deceiver?

At this point, I find it impossible to believe you are a Christian at all. Your actions do not align with Christ but with those who stand against Him. Scripture warns of false teachers—those who twist faith into something self-serving, those who masquerade as righteous while shutting the door of truth in others’ faces.

“For false messiahs and false prophets will appear and perform great signs and wonders to deceive, if possible, even the elect.” — Matthew 24:24

“Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You shut the door of the kingdom of heaven in people’s faces. You yourselves do not enter, nor will you let those enter who are trying to.” — Matthew 23:13

Do these words not describe men like you? Those who manipulate faith for their own ends, who wear the robe of righteousness but refuse to uphold its weight?

If you had even a shred of sincerity, you would acknowledge the harm done, seek to correct it, and demonstrate the integrity you pretend to possess. But I do not expect that from you.

The Bible warns of men like you—false teachers who reject accountability, who pervert truth, who stand in pulpits speaking of righteousness while their actions reveal something else entirely.

“For such people are false apostles, deceitful workers, masquerading as apostles of Christ. And no wonder, for Satan himself masquerades as an angel of light. It is not surprising, then, if his servants also masquerade as servants of righteousness. Their end will be what their actions deserve.” — 2 Corinthians 11:13-15

And what does Scripture say of shepherds like you?

“Son of man, prophesy against the shepherds of Israel; prophesy and say to them: ‘This is what the Sovereign Lord says: Woe to you shepherds of Israel who only take care of yourselves! Should not shepherds take care of the flock? You eat the curds, clothe yourselves with the wool and slaughter the choice animals, but you do not take care of the flock. You have not strengthened the weak or healed the sick or bound up the injured. You have not brought back the strays or searched for the lost. You have ruled them harshly and brutally.’” — Ezekiel 34:2-4

This is your legacy, Bryan. You were entrusted with a flock, yet you have led them astray. You have silenced the weak, dismissed the wounded, and abandoned those harmed by the church’s failings. You were given a position meant for healing, yet you have used it for harm. You do not serve righteousness. You serve self-preservation.

And here is the great irony, one I doubt you will ever grasp. You once asked me what you could do to bring me to Christ. Perhaps you have done exactly that, not through your faith, but through your failure. Not by embodying truth, but by standing so boldly in opposition to it that I could not ignore the contrast.

In your corruption, I have uncovered Scripture that speaks to something real, something undeniable. Not the doctrine you preach, but the justice it warns about. Not the rituals you perform, but the truth they were meant to represent. Today, I understand more clearly than ever what is necessary. The world has always known men like you. False teachers. Deceivers. Those who claim to serve God while serving only themselves.

The Bible does not only caution against your kind. It condemns you. And I have seen with my own eyes the very destruction it warns against.

 

audio link;  https://drive.datadupe.com/f/c6564b9a1fab41ef9458/

 

What the message says

Dan responds to the conspiracy accusation by offering a digital recording of his father and argues that denials cannot erase what was said.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This may be the most important evidentiary moment. The recording can potentially establish exact words, tone, setting, and approximate date.

It cannot by itself establish that Bryan heard, endorsed, repeated, or intentionally concealed the statement, nor that current church members continue it.

Dan supplies evidence but also predicts that Bryan will not retract because he lacks integrity. That framing makes examination harder by classifying any nonconfessional response in advance.

What it answers or contributes
  • Offers potentially primary documentary evidence
What remains open
  • Speaker, date, setting, completeness, and authenticity should be documented
  • What exact proposition does the recording prove?
  • Did Bryan hear or know about it?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Create a dedicated evidence card with excerpt, full-context link, transcript, provenance, Dan's asserted meaning, and limits.
54
A reckoning no longer presented as dialogue
Dan – February 23, 2025
+

Dan organizes his accumulated judgment under themes such as defensiveness, vague apology, spiritual deflection, gaslighting, narrative control, performative reconciliation, and public exposure.

Final assessmentGaslightingReconciliationPublic exposureRhetorical summary
Original correspondence

Sunday, February 23, 2025

Dan: 

Subject: A Reckoning You Can No Longer Avoid

Bryan,

Your words and actions have painted a clear picture of the man you are—a man who hides behind faith while evading responsibility, a man who manipulates with religious platitudes rather than confronting the damage he has caused. This letter is not an invitation for reconciliation; it is a statement of truth, a reckoning for the harm you have done and the self-serving narratives you continue to uphold.

Defensive Posture and Deflection

From the very start of our correspondence, you have been defensive. When I challenged the sincerity of your public offer for reconciliation, you immediately framed my response as “caustic and cynical.” Instead of engaging with the substance of my concerns, you shut down meaningful dialogue.

You have repeatedly avoided direct engagement with my pointed questions, shifting the focus away from yourself and onto me—questioning my tone, implying that I am too critical, and accusing me of misunderstanding your intentions. This is not the behavior of a man who seeks truth or reconciliation. It is the behavior of a man who fears exposure.

Evasion and Lack of Direct Accountability

You refuse to clearly state what you are apologizing for. Instead of acknowledging specific wrongs, you offer vague, blanket statements such as, “Please forgive me for the unnecessary, unhelpful pain I have caused you.” This is a non-apology—it lacks ownership, specificity, and sincerity.

When pressed for details, you either ignore the request or change the subject. Even when you offer an admission, such as “Shame on me, I gave up on you”, it is carefully framed in a way that minimizes your responsibility. You present yourself as a passive participant in my estrangement, rather than an active enforcer of the church’s harmful practices.

The Use of Spiritual Language as a Shield

Rather than facing the specifics of your wrongdoing, you lean on religious platitudes to evade deeper discussion. You pivot to talking about Jesus, repentance, and healing without addressing the actual grievances at hand. When I called out your inconsistency, you retreated behind your faith, suggesting that true healing comes only through surrender to Jesus rather than through personal accountability.

Your final messages were particularly revealing: “I think Jesus disagrees with your healing technique” and “Healing happens when we surrender to Him.” These responses are nothing more than attempts to sidestep responsibility by placing the burden on me to forgive, while you escape the discomfort of reckoning with your actions.

Subtle Manipulation and Gaslighting

Your tactics are textbook examples of gaslighting. You downplay the significance of my concerns, suggesting that I am overly fixated on the past or that I am misinterpreting events. You insist that the church rarely talks about me and that “we hardly think about you,” despite the years of misrepresentation and slander against me from the pulpit.

When confronted with your past wrongs, your response was not to engage with the details but to cast doubt on my perception: “You don’t have an accurate picture of what is going on in our church community regarding yourself.” This is a classic deflection—dismissing my reality rather than taking responsibility for the role you and the church have played in shaping it.

Selective Engagement and Control of the Narrative

You engage only when it serves you. When I push deeper, you withdraw. You initially responded to my messages, but when the conversation became too uncomfortable, you slowed your replies and eventually ceased communication altogether.

Your last significant message was telling: “You should stop. You’re not our teacher.” With this, you positioned yourself as the authority, the one in control, deciding when the conversation was over. It was never about hearing me out—it was about maintaining dominance over the dialogue, ensuring that you dictated the terms of engagement.

Performative Apologies and Public Image Management

Your so-called reconciliation efforts were never genuine; they were a performance. Your public declaration that you were open to reconciliation was designed for appearances, not for real accountability. When I challenged you directly and privately, you distanced yourself, made excuses, and eventually shut down communication.

You never intended to make amends. You intended to control the optics. When it became clear that I would not allow you to shape the narrative to your liking, you retreated.

Projection and Framing Me as the Problem

You have attempted to frame me as obsessive, as though my repeated efforts to seek answers and accountability are the real issue, rather than the wrongs that led to my estrangement in the first place. Your comment about “riding on your father’s coattails” was a blatant attempt to diminish my credibility and agency, as if my words only carry weight because of my father, rather than the strength of my own experiences and reasoning.

And when you told me, “I really don’t want to block your number because we may need to communicate one day, right?”—this was nothing more than an attempt to position yourself as the reasonable party, subtly implying that I am the one crossing boundaries.

Final Assessment of Your Character

Bryan, your actions reveal the truth of who you are:

  • You do not genuinely seek reconciliation; you seek the appearance of reconciliation.
  • You avoid deep introspection and accountability, offering only vague apologies without real acknowledgment of harm.
  • You are more concerned with preserving the church’s image than with correcting past wrongs.
  • You subtly gaslight and reframe concerns as invalid or obsessive, rather than engaging with them sincerely.
  • You ultimately withdraw when the conversation reaches a point where you would have to truly reckon with your past actions.

The Consequence of Your Choices

Understand this: your words and actions will not remain hidden. Others will be made aware of what you have done. You have chosen to evade, deflect, and manipulate rather than engage in true reconciliation. That choice has consequences.

You are not the first religious leader to behave this way, and unfortunately, you will not be the last. But what you fail to see is that the world is changing. The systems that once protected men like you are crumbling. People are waking up to the deception, the hypocrisy, the hollow performances masquerading as faith. And those who refuse to acknowledge their part in the harm will find themselves exposed.

You have had every opportunity to face the truth. You have had every chance to engage with sincerity, humility, and accountability. But you have shown, time and again, that you are unwilling.

And so, Bryan, this is where we leave things—not in reconciliation, not in healing, but in truth. A truth that will not be buried, that will not be rewritten, that will not be controlled by you.

What the message says

Dan organizes his accumulated judgment under themes such as defensiveness, vague apology, spiritual deflection, gaslighting, narrative control, performative reconciliation, and public exposure.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

This is Dan's closing argument and is useful as a contemporaneous statement of his conclusions. It should not serve as the site's neutral final analysis.

Several concerns are strongly supported: tone criticism, selective engagement, withdrawal, coattails, publication objection, and unanswered questions.

Other labels require qualification. Bryan did offer specific apologies. Gaslighting is not established by disagreement alone. Claims that he never intended amends or withdrew only because he was exposed are motive inferences.

The message interprets nearly every possible response within one framework. An explanation that makes apology optics, boundaries control, disagreement gaslighting, silence guilt, and withdrawal fear becomes difficult to test.

What it answers or contributes
  • Makes the intended shift from reconciliation to public reckoning explicit
What remains open
  • Which labels are descriptions, which are interpretations, and which require stronger evidence?
  • Can exposure be accountability without becoming coercive pressure?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The page should test Dan's summary against the whole record rather than simply endorse it.
55
Exposure replaces reconciliation
Dan – February 23, 2025
+

Dan invokes To Catch a Predator as an analogy for concealed conduct meeting documentary exposure and ends with a public ultimatum.

ExposureAnalogyMoral comparisonUltimatumRhetorical escalation
Original correspondence

Sunday, February 23, 2025

Dan: 

Subject: To Catch a Preditor

Bryan,

Picture this: A man steps into a house, believing he has maintained control of the situation, that his actions will remain unseen, and that his narrative—the one he has carefully sculpted—will shield him from consequence. Then, from the shadows, Chris Hansen emerges and utters the words that cause the foundation of his deception to crumble: “Why don’t you have a seat?” Suddenly, he is no longer the one dictating the terms of reality. He is confronted by the weight of his own words, the undeniable evidence of his intentions, and the inescapable truth that he can no longer manipulate the situation to his advantage.

You, Bryan, have now found yourself in such a moment.

For years, you have projected an image of righteousness while operating within a carefully crafted framework of selective omission, self-preservation, and deflection. You have spoken of reconciliation while ensuring that true accountability never finds a foothold in your words. You have rewritten history to serve your own ends, reinforcing the illusion that your hands are clean while those you cast aside are painted as bitter, lost, or mistaken. But now, the truth sits before you—undeniable, unaltered, and demanding reckoning.

The Devastation You Have Left in Your Wake

When society speaks of harm, it often fixates on the visible—the tangible wounds of physical violence, the unmistakable scars of abuse. And yet, the human soul can be fractured in ways unseen, in ways just as lasting, if not more so. The damage inflicted by the predator is understood in the suffering of their victims, the lifelong struggle for healing, the dismantling of trust. But what of those whose wounds are not so easily named?

You once told me, “Shame on me, I gave up on you.” And you did. You gave up on truth. You gave up on honesty. You gave up on the responsibility that comes with leadership—the moral burden of ensuring that your words and actions align with integrity. And in doing so, you did something far worse than abandoning one person—you abandoned the very principles you claimed to uphold.

You spoke of me as if I were an illness to be quarantined. You ensured that my name, my choices, my pursuit of truth were framed as a warning rather than an example. You turned those who should have embraced me into gatekeepers, guarding against a version of reality that you could not control. And now, you stand exposed—not by malice, not by vengeance, but by the simple force of truth refusing to remain buried.

What of the child who grows up knowing that their family has been severed—not by tragedy, not by the natural unraveling of time, but by ideological control and forced estrangement? What of the son who watches his father, his mother, his siblings slowly turn away, not because of any crime committed, but because one man—a pastor, a leader—deemed it necessary for the preservation of an institution? What of those who are taught that truth is secondary to obedience, that faith demands sacrifice, but only of those who challenge authority?

A predator takes a child’s innocence. You have taken far more: the fundamental fabric of belonging, the foundation of love and connection that binds a family together. The child who suffers at the hands of a predator must fight to reclaim their sense of safety, their autonomy, their ability to trust. But the one who suffers at the hands of a leader like you must grapple with something even more insidious—the knowledge that those they once loved, those they once trusted, have abandoned them in service to a lie.

The Historical Precedent: Religious Leaders Who Rewrite Truth

History is littered with men like you, Bryan. Those who wield power not as a means of guidance, but as an instrument of control. The Church once silenced Galileo, branding him a heretic for daring to suggest that the earth was not the center of the universe. It took centuries before the Vatican admitted its error, but in the meantime, how many voices were drowned out? How many lives were shaped by an institution that placed its own authority over the pursuit of truth?

You have done the same, not on a grand historical scale, but in the microcosm of your church and your influence. You have sacrificed human connection at the altar of your own narrative, ensuring that those who question you become exiles, rather than individuals in search of deeper understanding.

The Theological Distortion: Using Faith as a Shield

You have twisted the concept of faith to serve your own ends. Faith, as Christ demonstrated, was never meant to be a tool for silencing dissent. It was never meant to be a fortress behind which the powerful hide from accountability. Yet you have used it precisely that way.

When confronted, you responded with vague spiritual platitudes: “Healing happens when we surrender to Jesus.” But surrender is not an erasure of responsibility. True healing comes not through silence, but through confession, through atonement, through making right what was made wrong. Jesus did not tell the Pharisees to bury their sins under scripture; he exposed them. He rebuked those who used their religious standing to oppress others. And yet, you have done the very thing Christ himself condemned.

You teach forgiveness, but you do not practice repentance. You speak of love, yet you engage in abandonment. You claim to follow Christ, yet you emulate the very hypocrites he chastised. If faith were truly your guide, you would not evade, deflect, or obscure—you would face the truth head-on.

The Question You Cannot Escape

Chris Hansen always ends his interviews with the same question: “Is there anything you’d like to say to others who may be tempted to do the same?”

And so, Bryan, I offer you the same moment of reckoning.

What would you say to the pastors who, like you, have spent years prioritizing image over truth, loyalty over integrity, control over accountability? What would you say to those who manipulate forgiveness as a tool to silence rather than to heal? What do you say to the men who, even now, sit in offices making the same choices you have made, believing that they are untouchable, that the truth can be restructured to suit them?

Or will you, like those who sat in front of Hansen, continue to insist that this is all a misunderstanding, that your hands remain clean, that you are simply a man of faith caught in a moment of misinterpretation?

Unlike them, you will not be led away in handcuffs today. You will walk freely from this conversation, just as you have walked freely from every difficult truth you have refused to face. But freedom is not the absence of consequence. True freedom comes only from owning the truth, no matter how painful it is to face.

So, Bryan, this is your moment. Your moment to say something, not just to me, but to those who are watching, those who have suffered in silence, those who have been cast aside, those who have been told that questioning is betrayal.

Or will you—like the men caught red-handed—simply disappear into silence?

Your move, Bryan.

What the message says

Dan invokes To Catch a Predator as an analogy for concealed conduct meeting documentary exposure and ends with a public ultimatum.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The intended point is a reversal of power: a person who believed he controlled the story is confronted with an evidence record he cannot manage.

The analogy imports the moral force of sexual predation even though no sexual misconduct by Bryan is alleged. It risks unfair association, alienating readers, and overwhelming the actual pastoral and family issues.

The strongest part is the distinction between forgiveness as teaching and repentance as conduct. The criminal and historical analogies weaken that argument.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • How can exposure be described without importing unrelated criminal conduct?
  • What right of reply and contextual notice are required?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Preserve the original if completeness is essential, but collapse it by default, add a content notice, state explicitly that no sexual misconduct is alleged, and never use predator language in the editorial title.

Part Eight – Later returns

Renewed family relationships and new testimony prompt further contact. Direct denials, unresolved evidence, and the coattails dispute bring the correspondence to its end.

56
Healing after the father's death
Dan – April 14, 2025
+

Dan describes his mother's renewed family relationships after his father's death and argues that the change demonstrates how deeply the father's authority had restricted her life.

Family restorationMotherFather's deathCause and interpretationContinuing contact
Original correspondence

Monday, April 14th, 2025

Dan: 

Update

This fall, during Thanksgiving, I will be fortunate enough to take my second Royal Caribbean cruise with my mother. But this is not just another vacation. It is a moment dense with meaning. For the first time in decades, my mother will be surrounded by people she once loved and lost—her sister, her brother-in-law, and her son. Three people now restored to her life, three people she once believed were gone forever. This reunion, this quiet return, carries a depth that cannot be overstated.

And let us be clear—this is no coincidence. This is not the result of prayer chains whispered through clenched hands. It is not the fruit of your “wise counsel” or the supposed blessings of your leadership. It is not a triumph of the church.

So I ask you, Bryan: what, in your heart of hearts, do you believe brought about this healing?

Was it the years of empty ritual? The carefully prepared sermons you delivered with polished certainty, even as the foundations of the families around you crumbled? Was it your guidance, your position as assistant pastor—an office you’ve occupied without ever truly reckoning with the fractures under your feet?

No, Bryan. We both know what changed.

My mother began to reclaim her life the day my father died.

His absence created the quiet that healing needed to grow. His voice—once the unrelenting force of judgment, control, and silence—is now gone. And in that absence, something sacred was able to return: connection. My mother’s spirit is slowly finding breath again. And yet you—who stood beside him, who nodded along, who refused to challenge the cruelty and control you witnessed—still speak with authority about how others should live, about what makes a family, about what faith should look like.

You once told me I had no place as a teacher—not like you. Say it again, if the sound of your own voice comforts you. But understand this: the ability to quote scripture from a platform does not make a man wise. It only magnifies his failure when he refuses to confront the harm his voice has helped inflict.

You’ve said I must be fascinated with you, as if my persistence is some personal fixation. It isn’t.

I do not reach out to you because of who you are. I reach out because of where you remain.

You continue to stand in a position of influence within a church that harmed me and still harms others—especially those I love. My family remains within reach of that pulpit. And so long as you occupy it, saying nothing, doing nothing, pretending that all is well, I will not stay silent.

This is not about you. It never has been. This is about what you enable. What you excuse. What you refuse to name. I write because silence makes me complicit, and I will not allow your comfort or denial to matter more than the truth.

You carry the illusion of moral authority while standing on a foundation built from fractured families, shamed children, silenced questions, and broken spirits. You did not build that foundation alone, but you helped reinforce it. You protected it. You benefited from it. And even now, you continue to sit silently upon it—unmoved, unrepentant, unaccountable.

That is why you hear from me.

Not out of obsession. Not out of curiosity. But out of responsibility. Out of conscience.

Someone must say aloud what you refuse to speak. Someone must tear the veil from the pulpit you hide behind. And as long as you stand in that place—shielding what needs to be exposed—I will not stop.

Not until the truth finally breaks through.

Or until you lose the last remaining right to speak it.

What the message says

Dan describes his mother's renewed family relationships after his father's death and argues that the change demonstrates how deeply the father's authority had restricted her life.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message introduces evidence from change over time: relationships resumed and behaviors once unthinkable became possible after the father was gone. This reasonably supports the conclusion that his presence was an important obstacle.

It does not by itself establish every cause, the mother's degree of agency, Bryan's role, or whether church policy formally required the separation.

Dan explains continued contact by pointing to Bryan's ongoing pulpit and institutional influence. The page must distinguish Dan's right to speak publicly from any unlimited right to direct access after a boundary.

What it answers or contributes

This unit develops the position described above without a separate factual acknowledgment or resolution.

What remains open
  • What other factors contributed to renewed contact?
  • What specific present responsibility belongs to Bryan?
  • Can scrutiny continue without repeated direct messaging?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The sequence is strong circumstantial evidence of the father's influence but not a complete causal account.
57
Tom's account and the question of silent approval
Dan – June 28, 2025 – 7:27 AM
+

Dan recounts secondhand information about wedding exclusion and family visits, acknowledges that he may have combined two events, and asks Bryan direct questions about presence, approval, and institutionalization.

TomFamily weddingWitness accountSilent approvalSelf-correctionInstitutionalization
Original correspondence

Saturday, June 28th, 2025 7:27 AM

Dan: 

Brian,

As you are aware, I was recently in Syracuse to attend my nephew Jonathan’s high school graduation. I remained in town for eleven days. Though I came for his ceremony, I stayed because something deeply important is now possible. I was able to spend time with my mother. This would not have been permitted in the past. My father, through a long pattern of domination and manipulation, controlled who I was allowed to see and what relationships I could maintain. His death removed that obstacle. But let me be clear—he did not maintain that control alone. You helped. You stood beside him. You reinforced the very lines he drew, and you allowed them to remain unchallenged. Through your silence, your gestures, and your unwavering support, you upheld the wall he built between me and my mother. And now, with him gone, I am left to confront not only his legacy, but yours as well.

This visit allowed me to reconnect with others who, like my mother, were once kept distant from me by lies and fear. Lies that were shaped by my father, but supported and sustained by your teachings, your counsel, and your presence. These lies are now beginning to erode. The truth is being spoken. People are beginning to see.

One of the most revealing conversations I had was with my brother-in-law, Tom Conena. He shared several stories with me—stories that both confirmed what I had long suspected and revealed details I had never known.

He told me that when he asked to marry my sister Debbie, my father imposed several disturbing conditions. One of them was that I, along with our aunt and grandparents, was not to be invited to the wedding. Tom asked why. No reason was given. Only a directive. And then, my father turned to you. According to Tom, you responded with familiar gestures and expressions—nonverbal affirmations he recognized instantly. I know those gestures too. I have seen them from the pulpit. I have heard them in your tone and cadence. I have read them between the lines of your letters. Even in silence, your approval was clear.

But that was not the only story Tom shared. He also told me of a time when he chose to visit our aunt and uncle, and when my father found out, he responded with intense disapproval. Again, there was no explanation. Only the assertion that this act of kindness was, somehow, a betrayal. That visit—like so many simple, good things—was twisted into wrongdoing. This too was consistent with my own experience. I was told to disassociate from our aunt and grandparents, though my memories of them, like Tom’s, are filled only with kindness and warmth. There was never any justification. Only control. Only division.

Now, I want to be completely honest with you. It is possible that in the course of my long conversation with Tom, I conflated the two events. It may have been your support for my father’s reaction to Tom’s visit that was witnessed and described, rather than the wedding exclusion itself. But regardless of which moment your gestures affirmed, the meaning is the same. The message is unchanged. You supported the behavior. You stood beside a man who inflicted harm and separation on those closest to him. You knew, and you nodded. You backed him when silence could no longer be interpreted as neutrality.

And this was not a one-time occurrence. I have four siblings. Not once was I invited to any of their weddings. And I am left asking, were you there too? Were you standing in the background once again, lending your silent blessing to the decisions that kept me cut off from my own family?

Before I returned to Miami, I gave Tom a copy of my book, COR Values. Our conversation moved him. It sparked in him a desire to know what really happened, and to understand the deeper harm that was done. In five months, I will see him again on a cruise with my mother, sister, aunt, and uncle. I will tell him I confronted you. I will show him this letter. I will share your answer, or your refusal to give one.

You need to be asked directly. Did you support my father’s decision to exclude me and others from the wedding? Did you support his disapproval of Tom’s visit to our relatives? Were you part of the decisions that fractured a family, justified through vague warnings and arbitrary spiritual claims? Were you once again the quiet figure standing behind a man who used fear as a tool?

Tom will soon read how you responded when I reached out to you in writing. He will read your words. He will see how you deflected, then distanced, and finally retreated behind legal disclaimers to avoid responsibility. He will read how you dismissed my questions by diagnosing me as obsessive, calling me narcissistic, turning every effort I made to engage sincerely into something twisted. He will read your sermons in which you taught separation, not reconciliation. In which you labeled outsiders—including Christians—as deceived by Satan. In which you used scripture to justify exclusion and justify cruelty.

He will see clearly, as I have seen for many years, that you chose the preservation of your position over truth. That you shielded yourself at the cost of others. That you stood behind my father while he drove wedges into the lives of those who once loved each other.

There is one more question I must ask. During the most vulnerable time in my life, I was institutionalized. I believe it was my father who made that call. But I now ask you, were you involved? Did you support that decision as well? Were you again the man nearby, never speaking truth to power, but always offering just enough support to keep the damage going?

Brian, your congregation once looked to you for moral direction. I never did. But they did. And because they did, your silence carried weight. Your approval, even unspoken, gave permission. And for years, you used that influence not to protect, not to heal, but to shield yourself and uphold the system you benefited from.

So now I ask you again—who are you?

This is your moment. After years of silence, complicity, and moral retreat, you are standing at a final crossroads. You can remain where you have always been—hidden behind your role, cloaked in doctrine, insulated by reputation. Or you can speak the truth. The real truth. Not a softened gesture toward regret, not a vague expression of sorrow, but a clear and courageous confession from the very pulpit where harm was made sacred. That pulpit is the stage upon which you helped sanctify cruelty, silence justice, and fracture love. It is there that you must stand and name what you have done.

I expect you to confess your complicity. I expect you to speak of the families shattered, the lies you helped protect, the damage you allowed to deepen through silence and suggestion. I expect you to name the teachings you preached that turned mothers against sons, brothers against sisters, congregants against their own humanity. I expect you to say these things not because you are being cornered, but because they are true. And truth, if it is ever to mean anything in your life, must finally be spoken aloud.

But if you cannot—if after all of this, your instinct to protect your name, your place, your years of constructed reverence is still greater than your willingness to do what is right—then know this:

I will speak.

And I will not whisper.

If you cannot find the strength to tear down the altar you built to yourself, I will do it for you. If you cannot stand before your congregation and speak honestly, I will bring the truth to their doorstep. I will not only tell the church. I will tell the world. I will name you. I will expose what you did. I will lay bare the system of fear and falsehood that you upheld with your silence and your nods and your deflections.

And understand this well, Brian. What I reveal will not carry the dignity of repentance. It will not be tempered by humility. It will not be softened by confession. Because it will not come from you. It will come from the one you tried to silence. And it will be far more damaging than anything you could say on your own.

When truth is spoken by the guilty, it has the power to begin repair. But when it is dragged into the light by those who were wounded, it becomes judgment. That is the path you are choosing, unless you speak now.

This is your last opportunity to reclaim your voice. Not for me. Not even for the people you misled. But for your own soul, before what remains of it is buried under the truth you were too afraid to speak.

What the message says

Dan recounts secondhand information about wedding exclusion and family visits, acknowledges that he may have combined two events, and asks Bryan direct questions about presence, approval, and institutionalization.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Dan's acknowledgment that he may have connected Bryan to the wrong event is important and strengthens credibility. The value is reduced when he then says the distinction does not alter the conclusion.

Wedding exclusion, objection to visiting relatives, and general support for separation are different allegations. Evidence for one may suggest a pattern but does not establish the others.

The evidentiary chain is secondhand and interpretive: Tom remembers, tells Dan, Dan summarizes, interprets a gesture, places it in a pattern, and concludes complicity.

What it answers or contributes
  • Asks answerable factual questions
  • Discloses uncertainty rather than hiding it
What remains open
  • Which event did Tom remember?
  • Who was present?
  • What gesture occurred?
  • What did it mean?
  • Was Bryan involved in institutionalization?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The message is both an accountability demand and an ultimatum backed by threatened public exposure.
58
A direct denial followed by unsupported blame
Bryan – June 28, 2025 – 10:20 PM
+

Bryan says he did not read the full message, directly denies the wedding conversation, suggests another person may have been present, and then speculates that Dan's behavior may have justified exclusion.

Direct denialTomWeddingBlameParentingPartial reading
Original correspondence

June 28th, 2025 10:20 PM  Bryan: 

There’s no way I’m gonna read all this. I got to the TC part. Tom’s remembering all wrong. I have never been in a 3-way discussion of any importance w Tom and your father. Ever. Period. It doesn’t even make sense. When Tom and Debbie were getting engaged I was not yet part of the church leadership. Maybe it was Bob Dean.
Not to skirt the issue. A father can have many reasons for refusing to have a son at a wedding. Did you fit any of those cases? Relentlessly antagonistic? Angry? Treating his father or the church his father pastors as enemy number one?
Don’t get me wrong. I love you. Enjoy the cruise. I pray you get blessed. No way are you the same man you were forty-plus years ago, right? Me either. I should hope not!
I believe this: your father wanted very much for you to be at the wedding. If he couldn’t tolerate your being there, that’s on you, not him. You must have been out of control or something. You tell me.
By the way, before you criticize a man for refusing to have a son come to a family wedding, you ought to maybe raise a family of your own first.
Try this: “Yeah, me and my dad put each other through hell way back then. For my part, I’m sorry. I now prefer to celebrate my wonderful nephew’s graduation from the school my dad pioneered. What a fantastic story! Thank you everyone who made this happen!”

What the message says

Bryan says he did not read the full message, directly denies the wedding conversation, suggests another person may have been present, and then speculates that Dan's behavior may have justified exclusion.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The direct denial and timing claim deserve serious consideration and verification. Bryan says he was not part of the wedding discussion and was not yet in leadership; he suggests Bob Dean as an alternative participant.

The response is weakened when it moves from "I was not there" to unsupported speculation that Dan may have been antagonistic, angry, or out of control. That conjecture does not answer Bryan's own involvement or justify a specific exclusion.

Saying Dan should raise a family before judging is irrelevant to whether the event occurred or was fair. The proposed mutual-responsibility story may contain a constructive impulse but risks false symmetry where authority and power differed.

What it answers or contributes
  • Directly denies wedding-conversation involvement
  • Offers a verifiable timing issue and alternative witness
What remains open
  • Was Bryan present at the separate family-visit dispute?
  • Did he make the gesture?
  • Was he involved in institutionalization?
  • What evidence supports his view of Dan's behavior and the father's wishes?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The page should separate the strong factual denial from the weak speculative blame that follows it.
59
A rhetorical analysis that sometimes overstates its case
Dan – June 29, 2025
+

Dan identifies six alleged fallacies in Bryan's response, defends Tom's account, and announces that the reply is for a public audience rather than Bryan alone.

Rhetorical analysisFallaciesPublic audienceEvidenceExposure
Original correspondence

Sunday, June 29th, 2025 8:02 AM

Dan: 

Brian,

Your response was revealing, though not in the way you likely intended.

You began by saying, “There’s no way I’m gonna read all this.” That was your first sentence. The length of my letter—carefully written, structured with thought, restraint, and honesty—was enough for you to dismiss it outright. That dismissal, from the outset, told me and will tell others everything they need to know about your intent. You did not engage with the message because you did not want to face what was written. That is not discernment. That is avoidance.

The irony of your comment is staggering. As a former English teacher at Living Word Academy, you were once tasked with teaching students the value of reading carefully, listening for meaning, analyzing tone, intent, and truth. That a few pages of sincere reflection were too much for you to read is not simply laziness. It is revealing of something deeper—a refusal to be confronted by what you already know. You did not refute the claims because you did not read them. And yet, you were quick to respond, to judge, to redirect. That tells me, and will tell any reader, that you have no interest in truth unless it flatters you. You have spent so long shaping your words to uphold your image that you now reflexively reject anything that threatens it.

And for that reason, my reply is not only for you.

It is for the many others who will read this exchange. Some are members of the congregation. Some are former members. Some are family. Some are simply truth-seekers trying to make sense of years of confusion and pain. They deserve to see not only your words, but my full response. They deserve to see how you evade, how you distort, how you protect yourself, and how you use language not to reveal but to obscure. So this letter will be as long as necessary. Not for your sake—but for theirs.

You wrote that you stopped reading at the part about Tom Conena. You then dismissed his memory as faulty. You said you were never involved in any “3-way conversation of importance” involving Tom and my father. Perhaps you’re right. Perhaps the moment Tom described was not a three-way discussion, but one where you were brought in for validation—silently, with a look, a gesture, a nod of support. Perhaps it was not during the engagement discussion at all, but after Tom visited my aunt and uncle, an act my father deeply disapproved of. I acknowledged that possibility in my letter. You ignored that.

What matters is this: Tom described a moment in which you signaled agreement with my father’s pattern of exclusion and control. And the tragedy is not whether the moment happened during the engagement or the visit to my relatives. The tragedy is that it could have been either. Both stories fit the same pattern. Both reflect the same habit of silence, complicity, and submission to an unjust authority. They reveal something consistent: your presence in moments of harm, not as a challenger, but as a quiet validator.

You also wrote, “Not to skirt the issue,” and then immediately did exactly that. What followed was a textbook series of rhetorical fallacies, each one designed not to uncover truth, but to protect your image. For the benefit of others reading, and perhaps even to remind you of the standards you once claimed to teach, I will name these fallacies clearly:

  1. Ad Hominem Fallacy – This is the tactic of attacking the person instead of the argument. Rather than engaging the actual substance of my letter, you shifted the focus onto me—suggesting I was “out of control” and implying I was responsible for my own exclusion. You attempted to disqualify my credibility without addressing the facts I presented. This is not only intellectually dishonest, it is morally evasive. It’s the oldest deflection in the book: if you can’t argue with what someone says, you attack the person who says it.

  2. Straw Man Fallacy – This is the act of misrepresenting someone’s argument so you can knock down a weaker version of it. You framed my concerns as if they were simply about a single wedding, about whether I was invited or not. In doing so, you ignored the broader issues I raised—systemic exclusion, long-standing complicity, and decades of emotional and spiritual harm. This is not a story about a wedding. It is a story about how a church and its leaders institutionalized control and used family as leverage. You chose to reduce that to something convenient, something easier to dismiss. But others will not be so easily misled.

  3. Red Herring Fallacy – This fallacy diverts attention from the real issue. You asked me whether I’ve raised a family of my own, as if that disqualifies my insight into family dynamics. This is irrelevant to the issue at hand. My ability to question your role in years of division does not rest on my status as a father. It rests on lived experience, on documented patterns of behavior, and on a lifetime of spiritual and emotional abuse cloaked as religious authority. Bringing up my parental status is not just a diversion—it is a weak one.

  4. Appeal to Emotion / Sentimentality – You inserted warm phrases like “I love you” and “I pray you get blessed,” but these were placed between deflections, accusations, and dismissals. This is sentimentality used as cover. It is emotional manipulation. It is meant to soften the appearance of what is actually a refusal to take responsibility. But those who have experienced real love know this: love without truth is not love. Love that refuses to look in the mirror is vanity.

  5. Gaslighting – Perhaps the most insidious of all. You claimed that my father “wanted me at the wedding,” then suggested that if I wasn’t there, it was because I was unfit to be. You positioned yourself as an interpreter of my father’s intent, as someone who understands my own past better than I do. This is gaslighting—subtly suggesting that my memory, my experience, my conclusions are suspect or false, while you offer no facts to support your version. It is psychological manipulation dressed up as reasonable doubt. But others will see it. They will recognize what it is.

  6. Motte and Bailey Fallacy – This is a rhetorical bait-and-switch. The “bailey” is the aggressive, controversial stance: that I was too unstable to be included, that exclusion was my fault. But when challenged, you retreat to the “motte”—safe, uncontroversial statements like “We’ve both grown,” or “I love you.” You pretend that this softer version was your real position all along. But it wasn’t. You used harsh judgment first, then hid behind kindness when challenged. This is not only evasive—it’s cowardly.

  

These fallacies, when stacked together, form a wall built not with truth, but with calculated deflection. They reveal a person more interested in protecting themselves than in confronting what is true. They reveal a man who has learned to speak in religious tones, but not in moral clarity. They reveal someone who once taught students to read and understand meaning, now unable to apply that same literacy to his own life.

You suggested that I issue a neat public statement: that I and my father “put each other through hell,” that I now celebrate my nephew, and that we should all move on. But what you offered is not healing—it is revision. It is the rewriting of reality into something you can live with. But I am not here to help you feel better. I am here to speak truth.

And yes, I was angry. I had reason to be. I watched people I loved be divided. I watched scriptures weaponized. I watched obedience replace conscience. I watched loyalty replace love. I watched a man—my father—become more interested in control than in compassion, and I watched you standing beside him, offering the silent nod that made it all seem spiritually justified.

You were not a bystander. You were part of the machinery.

This letter, again, is not only for you. It is for those who still live in the silence you helped build. It is for those who were told that separation was obedience, that cutting off loved ones was godliness, and that submission was proof of faith. It is for those who wonder if what they endured was normal, or necessary, or holy. It is not. And it never was.

You had a chance to answer with humility. You answered with condescension. You had a chance to engage. You retreated. You had a chance to own your part. You blamed mine.

And so I say again: if you will not speak the truth from the pulpit where the damage was done, I will speak it elsewhere. I will speak it publicly, with clarity, and without hesitation. I will tell the truth to those who still believe your silence means you have nothing to hide. I will tell it to those inside your circle and those beyond it. I will name what you did, what you allowed, and what you justified. And when I do, it will not carry the dignity of confession. It will carry the authority of exposure.

Because when the guilty speak, healing is possible. But when the wounded must speak in their place, what follows is accountability.

What the message says

Dan identifies six alleged fallacies in Bryan's response, defends Tom's account, and announces that the reply is for a public audience rather than Bryan alone.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

Some criticisms are strong: Bryan introduced unsupported character speculation, answered only the portion he read, and invoked parental status as an irrelevant credential.

Other labels are too categorical. Warm language does not prove manipulation. Disagreement and invalidation do not by themselves establish gaslighting. Motte-and-bailey is not a precise description of affection and blame coexisting.

Dan again concedes that Bryan may be correct about the wedding conversation but says either event fits the pattern. A pattern may guide inquiry; it should not replace verification.

By explicitly changing the audience to future readers, Dan formally ends the private reconciliation frame and writes as testimony, argument, and anticipated publication.

What it answers or contributes
  • Identifies the incomplete reading and irrelevant parenting remark
  • Makes the public purpose explicit
What remains open
  • Which rhetorical labels are precise?
  • How should ambiguity affect the pattern claim?
  • What evidence would confirm Tom's specific recollection?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
Present a two-column table comparing Dan's fallacy label with the editorial assessment rather than endorsing all six labels.
60
Coattails
Dan – July 21, 2025
+

Dan returns to Bryan's coattails remark, defends the independent life he built, cites paying for his father's funeral, and accuses Bryan of inheriting the platform from which he criticized Dan.

CoattailsIndependenceFuneralSuccessionProjectionFinal message
Original correspondence

July 21st, 2025 11:50 AM

Dan: 

 

Coattails.

Of all the things you could have thrown at me—that’s the word you chose?
Coattails.

I was thrown out of my home and spent decades looking back—not to beg, not to accuse—but hoping to reconnect with family. I built a life and a business from nothing. No help. No inheritance. Not once did I turn around and ask for a thing—not a dollar, not a favor.

And now you call that coattails?

I don’t take from people, Bryan. Not then, not now. I’ve been offered more than you’ll ever know—things most people would grab without hesitation. I said no. Every time. Not because I couldn’t accept help, but because I refuse to live a life built on shortcuts and borrowed ground.

I live by principle. You speak of one. That’s the difference.

And you—of all people—have the gall to speak of anyone riding coattails?
Bryan, your entire platform was handed to you. You stepped into a church, a ministry, a school—built, funded, and fought for by others—and settled in like you laid the first brick.

My father told me exactly why you became his successor when his health began to fail:
“He was the only one chasing it,” he said.
The only one who wanted it badly enough.

You didn’t build anything. You waited. You maneuvered. You took what was already made. You’ve coasted on the work, sacrifices, and reputations of those who came before you—and you’ve done it with remarkable ease.

So don’t talk to me about coattails.
Not when riding them is what you do best.

And while we’re here, tell me this—
What kind of man, riding someone else’s coattails, quietly pays fifteen thousand dollars for the funeral of the father who rejected him his entire life?
No applause. No recognition. No reimbursement. Just a quiet decision to honor a man who never honored him back.

Does that sound like someone clinging to someone else’s legacy?
Or someone making peace with his own?

You speak of coattails.
But it was never me wearing them.

It’s not just hypocrisy.
It’s projection.
And it’s beneath even you.

What the message says

Dan returns to Bryan's coattails remark, defends the independent life he built, cites paying for his father's funeral, and accuses Bryan of inheriting the platform from which he criticized Dan.

Meaning in context · editorial interpretation

The message explains why the word struck deeply: it attacks Dan's understanding that he survived without family support, built his own life, refused dependency, and still honored his father.

Two meanings should be separated. Material dependence concerns money, employment, and favors, which Dan denies. Associational attention concerns why church-connected people notice his work, which may partly arise from being the founder's son.

Bryan did inherit leadership within an existing institution, but succession alone does not prove opportunism. The stronger questions concern how he obtained the role, what he contributed, and whether inherited benefit affected his willingness to confront harmful practices.

Calling the remark projection diagnoses Bryan's unconscious motive. A more supportable conclusion is that the remark overlooked how much Bryan's own authority arose within institutions built before he led them.

What it answers or contributes
  • Ends the correspondence on the theme of inheritance and institutional legacy
What remains open
  • What exactly did Bryan mean by coattails?
  • How was succession determined?
  • Did inherited institutional authority affect accountability?
Another possible reading or editorial caution
The funeral payment demonstrates duty and generosity despite estrangement, though it does not directly resolve the narrower question of why church members pay attention to Dan's work.

Closing synthesis

What Bryan acknowledged

The correspondence contains several specific acknowledgments that should not be minimized:

  • He apologized for giving up on Dan as a teenager.
  • He apologized for the harshness of earlier emails.
  • He accepted that person-to-person repentance might have deserved fuller treatment in his sermon.
  • He said judging Dan's inner spiritual condition was not properly his decision.
  • He said he knew the father had faults and had tried to distinguish himself from him.

These acknowledgments are limited but real. The page should neither inflate them into complete accountability nor erase them because they did not reach the full history Dan wanted addressed.

What Bryan denied or disputed

Bryan denied or disputed personal FBI involvement, sustained public discussion of Dan, intentionally preaching about him, hearing the father call him poison, participation in the reported wedding conversation, complicity in the full history Dan described, and the broader interpretation he called conspiracy.

A denial is an answer even when Dan believes it is false. The page should not treat denial as proof of innocence or proof of guilt.

What Dan asked Bryan to do

Dan asked for specificity, explanation of earlier judgments, answers about police and FBI activity, review of audio and documents, public correction, family intervention, compassionate engagement with former members, access to institutional accountability, reading of the memoir, answers about wedding exclusion and institutionalization, and ultimately public confession from the pulpit.

These requests differ greatly in scope and practicality. Some are factual questions, some requests for empathy, some requests for investigation, some demands that Bryan accept Dan's interpretation, and some public remedies proposed before shared factual agreement existed.

What remained unanswered

Unresolved matters include the origin of the police and FBI activity; which recordings Bryan reviewed; exact public statements and context; Bryan's role in family-visit disputes, wedding exclusions, or institutionalization; the basis of his 2007 judgments; the identity and accessibility of the church's internal oversight group; whether Bryan would speak with David; and how publication, privacy, correction, and right of reply should be balanced.

Evidence classification

The evidence cards distinguish among these source types. Authentication remains necessary before treating a recording or reproduced message as verified:

  1. Primary documentary evidence – original messages, complete emails, authenticated recordings.
  2. First-person testimony – Dan's account and reports by people describing their own experiences.
  3. Secondhand testimony – Dan's account of what another person told him.
  4. Interpretation – claims about motive, meaning of gestures, complicity, gaslighting, projection, or why someone remained silent.

How Dan complicated the exchange

Dan opened with severe conclusions, sent many long messages, continued direct contact after requests to stop, sometimes stated motives as fact, treated some denials as evidence of guilt, announced public use of private messages, demanded a prescribed confession, used analogies unsupported by the alleged conduct, confronted Isaiah publicly, and sometimes treated uncertainty as immaterial because an event fit a larger pattern.

These choices do not erase the grievance. They help explain why the exchange became defensive, guarded, and eventually impossible.

How Bryan complicated the exchange

Bryan began with a nonspecific apology paired with criticism, offered reciprocal forgiveness without identifying Dan's wrong, answered selectively, had previously used severe spiritual and psychological language, redirected some interpersonal questions into theology, relied on favorable character judgments when declining inquiry, invoked internal accountability without explaining access, stopped reading some messages while still speculating about Dan, and offered interpretations of Dan and the father while objecting to Dan's interpretations of him.

These choices do not prove every allegation. They help explain why Dan experienced the exchange as dismissive and resistant to accountability.

What apology accomplished

The apology established that Bryan regretted failing Dan during adolescence and the harshness of earlier emails. It did not create a shared account of the wider history, the church's role, public statements, family consequences, or appropriate repair.

An apology may be sincere within the scope the speaker accepts. The recipient may still regard that scope as inadequate. Reconciliation requires enough shared reality for both people to understand what relationship they are rebuilding. That shared reality never emerged here.

What a workable accountability process would have required

A defined allegation list; separation of Bryan's conduct from the father's; source identification; direct answers; verification of dates, recordings, and witnesses; a neutral facilitator; publication and privacy boundaries; distinction among acknowledgment, investigation, correction, and repair; consent from family members; and an outcome that did not require either person to surrender every disputed belief before the process began.

Final reflection

This correspondence did not produce the reconciliation I hoped for. It produced something narrower but still important: a record.

Bryan acknowledged some wrongs and denied others. I offered evidence, memory, interpretation, accusation, and at times language harsher than necessary. He answered some questions, left others untouched, questioned my account, and eventually withdrew.

Readers may conclude that I pressed too hard. They may conclude that he did not engage deeply enough. They may see sincerity, defensiveness, anger, injury, faith, certainty, and fear on both sides.

The purpose of presenting the exchange is not to prevent those judgments. It is to make them answerable to the words themselves.

The questions remain: What does an apology require? When does a leader's responsibility extend beyond what he personally intended? When does persistence become pressure? When does a boundary protect a person, and when does it protect authority? What should happen when a family, church, and individual carry incompatible accounts of the same past? And when private conversation fails, what does responsible public testimony look like?

I do not believe every answer belongs to me. I do believe the questions deserve to remain visible.

Right of reply

Bryan Rocine, Isaiah Rocine, and any person whose words or conduct are directly represented may submit a correction, clarification, or response. A response should be presented beside the material it addresses, in full, provided it can lawfully be published and does not disclose private information about unrelated people.

Factual errors should be corrected transparently. Corrections should be dated, and original wording should not be silently altered.

Contact Daniel to submit a response or correction ↗

Source and correction note

The correspondence retains the participants’ wording, spelling, and grammar. Dates and times are reproduced as recorded; the February 19–22, 2025 chronology requires confirmation. Evidence notes identify where context, provenance, or publication permission remains unverified. Corrections supported by original records will be dated and identified clearly.

Understanding the Back Cover of Luke

A guide for readers before the opening pages

Below the cover image, you will find the first ten pages of Watch.
These opening pages are meant to introduce the tone, the world, and the emotional direction of the novel, not to explain everything at once.

Before reading them, this short guide explains what the back cover blurb means, what the book is about at its core, and what kind of story you are stepping into.

The question at the heart of the novel

The back cover of Watch opens with a single question:

What if the life you believed was yours was quietly arranged long before you knew how to ask otherwise?

This question is the foundation of the book.

It asks readers to consider whether a life can be shaped without force, without cruelty, and without anyone ever saying, you must do this. A person may believe they are choosing freely, while never having been shown that other choices were possible.

The novel is about that realization, and about what happens when it begins to surface.

What “quietly arranged” means

In Watch, control does not look dramatic. It does not come through shouting or obvious threats.

It works in ordinary ways.

Who offers help
Who gives approval
What questions are encouraged
What topics are avoided
What earns trust
What feels normal

Over time, these small influences add up. The life begins to take shape, not through force, but through guidance that feels caring.

The book asks whether kindness and control can exist at the same time, and how difficult it can be to tell the difference.

Power that doesn’t look like power

The blurb describes Watch as a story about power that does not announce itself.

This means the power in the novel does not demand attention. It blends into daily life.

It decides what is acceptable
It sets expectations quietly
It rewards cooperation
It discourages questioning

Because this kind of power feels reasonable, people often accept it without noticing how much it is shaping them.

The novel is about recognizing that influence once it has already done its work.

Care that comes with conditions

The system at the center of Watch offers real benefits.

Order
Belonging
Generosity
Protection

But these come with an unspoken expectation: silence.

Silence about doubts
Silence about discomfort
Silence about contradictions

Over time, silence begins to feel like good behavior. Like maturity. Like loyalty.

The book is not accusing individuals of cruelty. It is showing how systems can slowly teach people what not to say.

When obedience starts to feel like belief

One of the most important ideas in the blurb is the moment when obedience begins to feel indistinguishable from belief.

At first, a person follows rules because it feels safer or easier. Later, those rules begin to feel true.

The novel explores how this shift happens slowly, and how unsettling it can be to realize that some beliefs may have been learned rather than chosen.

This recognition does not arrive suddenly. It builds quietly, just as the system did.

The community at the center of the story

The community in Watch is described as having order, generosity, and quiet authority.

These qualities are not accidental. They are what make the community appealing.

Order provides stability
Generosity creates trust
Quiet authority feels reassuring

The book does not present this community as simply good or bad. Instead, it asks how environments that feel safe can also shape people in ways they may not fully see.

Protection becomes design

At first, the protagonist experiences protection. Help appears when needed. Guidance feels timely. Opportunities open.

Only later does he begin to notice patterns.

Certain paths are encouraged
Certain questions are avoided
Certain outcomes seem guided

The word design suggests intention. The protagonist begins to sense that his life is being shaped toward something, not simply unfolding on its own.

This realization is subtle, but it changes everything.

Leaving is not freedom, but reckoning

The blurb makes clear that leaving such a system does not feel like escape.

It feels like reckoning.

Leaving means facing what was accepted, what was ignored, and what was traded for safety and belonging.

The novel is not about dramatic rebellion. It is about the difficult work of understanding one’s own participation in a life that once felt secure.

Why the story moves quietly

Watch is written in a restrained, thoughtful style because the kind of control it explores is quiet.

The book focuses less on big events and more on how people slowly come to accept things they might once have questioned.

Small compromises
Small silences
Small rewards

Over time, these shape a life.

The opening pages you are about to read reflect this approach. They are meant to settle you into the rhythm of the story rather than explain it outright.

Being seen versus being free

One of the novel’s central tensions is the moment when being seen begins to feel safer than being free.

Being seen means belonging. It means being known and valued.

Freedom, by contrast, can mean uncertainty and loss.

The book explores this tension without judgment, showing how understandable it is to choose safety over independence, especially when the cost of freedom is unclear.

No clear villains, no simple answers

Watch is not a story of heroes and villains.

People can care and control at the same time. They can believe they are helping while also limiting others.

Truth in this story does not arrive all at once. It emerges gradually, and it comes with consequences.

What these first ten pages are meant to do

The pages that follow are the first ten pages of the novel.

They are not meant to provide answers. They are meant to introduce the atmosphere, the voice, and the world of the story.

As you read, you may notice:

Quiet guidance
Unspoken expectations
Moments of comfort mixed with unease
A life beginning to take shape

These early pages are the beginning of recognition, not its conclusion.

The purpose of Watch

The purpose of Watch is not to tell readers what to think. It is to invite them to notice.

To notice how lives can be shaped without force
To notice how silence can feel like loyalty
To notice how belonging can come with conditions
To notice how easily obedience can become belief

And to ask a simple, unsettling question.

Was the life I was given truly the life I chose?

To All Pastors

I offer these words not in anger, but in truth, for truth is the beginning of healing.

What does it say of a man—one who held the title of pastor, shepherd, and father—if for decades he could avoid the most sacred calling of all: to reconcile with his own son? A father who, even in his final days, spoke only in superficial tones, never daring to confront the truth that lay between them, never opening the door to accountability, never acknowledging the great silence that had endured for so many years.

What kind of gospel allows this?

And more pressing still, what does it say of a church that knew—because the son himself told them—and did nothing? A church that bore witness to a long and public estrangement, and remained still. A church that turned its concern not toward justice or compassion or repair, but toward protecting an image. An image of a man. An image of itself.

If that is what your gospel protects, what then is the cost of your silence?

And what are we to think when a new pastor assumes the pulpit with full knowledge of what came before—and still, says nothing? What are we to make of leadership that inherits not just a congregation but a legacy of wounds, and chooses complacency over clarity, image over integrity?

What kind of light does such a church offer its people, when it hides from its own reflection? What healing can be preached from the pulpit, when no healing is practiced within the walls?

I have lived this story. I was the son. I wrote it down in COR Values not to accuse, but to reveal. Because I believe that only in revealing can there be restoration. I believe that silence in the face of truth is a betrayal—not just of people, but of God, of the very Spirit churches claim to follow.

You cannot preach reconciliation while avoiding it. You cannot speak of love while excusing long-held indifference. And you cannot proclaim truth if you are not willing to face it in your own house.

This is a call not to guilt, but to courage.

To every pastor, every leader, every church: the world is watching. The children are watching. The sons and daughters who were turned away, who were labeled and dismissed, are watching. And they are asking not for showmanship, not for pageantry, not for empty declarations—but for truth, for integrity, and for love that does not flinch.

A church that cannot face its own failures has no authority to speak to the brokenness of the world.

With unwavering hope that some will choose the harder, braver path,
Daniel Robert Mazur

An In-Depth Analysis of Felix the Fluke in Beyond the Morning Light

 

Due to the many comments I have received about the story of Felix the Fluke—where readers have shared various interpretations of its symbolism and metaphors—I have decided to take the time to explain my own thoughts behind its creation. While I value the different perspectives that have been brought to me, I want to clarify the deeper meanings I intended to convey.

 

Felix as a Reflection of Alden and the Human Experience

 

The story of Felix the Fluke, embedded within Beyond the Morning Light, serves as a powerful metaphor for Alden’s personal struggles, his philosophical musings, and his relationship with his father, family, and faith. At the same time, it also reflects themes that I, as the author, have explored in my own life—particularly in my journey toward self-expression and independence. This narrative within a narrative offers a deeply symbolic reflection on existence, survival, and the human condition, drawing parallels between Alden’s personal journey and the broader truths I have sought to convey.

 

Felix, a tiny liver fluke living inside a Bengal cat named Sable, represents Alden’s own perceived insignificance in the vast world around him. Just as Felix exists within an environment he cannot fully comprehend, Alden navigates forces that shape his life—his father’s expectations, the church, societal structures—without fully understanding their origins or long-term consequences. Felix’s story mirrors Alden’s journey in several key ways:

 

  1. The Unseen Yet Sensed Presence – Felix cannot see Beatrice, the elderly woman who owns Sable, just as humans cannot see God, the universe, or other unseen forces. Yet, he senses a higher force influencing his existence. This parallels Alden’s struggles with faith and his search for meaning in a world governed by unseen influences.
  2. The Burden of Awareness – Felix becomes self-aware, recognizing that his survival depends on consuming Sable’s liver, and with that awareness comes guilt. He realizes that his natural tendencies will ultimately lead to the demise of his host. This mirrors Alden’s realization that his own self-awareness and growing independence, while necessary for his personal growth, contribute to the deterioration of his relationship with his father. Awareness, rather than bringing peace, brings inner turmoil and existential questioning.
  3. The Inevitable Role in the Cycle of Life – Felix eventually understands that he cannot change his fundamental nature. This realization reflects Alden’s own internal battle—whether to fight against the structures that have defined him or to accept them as part of his reality. The struggle for autonomy against forces beyond one’s control is a persistent theme in Alden’s life and a central exploration in my own work as an author.

 

The Connection to Alden’s Father and My Own Journey

 

A key element of Beyond the Morning Light is Alden’s relationship with his father, which is mirrored in Felix’s relationship with Sable and the unseen Beatrice. Just as Felix’s actions have consequences for beings he cannot directly perceive, Alden’s choices and struggles exist within a larger familial and societal framework.

 

However, these struggles are not solely Alden’s—they also reflect aspects of my own experience in grappling with autonomy, self-expression, and family expectations. The novel serves as both an intimate character study of Alden and an extension of my own process of breaking free from control and allowing my voice to be heard.

 

Felix and Sable’s Relationship as a Metaphor for Alden and His Father

 

Felix’s relationship with Sable encapsulates Alden’s complex and evolving connection with his father. Just as Felix is completely dependent on Sable for survival, Alden was once entirely reliant on his father’s approval, validation, and sense of structure. However, this dependency is not without consequence—Felix’s very existence erodes the health of his host, much like Alden’s growing self-awareness and independence strain his relationship with his father, ultimately leading to its demise.

 

The more Felix feeds, the more he brings harm to the entity that sustains him. In a parallel sense, Alden’s journey of self-discovery—the realization that he is an individual beyond his father’s expectations—introduces an irreversible shift in their dynamic. Awareness, in both cases, acts as a double-edged sword. Felix cannot exist without harming Sable, and Alden cannot grow into his full self without distancing himself from the influence of his father. The realization that autonomy requires separation is as painful as it is inevitable.

 

For me, as the author, this theme is deeply personal. Self-expression, particularly through writing, has been both a means of resistance and a path to liberation. Yet, this liberation has not come without a cost. Just as Alden’s journey toward self-definition leads to the unraveling of his relationship with his father, my own embrace of my voice and truth has created an unbridgeable distance between me and the person who once shaped my world. Writing has not only been an act of discovery but also an act of separation—a necessary step toward autonomy that, like Felix’s existence within Sable, alters the balance of what once was.

 

Broader Themes of Survival, Morality, and Power

 

The story of Felix also engages with Alden’s earlier philosophical reflections on intelligent creatures whose survival depends on the demise of others—a concept that extends beyond the literal parasite-host dynamic.

 

  • The Inescapability of Predation – Whether it is Felix feeding on Sable, Sable preying on smaller creatures, or humans consuming animals, life persists through the consumption of others. This raises moral questions about existence itself and whether survival is inherently exploitative. This theme resonates not only with Alden’s reflections but also with my broader inquiry into the structures that shape us—religious, societal, and familial systems that, in their own way, consume individuals.
  • Does Intelligence Change the Moral Dilemma? – Felix, unlike other flukes, is aware of his impact on Sable. Similarly, Alden’s self-awareness causes him to question his own role in the systems that shaped him. This mirrors human struggles with morality—does understanding our impact change our responsibilities, or are we simply playing out roles imposed by larger unseen forces? As the author, I have explored these same dilemmas—both intellectually and personally.
  • Control Versus Acceptance – Just as Felix cannot change his fundamental nature, Alden grapples with the idea of whether he can ever truly escape the influences of his past. His journey toward self-acceptance echoes Felix’s final realization that awareness does not always lead to change—it sometimes only leads to understanding. Similarly, as I reflect on my own path, I recognize that some structures cannot be dismantled—but they can be outgrown, transcended, and redefined through the act of storytelling.

 

Conclusion: The Power of Felix’s Story

 

The story of Felix the Fluke serves as an intricate allegory, tying together Alden’s existential reflections, his struggles with his father, and the overarching themes of faith, control, and self-awareness. Yet, it is also a reflection of my own journey, the struggles I have overcome, and the questions I continue to explore through my writing. Ultimately, Felix the Fluke is a meditation on awareness, autonomy, and the act of finding one’s voice—whether in fiction, in reality, or in the space between.

December 22, 2024

Pastor Bryan Rocine and Members of the Board,

 

The doctrine of separation within The Living Word Church is not merely a mistake of the past; it is a festering wound, a moral failure that continues to inflict immeasurable pain on those it has harmed. For decades, this doctrine has ravaged families, alienated devoted individuals, and destroyed the bonds that form the cornerstone of any healthy community. Its legacy is not confined to history; it reverberates in the present and, if left unaddressed, will haunt the Church far into the future.

And yet, the Church continues to deny the very existence of this doctrine. You claim it does not exist, that there is no policy, no teaching of separation. But I know what I have seen. I know what I have heard. Growing up in Syracuse, I witnessed this doctrine in action. I have heard it in sermons, not just in person but also broadcast over the internet after I moved to Miami. Bryan, you know this to be true because I have written to you about it repeatedly over the years. Time and again, I raised these concerns, only to be met with silence or avoidance. You have failed to address these matters, failed to engage with the truth, and failed to take responsibility for the harm caused.

I still have the letters between us, Bryan. If you need a reminder of your failure to address this issue, of your very own words spoken from the pulpit, I can send them to you again. Do you recall when I wrote to you about my concerns regarding your teachings on the need for separation from family? Do you remember, Bryan, how I warned you that I would inform the Syracuse community of your harmful actions and your belief in separating people from their loved ones? Your response was not one of accountability or willingness to engage, but a demand that our correspondence remain confidential, subtly implying that sharing your words with others could result in legal consequences. Do you remember that?

And, Bryan, do you remember what followed? A day or two later, the police arrived at my home. They claimed my father had informed them I was building a bomb with the intention of blowing up the church. They searched my home, Bryan. Do you recall me telling you this? Do you remember how I wrote to you about this, how I even documented it in my book, COR Values? These actions—your silence, your veiled threats, and the sudden police intervention—paint a chilling picture of the lengths to which you and others were willing to go to suppress the truth.

The excuses used to justify inaction are many, but none withstand scrutiny. Some claim, “It was in the past,” as though the passage of time alone absolves the Church of its sins. But time does not heal wounds that remain untreated. Others argue, “These are family matters,” as if relegating the pain caused to the private sphere relieves the Church of its moral responsibility. This dismissal not only trivializes the harm inflicted but abdicates the Church’s duty to lead with integrity and accountability. Still, others hide behind, “It’s all hearsay,” attempting to diminish the lived experiences of those who have suffered as if their voices lack credibility. This excuse is particularly insidious, for it silences the very people who have been wronged and denies their suffering a rightful place in the Church’s conscience.

And then there is the most egregious justification of all: “We no longer reject others, so there is no need to do anything.” This claim is not only insufficient but offensive. Ceasing to harm is not the same as making amends. To adopt this excuse is to ignore the ongoing ripple effects of the past—broken families, lingering pain, and lives permanently altered by rejection and alienation. It is to close your eyes to the scars left behind and pretend they do not exist. This is not progress; it is avoidance, and it is a betrayal of the very principles of accountability and healing that Christianity proclaims.

Another, perhaps unspoken, rationale for inaction is the fear of tarnishing the Church’s reputation. This fear betrays a deeper problem: the prioritization of institutional image over the well-being of the people the Church claims to serve. But what good is a spotless façade if the foundation beneath it is rotting? A Church that fears the truth more than it values justice has already failed in its mission.

Lastly, there is the excuse of complacency, the subtle yet pervasive belief that addressing the past is simply too difficult, too uncomfortable, too disruptive. But Christianity is not a faith of convenience. It demands sacrifice, courage, and an unwavering commitment to truth. To shy away from this challenge is to admit that comfort has become more important than conviction, that maintaining the status quo outweighs the call to embody the love, reconciliation, and justice at the heart of the Gospel.

You tell the congregation you are a humble servant of the Lord. You publicly admit your shortcomings, even going so far as to announce your phone number from the pulpit, inviting those harmed by so-called “mistakes” or “misunderstandings” to call you so you can ask for their understanding and forgiveness. Yet you and I both know the truth: you have no genuine interest in engaging with those who have been hurt. This is not humility; it is a façade, a carefully crafted performance to reinforce the image you wish your congregation to believe—a false portrait of yourself as humble, human, and capable of failure.

I know this because I was one of those people who called you. I reached out, seeking an honest and meaningful conversation, only to be met with refusal and indifference. It was clear to me then, as it is now, that your so-called humility is hollow, a tool used to placate those who might otherwise demand accountability.

This pattern of behavior extends beyond you, Bryan. It is clearly reflected in your son, Isaiah, another leader within your church, whom I have recently met. I will never forget the day he shook my hand in front of a group of people, including my brother Paul. He looked me in the eye and said, “I owe you one,” acknowledging the validity of my calling him out on a cowardly act, an act he openly admitted was wrong. In that moment, I forgave him, believing his words to be genuine, that he had recognized his wrongdoing and felt sincere remorse.

Yet, once the audience had dispersed and no one remained to hold him accountable, his actions exposed a starkly different reality. He reverted to the same cowardly behavior, revealing not only his dishonesty but also the deeply troubling nature of leadership that has permeated not just the leadership of your church but your family as well. This conduct is profoundly disgraceful, standing as a direct betrayal of the principles the Church is meant to uphold. It erodes the foundation of trust, integrity, and moral leadership that the Church is called to embody.

I write to you today not as a Christian, but as someone who has been immersed in its teachings since childhood. Although I am an atheist, I cannot ignore the profound beauty and moral clarity embedded in the values your faith professes to uphold. I understand its call for compassion, its pursuit of justice, and its unwavering commitment to truth. In addressing you, I am choosing to engage with the language of your faith, to invoke the scripture that forms the foundation of your beliefs, in order to highlight the glaring contradiction between the Church’s actions and the mission it claims to serve.

 

The rejection and ostracization of good people, the destruction of fellowship and family bonds, are not just betrayals of individuals. They are betrayals of the Gospel itself. Christianity, at its core, demands accountability. Its teachings call for love, reconciliation, and the restoration of what has been broken. The words of Jesus leave no ambiguity: “Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind. This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it: Love your neighbor as yourself” (Matthew 22:37-40). To divide families, to sever bonds of love and community, is to act in direct opposition to these commands.

The doctrine of separation is a betrayal of Christianity itself. At its heart, your faith esteems family as sacred. The Apostle Paul declares, “If anyone does not provide for his relatives, and especially for his immediate family, he has denied the faith and is worse than an unbeliever” (1 Timothy 5:8). How, then, can The Living Word Church justify tearing families apart, severing the bonds of love and connection that form the bedrock of human life? Community, too, is fundamental to Christian teaching. Jesus said, “By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you love one another” (John 13:35). Yet the Church’s actions have been marked not by love but by exclusion, judgment, and rejection.

These choices are not merely a betrayal of individuals; they are a betrayal of the Gospel itself. Scripture warns against hypocrisy: “Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You shut the door of the kingdom of heaven in people’s faces. You yourselves do not enter, nor will you let those enter who are trying to” (Matthew 23:13). This is not a hypothetical warning; it is the precise indictment the Church now faces.

I write to you with the weight of personal experience. My own family has borne the crushing burden of this doctrine. Some members, now gone, left this world carrying the scars inflicted by the Church’s rejection. Others remain, their lives irreparably shaped by wounds that never healed. I refuse to allow their suffering, and the suffering of countless others, to be erased by indifference or buried under the veil of willful ignorance. This is not a matter of preference for me; it is a moral obligation. To remain silent would be to betray not only those I love but also the principles of truth and justice that transcend belief systems.

Let there be no misunderstanding: this matter will not rest. It will be addressed, with or without your cooperation. The tide of awareness among members of The Living Word Church is rising, and it will not be turned back. You do not face a choice between addressing this issue or ignoring it. You face a choice between leading this reckoning with wisdom and humility or watching it unfold beyond your control. Every moment you resist deepens the damage to the Church’s legacy, its mission, and its people.

Let me be clear. I will not stop. I will not falter. This effort to demand accountability and reconciliation will continue until one of two outcomes is reached: either these injustices are resolved, or my time on this earth comes to an end. This is not a threat; it is a promise born of conviction. I have no desire for discord within the Church, but I will not allow peace to be purchased at the expense of truth. The harm inflicted must be acknowledged. The wrongs must be owned. The wounds must be healed. Anything less is complicity in ongoing injustice.

Pastor Rocine and members of the Board, this is your moment. This is your opportunity to lead, not by preserving the status quo or evading discomfort, but by rising to the moral and spiritual responsibility that your positions demand. Acknowledge the truth. Take responsibility for the harm done. Guide the Church toward healing and reconciliation. To do otherwise is to reject the principles of love and justice that your faith commands and to embrace a legacy of silence and failure.

This is not a question of preference; it is a certainty. The reckoning will come. The only question is whether you will face it with courage and integrity or wait until circumstances force your hand. The time for action is now. The decision is yours.

Respectfully and resolutely,

Daniel Robert Mazur

Seeking Change Through Texting

July 8th, 2024

 

Earlier this year, I received an invitation to a wedding—a rare and significant event in my life. Apart from my father’s funeral and a nephew’s graduation ceremony, it was the first major family gathering I had ever been invited to attend. At sixty-two, with two brothers and two sisters, all married with many children, I had missed countless milestones over the years—birthdays, weddings, and more. This time, however, I vowed to attend.

 

I flew to Syracuse during the last week of June, filled with anticipation. The wedding was not just an opportunity to reconnect with my niece and her family but also a chance to spend precious time with my mother before returning to Miami. I booked a few extra days, and the excitement of reuniting with loved ones and being part of such a joyous occasion made this trip unforgettable.

About a week before my departure, it dawned on me that being in Syracuse meant I would likely cross paths with many people from the church—a prospect that stirred a mix of emotions. Among them was Bryan Rocine, who had recently made a public appeal from the pulpit, offering his personal cell phone number to anyone he had harmed, inviting them to reach out so he could apologize. This was an opportunity too significant to ignore.

The timing felt right, so prior to leaving for Syracuse, I decided to take him up on his offer. However, instead of calling and talking with him, I chose a more measured approach and initiated a text dialogue. As my fingers hovered over the screen, I couldn’t help but wonder what lay ahead in this conversation. Would it be a step toward healing or just another painful reminder of the past? With a deep breath, I typed my first message, setting in motion a dialogue that would challenge my perceptions and potentially reveal the true nature of his intentions.

From the onset, I harbored deep doubts about whether Bryan Rocine had truly changed. If genuine transformation had taken place, surely the many people he had wronged would have told me. To me, his public announcement felt more like a self-serving gesture—a declaration designed to appease the congregation and suggest that nothing more needed to be done or said.

However, family members and a few others assured me that Bryan had indeed changed and that the church was now committed to caring for those who had been harmed in the past. Reluctantly, I decided to extend the benefit of the doubt and engaged in the written exchange.

Each text message I received was scrutinized; each response I sent was deliberate. The words exchanged between us would reveal whether his proclaimed repentance was genuine or just a facade. Has he truly changed? Read the text dialogue and decide for yourself.

 

The Text Exchange

Dan: Why would a man publicly announce his availability for anyone to contact him? What is the true message here? Is it genuinely for those who may wish to reach out to him, or is it merely a performance for the world to perceive him as accessible and accountable?
If this person sincerely believes he has unjustly harmed others, should he not already know who these individuals are and take the initiative to reach out to them directly?
Imagine a scenario where someone spends thirty-six years meticulously documenting the ways in which he and others have been harmed by this man, compiling these details into a manuscript and placing it before him. Such an effort far exceeds any public declaration of willingness to accept calls from those wronged, ostensibly to discuss and make amends. Yet, this manuscript would be ignored, and any attempt to bring it to light would be vehemently suppressed and attacked.
What does this say about such a person? He has constructed a world that he and others inhabit, a realm he will defend at all costs. He is a consummate salesman, perpetually presenting his pitch to anyone at his doorstep. Until his final days, he will fabricate stories to preserve the comforts he has created for himself.
This is not a man of integrity, honor, or character to be admired. He is someone from whom people need to protect themselves, lest they fall victim to his deceitful machinations.

Bryan: Is this Daniel? What do you prefer to be called? Dan? Danny? Daniel?
Please forgive me for the unnecessary, unhelpful pain I have caused you. I forgive you for the same.
Judging by the caustic and cynical position of your text we may not be able to continue with any communication.

Dan: To seek my forgiveness and, in the same breath, label my message as caustic and cynical, does not reflect the actions of an honest or sincere individual. Have you ever considered that true contrition and criticism cannot coexist in a single plea for forgiveness? True repentance demands humility and self-reflection, not judgment and reproach.

Dan: But perhaps, upon further reflection, I am mistaken, and your message is sincere. I have been wrong before, many times in fact. If you genuinely seek my forgiveness, it is a request I am bound by duty and conscience to consider. Please tell me, what is it that you believe you have done to me for which you seek forgiveness? Without this clarity, I find myself without even the option to offer forgiveness. How can I say I forgive you without knowing what I am forgiving you for?

Dan: Bryan, I ask you once more: what is it you wish me to forgive you for? What have you done that you regret, that you acknowledge has caused me harm? Are you sorry for rejecting my pleas for help when I sought your assistance in reaching out to my father years ago, unlike other pastors who showed compassion and tried to help? Are you sorry for judging me and labeling me as a rebellious son without ever having a conversation with me about my life and my relationship with my father, relying solely on the biased views of others? Are you sorry for ignoring my request to visit me and understand my perspective through the lens of those who have known me for decades here in Miami? What is it that you want my forgiveness for? Is it any of this?

How can you know what has caused me harm if you do not ask or tell me what you seek forgiveness for? What have you done? Why wouldn’t you first acknowledge your wrongdoing? What meaning could “forgiving you” possibly have without knowing what for? Maybe you don’t feel there’s anything wrong with the actions I’ve mentioned that harmed me. If this is the case, and I simply say “I forgive you,” would that not be entirely incoherent and meaningless? If you never tell me what you’ve done wrong, how can I believe that it is forgiveness you seek and not something else entirely?

In our past correspondence, I asked you many questions, most of which you refused to answer, choosing instead to disparage me. No other pastor in Syracuse treated me with the same distance and disdain as you did, claiming to know my thoughts, even going so far as to say “God is my arch enemy.” How is it that so many years have passed, and you have yet to address these wrongs? Are you different today? Do you now acknowledge that your behavior was wrong and regret it? How am I to know? Why is this so difficult for you?

Dan: What do you truly know of me, of my life? You know I was committed to a mental institution, but do you understand the circumstances? Instead of judging me as a reprobate and a God-hater, did you ever think to ask me? Did you ever consider that you might have been contributing to the damage inflicted upon me? Maybe you have, and this is what you’re asking my forgiveness for. How can you not understand how meaningless it is to ask for forgiveness without stating what for? You are a pastor, someone who is supposed to study these matters for the benefit of others.

Take this as criticism if you must, but I simply do not understand your behavior. As a leader, with many eyes on you, the responsibility of your position is immense. Should you not put every fiber of your being into getting these things right? And as a leader, should you not focus more on your own actions rather than defending your wrongdoings by pointing out that others have wronged you too?

Where is the wisdom I longed to see for decades that would have had me by my father’s side, a member of your congregation? Your position demands a higher standard, one that requires introspection and accountability. It is time to reflect on your actions and genuinely seek to understand the impact they have had on others, especially those who looked to you for guidance and support.

Dan: When the police came to my door, claiming my father told them I was building a bomb to blow up the church, did you have a hand in that? Is it too much to ask for you to tell me the truth? This occurred around the same time you wrote to me, insisting our correspondence was confidential while subtly threatening me not to disclose your comments to others. The people I know here, when told of such events, say you all are nuts, that you all are crazy people and I need to stay away from you. Why don’t you provide evidence to the contrary? What do you know about the police searching my home for a bomb or the FBI investigating me? When I’ve asked you for similar information before, your response was simply to attack my character. Should I expect differently today? Or have you changed? Will you be forthcoming? Is any of this what you seek my forgiveness for?

Dan: When the police came to my door, claiming my father told them I was building a bomb to blow up the church, did you have a hand in that? Is it too much to ask for you to tell me the truth? This occurred around the same time you wrote to me, insisting our correspondence was confidential while subtly threatening me not to disclose your comments to others. The people I know here, when told of such events, say you all are nuts, that you all are crazy people and I need to stay away from you. Why don’t you provide evidence to the contrary? What do you know about the police searching my home for a bomb or the FBI investigating me? When I’ve asked you for similar information before, your response was simply to attack my character. Should I expect differently today? Or have you changed? Will you be forthcoming? Is any of this what you seek my forgiveness for?

Dan: This matter transcends forgiveness and enters the realm of accountability, embodying the true essence of taking responsibility for past wrongs. As a pastor, it is your duty to address the injustices perpetrated against me from the very pulpit of your church. Perhaps you are unaware, but to this day, I remain estranged from my brother David. I was deeply upset when he stood before the congregation, misrepresenting my thoughts and praising you all, claiming I saw the “good” in you and how “perfect” the memorial service was. I never said such things. In fact, I had confided in him about the immense challenge it was for me to stay calm in an environment that severely tested my well-being.
I had hoped that the days of being disparaged and lied about from the pulpit, as my father did, had ended with his passing. Yet, when I expressed my distress to my brother, he showed no inclination to make amends. If you have truly changed, you should understand that seeking forgiveness is not enough. The matter must be addressed and corrected. The congregation needs to hear the truth about the past—about who I am, who I was, and what I did not say or do.
I have already taken steps to set the record straight in my book, where I speak the truth for anyone who cares to seek it. If you are a true seeker of truth, you will understand the importance of these matters and will ensure that the falsehoods spoken about me from your pulpit are corrected from that same pulpit. Yet, at this very moment, I have no idea if these are the matters you regret your participation in. As all this transpired, you stood there, hands folded by my father’s side. Who are you today, Mr. Rocine? Are you the same man who stood silent, or have you become someone who will confront the past and embrace the truth?

Dan: So tell me that I am wrong, that my belief in your lack of integrity has been misplaced. Assure me that doing what is right is indeed paramount to you, even when it doesn’t align with your desired outcome. Tell me that my understanding of your true nature, of who you really are, has been mistaken all these years. Proclaim that you believe in justice and truth above all, and that personal wants and desires play no part in your decision-making process, especially in matters that affect those harmed by the organization you are part of. Show me that you stand for what is right, regardless of the cost. Demonstrate to me, and to everyone who doubts, that you embody the principles you preach, and that truth and justice guide your every action.

Dan: The narrative of my experience with your church has been purposefully contorted and contrived to suit the needs of others. You have all misunderstood me profoundly. It is for these reasons that I published my book. Additionally, I have created a short video—a slide presentation—that you and others in your congregation need to see. It is something you should willingly present to your group to set the record straight.

Dan: https://youtube.com/watch?v=n2Coj-eOYaw

Dan: Your integrity is under scrutiny. Having confessed to wrongdoing, you must face the consequences with courage, not retreat. Your role as a leader, an influencer, and a pastor demands accountability and unwavering transparency.

Bryan: Thanks for your explanation. Somethings are becoming clear to me.
Please forgive me for not being a greater help to you when you were a teen when I was trying to be a good influence on the teens in the church. Shame on me I gave up on you. Please forgive me for the harshness of my emails to you some years ago.
Here’s what I am realizing. You don’t have an accurate picture of what is going on in our church community regarding yourself. No one I know sicked the FBI on you. I had nothing to do with it. Id be shocked to learn your dad did. He was very quiet about you.
There has been next to zero public statements about you. I recall very brief and uncritical, 40 years ago like, “My son asked me to stay home from church for him. I couldn’t do that. “. (I summarize.)
I have never that I remember preached a single word about you knowingly or intentionally. The church is very quiet and respectful about what we consider Mazur family business. We don’t gossip about you. We hardly think about you.
I hardly ever talk about you to anyone. And hardly ever for more than a sentence . Most of any talk is in prayer. You are not a bigger topic or a preoccupation around here than anyone else.
My texts take a long time to come back to you because I have many other people to prioritize ahead of you.

Dan: This message feels like the beginning of a meaningful dialogue, and for that, I am deeply grateful. As I reflect on the past, I harbor no resentment for any perceived lack of encouragement during my teenage years. My greater concern lies with the events that have transpired in the years that followed.
I’m unsure if you’ve read my book, but it contains crucial information that sheds light on my comments. For instance, shortly after I moved to South Florida, the FBI came knocking on my door. This was a direct consequence of my father’s actions—something you might not have known. Considering everything else that has transpired, this shouldn’t come as a shock, though it’s possible you were unaware.
You mentioned there have been “zero” public statements about me. This is not true. I have received copies of several statements embedded in the sermons of the organization you now head. I’ll share one of them with you here; it’s an audio recording from the pulpit. I would appreciate your thoughts on this message made within your church and whether you believe such a comment should be addressed or corrected. My father has claimed, and even insisted to me and others, that he has not discouraged my siblings or anyone from having a relationship with me. This is an outright lie, one of many manipulations I can prove have existed, and as a person in your position, you have a responsibility to address it. This is one of many circumstances occurring long after my teenage years that I ask you to respond to and address.
You claim not to gossip about me, yet you have written extremely harsh criticisms of my character. From where your conclusions about me originate, I can only speculate. These comments, a few of which I have already addressed in this thread, are very damaging and have compounded other false claims and attacks that have caused significant harm, not just to me, but to others as well. It’s these criticisms of yours, not anything from my teenage years, that I want you to address.
I also want to remind you of the time I invited you to Miami to meet people who know me, rather than relying on the damaging comments of others. Instead of accepting or even responding to my sincere offer, you accused me of being obsessed with you and justifying myself to you. These examples of your behavior are what concern me and deserve a proper response.
There is much more to discuss, but addressing these points would be a good start.

Dan: https://drive.datadupe.com/f/1e2a84c315aa4fe6ad8d/

Dan: You need to understand that the entire narrative surrounding my departure from my family and your church has been a gross manipulation and complete mischaracterization of the truth. I urge you to watch the video clip I sent you, if you haven’t already. It accurately represents what truly happened, unlike the false narrative constructed for you and the church members to believe. This narrative was crafted to fit a misleading image of who I am and how I should be perceived.

Dan: This false narrative endures, continuing to fuel the rift between me and family members, especially my brother David. It has become an impenetrable wall that must be torn down. Only by confronting and dismantling these misconceptions can healing begin and genuine reconciliation be found.

Dan: Before I continue with my workday, I’d like to share one more point for you to ponder. It concerns the contrasting perspectives I hold of you and my father. Throughout our communications, I have never questioned your honesty. I’ve never caught you in a lie or observed any intentional deceit. Perhaps you truly believed, at least at the time, the negative sentiments you expressed about me. I cannot say with certainty whether you are a dishonest person, but dishonesty is not something I have witnessed from you.

However, it’s crucial to recognize that my father possessed a deeply troubling characteristic. He was not just dishonest; he engaged in deceit far beyond simple dishonesty. Simply stated, as painful as it is to say this about one’s own father, my dad was not an honest man. He was capable of crafting and spreading the most untruthful stories to achieve his desires. Whether you have discovered or acknowledged this yet, you eventually need to contemplate this harsh reality. If you are ever to move forward in situations like mine and others, with a godly purpose aligned with the teachings of the Bible, you will eventually need to cross this bridge. You will need to face this most uncomfortable truth, as I have, about who my father truly was.

Did he believe in many good things? Was he a great contributor to the well-being of others? Certainly, he was. However, this characteristic you may identify as a sin had dire consequences. No matter how much good anyone does, it is vital to address such deficiencies to prevent further damaging consequences. In the end, it is not merely our actions that define us, but our willingness to confront the uncomfortable truths about those we love and ourselves. Only then can we strive for true integrity and redemption.

Dan: It’s 12:45 AM. I usually wake at 2 AM every weekday morning to begin my day. But not this morning. What you wrote to me yesterday, about my father telling you I asked him to stay home from church for me, has kept me up all night, unable to sleep. So, as I have often done when dwelling on poignant moments of my past, I turn to my pen.
The moment I read your message, I knew exactly which day you were referring to. Your message from my father—whether you recall his words clearly, partially, or exactly as he said them—brought back memories I cannot shake. I remember that day vividly, as it was during a formative time in my youth. I was going through a crisis, the specifics of which blur among many, but the significance of that moment stands out starkly.
The crisis was as severe as when I needed to speak with my father about being molested by someone in my younger years who I had just learned was coming to town and would be visiting my family. Despite my distress and the gravity of the situation, my father refused to even be late for church to address my crisis. That response shifted my concern from the crisis itself to a more devastating, ongoing issue between me and my father.
No, I did not ask my father to forfeit his presence at church that day to be with me. My request was simply for him to understand the gravity of my situation and the worth of a moment with me, even if it meant risking being late for one of his meetings. Whether he misrepresented that day to you, or if you are absolutely certain he told you I expected him to forfeit his church attendance, then he certainly did. And if he did, that encapsulates the problem between us.

Dan: During my youth, any significant event in my life was often altered by my father to fit a narrative that suited his interests. For instance, in my book, I recounted a story about a fight I got into with a school kid. The entire incident was my doing, my fault, and I needed to be admonished and to learn a lesson about the wrong I did. However, when I approached my father to explain what happened, despite my extreme efforts to be truthful and represent what truly happened, he would not hear it. He turned the story entirely around and made it part of his sermon the following Friday evening, about how Christians need to defend themselves when attacked by sinners.
This is just one anecdote representing my lifelong struggle to communicate with a father who not only would not hear me but was willing to present me to others in an untruthful way that suited his narrative. He molded every significant moment to fit his interests, to serve the purpose of his church and other ambitions, many of which I believed then, and today are very good, but not worthy of the many deceptive means I observed his accomplishments achieved by.
What truly concerns me, what haunts me in the quiet hours of the night, is not merely the events themselves but the chasm they created between us. A chasm built on misrepresentation and a lack of understanding that has left me, even decades later, grappling with the lifetime of silence between us that he enforced and ensured until his dying days.

Dan: I wanted to let you know that my aunt will be at the church tomorrow. I feel very strongly that a warm hello from you would be very well received. Rest assured, I will ensure there are no concerns about any difficulties from me.

Bryan: Nice of you to give a “heads up.” Thanks.

Dan: Good morning, Bryan,
I want to express my heartfelt gratitude for making my aunt feel welcomed at the church. Despite her initial reservations, she deeply appreciated attending the Sunday morning service. A particularly significant moment for her was reconnecting with an old acquaintance and coworker from General Motors. Despite a past rift, he approached her with open arms, genuinely happy to see her. This was just one of several similar positive experiences she encountered.
For me, this experience illuminated the inherent goodness in others. Your son, Isaiah, especially stood out. I had the pleasure of spending time with him at the wedding and after the Sunday sermon. Isaiah was approachable and engaging, and our conversation left me eager to learn more about him and your family.
Interestingly, Isaiah knew very little about me, including the fact that I have published a book. This lack of awareness was surprising, especially considering I discovered yesterday that even my own niece, Natalie, was unaware of it. It seems that those I spoke with were not particularly interested in learning more about me, which was unexpected given my deep curiosity about them. This realization was both informative and eye-opening.
During our conversation, Isaiah asked why I am not a Christian. Given our shared background and exposure to the Living Word Church, I found it difficult to provide a concise answer in the moment. Interestingly, it was my nephew, Davie, a close friend of Isaiah, who told him everything he knew about me. The only thing he knew was simply that I am an atheist. I found it intriguing that this was what came to mind when asked about who I was. Additionally, my nephew had confided in me that intimate relationships with non-Christians, people like me, were not possible for him. This revelation was profoundly impactful and is crucial to understanding my perspective.
In retrospect, I believe a chapter from my book encapsulates my reasons for not being involved in your church and why my beliefs have diverged from those in attendance. This chapter delves into the theme of family and the potential for positive relationships between people of differing beliefs. It explores how these relationships, once full of promise, were shattered by stringent dogma that, in my view, needed to be more flexible to keep good people together instead of apart. This rigid adherence to unyielding doctrines, I believe, undermines the possibility of unity and mutual respect among individuals with diverse perspectives. The chapter seeks to convey the profound impact of these dynamics on my own journey and relationships.
If Isaiah is interested in knowing more about me and my perspective, could you kindly provide him with the following link to this chapter?
https://drive.datadupe.com/f/6d9983bda451435781ab/
Once again, thank you for greeting my aunt and making her feel welcome on Sunday morning. Your kindness did not go unnoticed.

Dan: Your sermon last Sunday morning, titled “The Power of Repentance,” left a profound impact on me. You began by referencing Mark, where John the Baptist preached repentance for the forgiveness of sins, drawing the entire Judean countryside and the people of Jerusalem to confess their sins. You emphasized the transformative power of repentance, asserting that it can alter the course of one’s life. Repentance, you stressed, offers a pathway to forgiveness, severing the chains of wickedness that bind us to our past and preventing it from dragging us into the depths of despair.
You explained that repentance involves both intellect and emotion, compelling us to feel genuine sorrow for our wrongdoings. This change in attitude moves us away from fault-finding and toward self-reflection. Quoting Jeremiah, you lamented how few people genuinely repent, asking, “What have I done?” You urged us to ask the Lord this crucial question, and to follow it with, “What shall I do?”—a significant step in the process of repentance.
After the sermon, my mother, aunt, Jody, and I dined at The Waterfront Tavern in Central Square, where the sermon became the central topic of our conversation. The emphasis on forgiveness resonated deeply with me, sparking hope for a meaningful dialogue with you. I listened intently to your sermon and engaged in discussion with my family and friend, Jody.
I shared with Jody how my ears perked up when you spoke of repentance and forgiveness. Your repeated call to ask, “What have I done?” and “What shall I do?” filled me with excitement and hope. It struck me that just as we seek forgiveness from God through repentance, we must also seek forgiveness from those we have wronged. This vital aspect seemed missing from the sermon, and I hoped it might appear in your concluding remarks.
When I expressed this to Jody, she responded, “Well, the service is only so long. Brother Bryan can’t fit everything into one sermon.” To which I replied, “Do you mean the message I just shared with you—something you clearly understand—delivered in less than sixty seconds?”
My visit with my family lasted an entire week, from one Wednesday to the next. Though the invitation to my niece’s wedding required fewer days, I chose to stay longer to spend precious time with my aging mother. This extended visit allowed for many moments of deep conversation between us, often centering around the current and past activities of our family and the church, some of which I have already shared with you.
Throughout this past week, my mother has increasingly acknowledged the past wrongdoings of her church, my father, and herself. She has continually sought my forgiveness for her role in these events—transgressions she has confessed and for which I have long forgiven her. Our conversations have revealed her growing understanding of my beliefs, and she often says, “Danny, you’re not an atheist; I just don’t believe it.” To this, I respond, “Mom, today I am; tomorrow I may be something else.”
She insists, “But you believe in God. You must, I can tell.” I reply, “Well, if He exists, where can I find Him—in your church?” This gives her pause, as she has come to realize the extent of the wrongs, deceit, and harmful behavior that have made it impossible for people like me, who have strived to live according to Christian principles, to remain connected not only to the church but also to their own family.
During my visit, I had the opportunity to visit Mary Sorrendino on Monday. As you’re aware, Mary once attended the Living Word Church and even taught Sunday School there for about ten years. I recently read her book, Misery to Ministry, where she recounts a traumatic event she and her sister experienced when they first attended the church.
Mary’s sister was about to deliver a child, but tragically, the baby was stillborn. Not knowing how to handle the situation, Mary called our home to speak with my father, her pastor. My mother answered the phone and told Mary that the church does not handle such matters and that there was nothing they could do. There was no offer of sympathy or mention that the church would pray for her sister and her family.
Furthermore, due to the church’s doctrine against secular counsel, no external support was sought. Mary’s sister, adhering to the church’s teachings, refrained from seeking the necessary help. Consequently, they endured greater and unnecessary suffering, difficulties that could have been mitigated with proper counsel and support.
Considering everything thus far, I intend to send another message to my mother. If she is truly interested in my belief in God, she has the capacity to demonstrate a quality that, if He exists, He would surely possess. I have often stated that while I do not yet know where God is, I do know where He is not.
I would ask my mother to show me that, unlike so much I’ve seen in the past, a member of the Living Word Church has the courage to do what the Bible says and embody the principles you preach. The truth of Mary’s claims and the accuracy of her memories—do these even matter? Do we need a witness? The fact is, Mary and her sister were hurt.
What if my mother found the courage to invite Mary and her sister over for coffee? What if she allowed them to express their pain without judgment? My God, the woman lost her child. Is it too late? Is it ever too late to show love, care, and concern for another? To acknowledge where we have fallen short and ask for forgiveness?
This gesture could be a profound act of healing. It would demonstrate the true essence of repentance and forgiveness, offering a tangible example of living out the principles of compassion and empathy. It would show that faith is not just about belief but about action—about reaching out to those we have wronged and seeking to make amends. This is the God I would believe in, a God reflected in the courageous acts of those who follow Him.
Am I saying this would make me believe in God or in His involvement with your church? Maybe it would, maybe it wouldn’t. But it is in such places, through such actions, that I would continue to observe closely. I am searching, and if I found a place aligned with what I know to be right, I would want to delve deeper, eager to discover what I do not yet know. I recognize truth when I see it, and I am drawn to it.
As I’ve said, I will convey this message to my mother. However, as her pastor, your involvement could significantly impact Mary and her sister and my mother. If you spoke with my mother and facilitated a meeting with Mary and her sister, the gesture would be powerful.
As you’ve preached, the sin that does not lead to death is the sin that is quickly repented of. I will send you a copy of the passage from Mary’s book detailing what happened. It is my hope that you act swiftly upon this opportunity. If not, I will be the one providing my mother and others the chance to benefit from this experience.
This moment could be a testament to the true spirit of repentance and forgiveness, demonstrating that faith is not just about words but about actions. It could bring healing and reconciliation, showing that the church is a place where love and understanding prevail. This is the God I could believe in—a God reflected in the courageous and compassionate acts of His followers.

Dan: From “Misery To Ministry”
Bill was coming out to church with Toni.  Back in 1977, on Christmas day, Toni had miscarried in the 16th week.  I was in England at the time.  Toni’s baby would have been 7 months younger than my second son, Jason.  It was hard for her, but Toni was taught not to count her chickens before they hatched.  So, she just tried to think that it was not a baby and she shouldn’t be upset.
Toni got pregnant shortly after she accepted Christ, and I was excited!  I thought, How awesome this is! Eric was one year old and would be two in April; Toni’s baby was due in June 1982.  We always thought that we would have our children at the same time or very close in age.  Although Jason and Toni’s other baby would have been the same age, I was glad that Eric would be just two years older than this baby.
I planned for the baby shower to be when Toni was in her eighth month.  That way if she delivered early the baby should be okay.  After having Chuckie six weeks early and Jason ten weeks early, I knew how fragile life is.
We had a surprise baby shower at my home and invited a lot of family members.  Everyone was so excited because they felt terrible when Toni lost that other baby in the fourth month in 1977.  Bill’s daughter Tami was there and was also excited, because she was going to have a little brother or sister.  Tami was 7.5 years old; she was a sensitive little girl.
Tami said to me, “I hope what happened that last time won’t happen again.”  I said, “Sweetheart, that won’t happen.  She’s almost due….”  I went over to the trailer where Toni and Bill lived.  Bill had put the crib together, and Toni was very excited.  But I thought I heard God say that no baby would sleep in this crib in this house. 
About two weeks later I was sitting at the dinner table and I had this overwhelming sense that something was wrong with my sister.  I said to my husband, “Oh my God!  I feel like something is wrong, like Toni is sick or dying !!!!
Chuck knew how I had had dreams in the past that came true or feelings that had meaning.  I immediately called Toni; she was taking a nap, and she was very tired.  I asked how the baby was, and she said “Good, but it was weird that the baby kicked really hard earlier.”  I said I was just checking on her because I was worried.  “Don’t worry, I’m okay, just tired.”
The next day Toni said, “Mary, the baby’s not moving anymore.”
“Well, Toni, there’s not much room for the baby.”
A few days later Toni had an appointment with her OB/GYN, Dr. Ziver Huner.  When he went to listen for the heartbeat, there was silence.  He immediately asked if she was alone.  She said no, Bill had come with her.  Then Dr. Huner asked him to come in, and they talked and set up an ultrasound to be done immediately.  Toni went for the test and was very confused.  As they went down the hall Bill knew what was going on, but Toni was not getting it.  She asked Bill, “What are they going to do now to get the heartbeat back?” She said she felt the Lord say that everything would be okay.
She returned to the office and Dr. Huner told her and Bill that their baby had died.  Toni was unable to process the information…. He offered counseling.  Toni said no, she thought that it was WRONG to meet with a counselor because the church we attended spoke against it, and she wanted to do the right thing. At this church counseling was not recommended, and anyone who did see a counselor was somehow in error.
I was home when Toni and Bill left Dr. Huner’s office.  Bill knew that he had to bring Toni to see me.  I looked out and saw them getting out of the car, and I KNEW!  God said, “I am in control.”  I was devastated!!!!  Toni was devastated!!!!
I called the pastor’s house.  It was a Friday, and being Catholic I wondered what they would do to help us.  I was recently baptized and Toni was attending regularly.  The preacher’s wife got on the phone.  I was very upset and asked if she knew my sister.  She said yes, she had seen her in church.  I went on and told her that her baby died and that we would need a pastor or something like that for the funeral arrangements.  I asked, “What do you do in these situations?”  She said, “Nothing.  We do nothing.”  She never said she was sorry – just “nothing,” like it was no big deal!  She didn’t even say they would pray.
I thought, Oh…this church is much different than what I was brought up in.  I felt hurt by the lack of care and concern for a family in the church that was experiencing a devastating situation.  Although this did not make sense, I thought that God had sent me to this church and we were just expected to lean on God.  After their response I thought that I was wrong to expect anything from them. I did not trust my feelings or thoughts, so I assumed that I was wrong for contacting them. 
Finally, on June 1, 1982 Toni gave birth to her stillborn daughter, Therea Ann Wood.  Toni never went to counseling and therefore was not prepared for the birth.  She pretended that she was not going through this.  Although she did do some grieving, she never held Theresa.  The nurses at Community General Hospital were great.  Bill did look at their daughter and said she just looked like she was asleep.  She had dark hair, and later Toni found out from the nurse that she had really long eyelashes and she weighed 1 lb. 7 oz.  Later in the day Toni asked if she could see the baby now and maybe hold her… but it was too late.  If she had counseling she would have been prepared for this and would have known that she could have held the baby.
Toni was traumatized by the event.  She worked at a retail store on Erie Boulevard, and many customers asked her if she had a boy or girl. Tini told them she had a little girl but she was stillborn.  The customers and her co-workers were wonderful and compassionate to my sister. It was very difficult working in public with so many individuals having contact with Toni.

Bryan: Hi Dan. Thank you for listening so intently to the message of such an imperfect messenger as I. Your recall is almost perfect.
1. Right or wrong, I did intentionally include the subject of our human relationships and person-to-person sin. I am sure you recall something like this: “Don’t take this message as being for someone on the other side of the aisle. THEY should repent.” I’ll explain. I thought the Lord wanted us to focus on first things first — our relationship with Him. But of course you may be right. Shoulda included our person-to-person relationships as part of an inseparable package. I often operate under the principle “less is more,” sometimes to the detriment of the bigger picture.
2. I don’t know how to satisfy you when it comes to the Toni S story. What your mom did and said is coming to us as hearsay. I know your mom very well, and I’m not about to doubt or investigate her tender and compassionate nature based on hearsay.
3. Re your challenge, that you may believe in God when you find people who live sincerely in obedience to the teaching of Jesus… don’t throw down that gauntlet. Judge God on His own merit not on mine or anyone else’s. I fall pathetically short. But He sent His Son to pay the price of our sins. What He did for us is enough to inspire undying faith and loyalty.

Dan: Thank you for responding, Bryan. I understand your emphasis on personalizing the message, and I recall your mention of it that Sunday morning. However, my concern remains. It is crucial to openly communicate what we need forgiveness for. This has been my message from the beginning and remains so now.
You mentioned, “I don’t know how to satisfy you.” But it’s not about satisfying me; it’s about recognizing the validity of my points, which align with what God requires of us. The truth of the story isn’t as important as the moral implications. When people come to you claiming they’ve been wronged, do you ask for a witness? Isn’t it more important to show compassion and concern, regardless of evidence?
Consider the story of Mary and her sister’s loss. Whether a child truly died or the accuracy of the occurrence isn’t the point; the real issue is how we respond with empathy and support. This experience should teach us to be more compassionate and to encourage others to seek appropriate counseling, whether secular or otherwise. Regardless, as I’ve mentioned, should you not be willing to participate in this opportunity to help my mother, Mary, her sister, and others, I will certainly be the one to do so.

Dan: I awoke this morning with an eerie feeling, one that evokes memories of my conversations with my late father.  As I write to you, I am reminded of the profound dialogues we shared. My father, like you, held the position of pastor, and he too struggled with the weight of his responsibilities.
Despite my repeated requests, I still do not know if you have read my book. Your reluctance to engage in open and honest dialogue with me has left me feeling unheard and misunderstood. When I inquired about presenting my offer to your son, your response was absent. When I tried to discuss the disparaging comments you made about me years ago, you closed the door to any meaningful conversation. Your initial response to my first message indicated that a dialogue was unlikely due to my perceived caustic and cynical position. However, it is clear to anyone that I have approached you with sincerity and a genuine desire for understanding.
This situation reminds me of my early mornings with my father. While my siblings were at school and my mother was teaching kindergarten at the Academy, my father would approach me, seeking my opinion on handling sin within the church—an elder molesting his children, members engaging in fornication, and such. Despite offering my thoughts, he often chose to keep such matters hidden to maintain the church’s facade. Yet, these were not the most disturbing conversations; rather, it was those where I implored him to show more compassion and understanding.
Had my father opened his heart and relinquished his need for control, my mother would have been spared decades of separation from loved ones, including her sister and parents. His insistence on isolation and stringent actions to maintain separation from those he deemed capable of diminishing his control of others caused immense damage. Today, my mother’s parents are gone, and she can never amend that loss. However, she has found solace in a renewed relationship with her sister and others, including me, the very person my father stripped away from her in his efforts to control and isolate.
Now, I see the same pattern repeating with you. Your door is closed, and you resist any effort to reunite loving people. Outsiders often describe your church as one devoid of love. This perception stems from the lack of compassion, empathy, wisdom, and understanding. Like my father, who saw himself as a simple small-town preacher, you project yourself as a humble servant of God. Yet, your actions suggest otherwise.
As a pastor, it is your duty, as mandated by the scriptures, to facilitate the coming together of people who have faced life’s challenges. What is required of you, as it was of my father, is simple: step aside and allow the spirit to move.
Please, Pastor Bryan, consider opening your heart and embracing a path of compassion and empathy. Let us work together to reunite those who have been separated, to heal wounds, and to foster a community grounded in love and understanding.

Bryan: I have accountability to a group of experienced men and women of faith. I am honest with them about my failings and keep them appraised of my actions and communications. They have the power to censure and/or fire me. They decide how to take care of me. I would not want it any other way. You simply are not in a position to be part of that group.
I literally don’t have time, energy, or interest in giving you that kind of relationship with me. In fact, it would be inappropriate and impossible. Cmon, Dan, you should understand that.
Since you are so desperate to know about me and your book, I have not read it. I don’t plan to read it. I really don’t relish telling you this.
 

Dan: Hi Bryan,

Fortunately, you won’t need to fabricate stories to distance yourself from me. I live far away, and you may find solace in knowing that I will no longer seek answers or further discussion from you. Yet, before we part ways, I wish to leave you with a final reflection on the matter that began this thread: forgiveness.

Your recent comments about my supposed obsession with you, echoing past remarks for which you sought forgiveness, and your ongoing reluctance to address my concerns, hint at a lack of understanding or compassion. Despite this, should it matter to you, I forgive you for both the past and present wounds inflicted by your words.

Know this: while empathy and understanding seem absent in your responses, I harbor no resentment or ill feelings toward you. After this message, you will no longer be troubled by my outreach. Despite your disregard for my concerns, my door will always remain open, just as it is with my brother David. Should you ever wish to discuss something that weighs on your mind, I will not judge you for your past or present actions. I will gladly listen, offer my full attention, and do my best to support you in any sincere matter you bring forth.

Life is hard, and we all make mistakes. I have made many and will make many more. But when I recognize them, I strive to address them with compassion, empathy, and understanding, especially when they affect others. Good luck to you, Bryan, and my best wishes for your future endeavors.

The Beginning of COR

I grew up in Liverpool, a serene suburb of Syracuse, cradled in the heart of central New York State. Tucked away roughly 250 miles northwest of the bustling streets of New York City, it offered a quiet contrast. My mother, whose maiden name was Fannie Fortino, was immersed from birth in the vibrant culture of a large Italian family. Although she had just one sibling, my Aunt Maryjane, she was intricately connected to a sprawling network of cousins.

 

Life in our family was modest and unpretentious, with little emphasis on professional aspirations. On a farm along Bear Road, where my mother and her relatives were raised, school often took a back seat to the relentless demands of farm work—planting, harvesting, and tending to vegetables became their daily rhythm. Academic pursuits were secondary; neither my grandparents, my mother, nor her sister completed high school. My grandfather poured his life’s sweat into the nearby steel mill from which he eventually retired, carrying only the weight of his memories. My grandmother, meanwhile, spent her working years on the monotonous line at the Resnick Pocketbook Factory. She never did learn to drive, and I distinctly remember the anticipation in the factory parking lot, as my mother and I waited to catch sight of her at the end of each workday, signaled by the piercing sound of the five o’clock whistle.

 

 

In stark contrast to the gentle rhythms of farm life in Liverpool, my father’s early years in New Jersey were marked by shadows and struggles. As the eldest of five siblings and the only child from his mother’s previous relationship, he was raised by a stepfather. Though raised Catholic, his family life lacked the spiritual daily expressions that were integral to my mother’s upbringing. His childhood memories were not filled with warmth and camaraderie but were instead overshadowed by a pervasive sense of alienation and despair.

 

Fate intervened when my parents, still in their teens, met at my grandfather’s camp on Oneida Lake near Syracuse—a serendipitous encounter, given that my father’s aunt owned the neighboring camp. The sparks between them ignited swiftly, leading to a whirlwind courtship and marriage. My mother was just seventeen, and my father, twenty, when they exchanged vows. Following the wedding, my mother relocated to New Jersey to join my father, who was making a living as a commercial artist. Yet, the absence of her close-knit family circle soon weighed heavily on her. The yearning for the familiar comfort of home and the strong bonds she had left behind in Syracuse grew unbearable. Financial constraints initially held them back, but eventually, the pull of family grew too strong to resist, and they moved into the welcoming arms of my mother’s parents’ home.

 

My father was a man driven by relentless ambition and an entrepreneurial spirit. Starting his career journey with modest beginnings, he went door-to-door, capturing and selling family portraits. This grassroots endeavor eventually secured him a stable position as an artist at a local agency. It wasn’t long before his hard work enabled us to buy our own home, marking the first of many milestones in his professional life. Yet, his entrepreneurial spirit was far from satisfied; he soon ventured into starting his own business.

 

During my childhood, the rhythms of our family life were marked by frequent visits with family. My weekdays and weekends were filled with trips to my grandparents’ house and time spent with a multitude of cousins, as well as serene Sundays at the Presbyterian church perched atop the city’s nearby hill. While my mother, sister, and I cherished these familial bonds, my father divided his time between work, his outdoor hobbies like hunting and fishing, and quiet moments spent with the newspaper.

 

 

1970 was a pivotal year that brought significant changes to our lives. I was nine when we moved from our cozy one-story home in Bridgeport to a more spacious four-bedroom, two-story residence in Liverpool. At that time, my Aunt Maryjane had ventured to Houston, Texas, to start a new life. Coincidentally, my father was also scheduled to be in Houston, competing in a national rifle shooting contest against both military and civilian sharpshooters. During this trip, Aunt Maryjane invited him to a church meeting. Despite initial reservations, he agreed to attend and experienced a profound spiritual awakening that drastically altered the course of his life. Upon returning from Texas, he made the life-changing decision to leave his burgeoning business and dedicate himself to preaching. Our family home in Syracuse became a bustling center of fellowship, which gradually expanded to other homes and eventually to a dilapidated church in the town of Euclid. As the congregation grew, we moved from one church building to another, marking new chapters in an expanding community outreach.

 

As the church’s influence widened, so too did the strictness of its doctrines. What began as subtle shifts in ideology soon crystalized into a rigid framework that distinctly isolated us from those not in sync with our new way of life. By the time my senior year of high school rolled around, I found myself increasingly at odds with the rigid beliefs that had come to define our family’s existence. With a heavy heart, I voiced my disinterest in the church, bracing for the possibility of being cast out from my home. Surprisingly, however, I was allowed to stay.

 

From 1979 to 1981, I lived somewhat apart from the day-to-day activities of my family. On Sundays, as my family bustled in preparation for church, bickering over unplugged hair dryers and prolonged bathroom use, I sought refuge under a pillow, trying to muffle the sounds of their arguments. Throughout the week, I unwillingly became a confidant to my father, who expressed his growing frustrations with church matters, discussing congregants’ fornication, gossip, and other assorted sins. This period was also marked by an escalating breakdown in our community ties, culminating in 1981 when my own grandparents were excommunicated.

 

My refusal to sever ties with them precipitated the inevitable: I was instructed to leave my home. This was a harrowing moment, filled with deep pain, and I detailed the emotional ordeal in a heartfelt letter to my brother David, an excerpt of which is included in my book.

 

 

For the subsequent six years, my attempts to bridge the gap with my family were met with cold rejection. This deep-seated sense of abandonment not only fueled a profound identity crisis but also propelled me toward a psychological precipice. By 1987, at the tender age of 25, this crisis culminated in my involuntary commitment to Hutching Psychiatric Center. This poignant moment in my life marks the opening of my book, beginning with its first chapter, ‘Off at Grandma’s.’ Seated on my grandparents’ sofa, enveloped in a sea of memories, I delve into the formative days of my father’s church, the uncompromising doctrines we were expected to uphold, and the series of harrowing events that led to my hospitalization. Here, I lay bare the emotional and spiritual tumult that shaped these years, setting the stage for a journey of introspection and healing.

 

 

This memoir began as a therapeutic exercise—a means to navigate my past and seek reconnection with my estranged family. Over the span of thirty-six years, these pages have transformed from personal reflections into a profound exploration of familial bonds broken and the enduring quest for authenticity amidst the pressures of conformity. Through chronicling my attempts to mend the rift with my father and understanding the stark divergences within our beliefs, I have unearthed the universal truth that diversity and genuine self-expression are not just vital for individual integrity but are also the cornerstones of resilient relationships.

 

My narrative aims not only to offer a window into my own soul-searching journey but also to resonate with anyone grappling with similar familial estrangements or identity crises. It is my deepest hope that this book will not only serve as a cautionary tale but also inspire others to cherish their bonds with loved ones, to embrace the rich tapestry of human differences, and to find the courage to stand firm in their truths. May these reflections guide you towards reconciliation and peace, not by erasing differences, but by celebrating them as the very essence of our shared humanity.

 

 

Unveiling the Core of Christianity and the Spirit of Its Followers

In contemplating what it means to identify oneself as a Christian, one embarks on a profound exploration of faith, belief, and the essence of spirituality. This reflection is not intended as a sweeping judgment of the Christian community at large, for such a diverse and multifaceted group defies simple characterization. Instead, it is a personal observation, shaped by years of introspective thought and a life journey deeply intertwined with a Christian upbringing, from childhood through the complex weave of experiences among those professing to be followers of Christ.


To distill the essence of Christian belief is to navigate a vast ocean of doctrine, tradition, and personal conviction. However, from my vantage point, shaped by early exposure to a community self-identified with Christian values, a paradox emerges. It is a realization, perhaps unsettling, that the core values often attributed to the heart of Christianity—God’s love, and the virtues of honesty, bravery, empathy, and selflessness—often seemed conspicuously absent in the lived experiences within my church community. These virtues, though lauded in sermons and embedded in the teachings of Christ, were met with indifference, or even disdain, by some who professed them loudest.


Raised in an environment where self-interest and the pursuit of comfort seemed to eclipse a genuine engagement with the divine, I observed a dissonance between the preached and the practiced. The church, ostensibly a sanctuary for spiritual growth and communal support, sometimes felt more akin to a social club, its members drawn together not by a shared journey towards spiritual enlightenment or sacrifice but by the allure of comfort and familiarity.


And yet, amid this dissonance, my perspective found its own footing. It was not in the echoing halls of that church or in the superficial embrace of community that I encountered what might be called the Divine, but rather in the quiet, steadfast pursuit of the very virtues overlooked by others. In the teachings attributed to Christ, I discovered a call to transcend the ordinary, to live a life anchored not in the pursuit of personal comfort but in the embodiment of love, truth, and sacrifice. It is here, in the sincere endeavor to live out these virtues, that I find the truest expression of what it means to be Christian.


In this journey, the real essence of faith emerges not from the ostentatious displays of religiosity or the comfort-seeking tendencies of a congregation but from an individual’s quiet commitment to embodying the virtues that Christ himself exemplified. It is a path less trodden, marked by challenges and often solitude, yet it is here that one finds a profound connection to what could be considered divine—a beacon of light guiding us towards a deeper understanding of what it truly means to live a life of faith. This, then, is the essence of Christianity as I have come to understand it: a call to live a life of profound love, truth, and sacrifice, transcending the superficial to touch the very heart of what is universally humane.






    About the Title

    COR Values describes a phenomenon where individuals choose “comfort over reality,” leading to the creation of self-serving, distorted truths. The term “COR” encapsulates the tendency of people to shape narratives and beliefs more aligned with their personal desires than with objective reality. Through telling my life story, this book examines how people, driven by the COR mindset, manipulate information, rely on emotional persuasion, and even fabricate facts to shape a reality that serves their own agendas, overlooking the necessity for integrity and objectivity.

    The central allure of being COR lies in its comforting reassurance by affirming pre-existing beliefs or offering oversimplified solutions to complex issues, often based on falsehoods or half-truths. This, however, comes at a significant cost. It promotes a culture of evasion, where confronting uncomfortable truths and acknowledging the consequences of one’s actions is avoided. This avoidance fosters a societal environment where the rigorous demands of truth and reality are shunned.

    The impact of being COR is profound and far reaching. Individuals influenced by these values may find themselves unwittingly supporting harmful ideologies, participating in destructive behaviors, or isolating others based on distorted beliefs. The repercussions are not just personal, involving emotional distress and financial loss, but also societal, leading to division, conflict, and the deterioration of democratic principles. As these fabricated realities take hold, they undermine the bedrock of trust and critical thinking, essential for a healthy society.

    About the Book

    COR Values is a true and evocative story that captures the intricate dynamics of faith, family, and personal convictions. At the heart of this narrative is a pastor, deeply rooted in his beliefs of sin and salvation, who faces a profound dilemma when his wife’s sister decides to marry someone he considers a sinner. This situation challenges the very core of his teachings, which advocate for separation from sinners to maintain spiritual purity.

    The story takes a compelling turn as the pastor, in his commitment to familial unity, reluctantly promises to make peace with this new family member. The real twist, however, comes when the pastor unexpectedly develops a deep and authentic bond with his new brother-in-law, the very person he had labeled a sinner. This unexpected relationship not only brings to light the pastor’s internal struggles but also highlights the complexities and contradictions of his long-held beliefs.

    COR Values delves into the tension between doctrinal rigidity and the realities of human relationships. It presents a nuanced look at how life’s encounters can challenge and reshape our perspectives, compelling us to reconcile our professed values with our real-life experiences, and underscoring the repercussions of ignoring life’s imperative calls for change. This book is a powerful read for anyone interested in the journey of self-reflection and the challenge of confronting one’s own prejudices. It uncovers the beauty of forming significant connections in the most unexpected places and the profound, both personal and communal, repercussions of turning away from life’s prompts to evolve from our misjudgments. It’s a story about the transformative power of acceptance and the unpredictable nature of life that can lead us to question and, ultimately, deepen our understanding of our core values.

    The Story and Purpose

    In 1961, I entered the world within the walls of Saint Joseph’s Hospital in Syracuse, New York. My early years unfolded in a modest, single-story dwelling in Bridgeport, a quaint town where community and simplicity intertwined. My father, a New Jersey native, and my mother saw their paths converge following an unexpected encounter at a family camp. Barely adults, with my mother at seventeen and my father at twenty, they embarked on a journey of togetherness, sealing their bond in marriage.

    Their early family life began with a move to New Jersey, where my father worked as a commercial artist. Yet, the pull of familial bonds proved too strong for my mother, leading them back to the familiar embrace of Syracuse, where they nested within the welcoming space of my maternal grandparents’ home. This period of adjustment and growth eventually culminated in the acquisition of our Bridgeport home, marking a new chapter of stability and belonging.

    Life in Bridgeport was a blend of tradition and new beginnings. My mother, steadfast in her faith, continued to nurture us with the values of her Presbyterian upbringing, attending church with me and my older sister, Debbie. My father, however, charted his own course, finding enjoyment in the solitude of hunting or engaging in hobbies that spoke to his independent spirit.

    An entrepreneur at heart, my father co-founded Tri Art Studios, a venture that symbolized both a professional and personal milestone. Our family’s fortunes mirrored this upward trajectory, leading us to a spacious two-story house in Liverpool, complete with the trappings of suburban life. Amidst these developments, my father’s passion for rifle shooting flourished, pitting him against competitors nationwide, from military personnel to civilian sharpshooters.

    During one such competition in Houston, Texas, my father experienced a profound epiphany. Coincidentally, my mother’s sister, Aunt MaryJane, resided in Houston, and it was by her invitation that he attended a local church service. There, a moment of divine clarity struck him as the pastor’s words seemed to pierce the veil of anonymity, speaking directly to his soul. Overwhelmed by this encounter, he was consumed by a newfound conviction of God’s presence and purpose for his life, a revelation that propelled him into a fervent pursuit of his spiritual calling.

    After my father returned from Houston, discussions about God became a daily fixture in our household. Our home began hosting meetings that initially included a large contingent of cousins. I vividly recall being questioned while observing from the staircase, “Can’t you see your father has changed? Don’t you notice the glow on his face?” This query lingered in my mind as I watched my mother play the organ in the family room, peering through the ornate metal bars of the stairway railing.

    As time progressed, my father decided to leave his business behind. The religious gatherings, once confined to our living room, moved to a dilapidated church in the town of Euclid, with my father taking on the role of pastor. Under his guidance, the congregation expanded, necessitating moves to progressively larger facilities until finding its current home on Court Street Road in Syracuse.

    Aunt MaryJane, mirroring my mother’s yearning for familial closeness, returned to Syracuse and became an integral part of my father’s church. She, along with my grandparents, regularly attended the four weekly services and immersed herself in the community through friendships and numerous activities.

    The teachings at the church were stringent and constantly evolving, with a strong emphasis on adherence to its principles. One such expectation was the concept of being “equally yoked,” particularly in romantic relationships, discouraging associations with those deemed sinners. This policy limited relationship prospects to within our own congregation, branding other churches as lukewarm or misaligned with God’s expectations. However, my aunt found love outside these confines, at her workplace at General Motors, where she met a man whose character she deeply admired and eventually married.

    The pervasive discrimination and judgment against those with differing beliefs, whether religious or otherwise, motivated me to share my reflections and spurred the publication of my book. Throughout my life, I’ve witnessed firsthand the consequences of attempts to exert total control over loved ones and their environments, which restricts access to the world’s diverse perspectives on identity, origins, and potential purposes. My writing, the result of thousands of hours of work over 36 years, embodies a deep, relentless drive to illuminate and challenge the roots of division and prejudice. This imposition on individuals’ inherent rights to individuality and authenticity, arising from discrimination, fractures families and friendships, infiltrating various spheres under the guise of dogma. It’s a pattern that has become deeply integrated into my family’s religious practices, a cycle that urgently needs to be broken. My work aims to expose these divisive forces for what they truly are, advocating for an end to the dogmatism that segregates and isolates.

    More on COR

    In my hands, I visualize two spheres. Held in my right hand is the sphere of truth, symbolizing the reality underlying everything. In my left hand rests another sphere, representing our desires to satisfy both our physical and psychological needs. I perceive every decision as a balancing act between the influences of these two spheres.

    When evaluating individuals, it is their character that captures my attention. Character is the essence that sets individuals apart from one another. I seek signs of integrity, courage, honesty, loyalty, and respectfulness – hallmarks of a person’s ethical and moral fortitude. The predominance of these traits in an individual often indicates that their decisions are predominantly guided by the ‘right’ sphere, the realm of truth. Conversely, a deficiency in these qualities is likely to lead to decisions heavily influenced by the ‘left’ sphere, dedicated to physical and emotional indulgence. Those who recognize this pattern should not find it astonishing that a deficiency in character results in self-serving actions that veer away from the truth.

    It is a well-acknowledged fact across all domains of life, including religion, business, and politics, that prejudice and discrimination stem from such poor character. Indeed, these are selfish actions born from the craving for comfort, both physical and emotional, at the cost of forsaking reality and truth. The greater one’s emphasis on comfort, the ‘left’ sphere, the more one distances oneself from ‘truth’, the ‘right’ sphere.

    It is these individuals I have deemed to be ‘COR’, as they show favor of ‘comfort over reality’.